Engine choices

Started by BlownMGB-V8, August 20, 2011, 06:06:45 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

BlownMGB-V8

We had a long 5 page discussion over on V8Buick about engine choices for the MGB swap so I cut and pasted what amounts to a summary below, dealing with the more common V8 engine choices. We didn't address V6 engines or straight 4's etc so it doesn't really apply to those, but what I found interesting after a long drawn out discussion of the various merits  of these engines,  particularly the LS and the SBF, is how well the Buick 300 is matched to the car.

JB

The LS may have the greatest power potential, fuel economy, and driveability, but it lacks bottom end torque and is outrageously difficult and expensive to install, so that swap is way out there. After all, just because you can put an Allison or Merlin in your '56 Chevy is no reason to do it. (and that swap has been done) Moving down the spectrum we'd come to the Buicks with power adders. Easy swap and the best bottom end torque but beyond the reach of most owners. Plus way way beyond anything that has ever been done so far (Tom's BBC drag car excepted), at a power to weight ratio approaching 2. Then the SBF, more costly and difficult because of interference with the frame and crossmember, less bottom end torque but good horsepower up to 600. Very likely the N/A Buick can be right there with it at about the same cost once the TA heads are available here. (cost of heads offset by cost of frame mods) But the SBB can be done for significantly less than the SBF if horsepower goals are more reasonable. Now we are entering the realm where most swaps live. Under 300 hp is the top of the bell curve, and that means the Buick 300, mild 302's, BOPR, and GM V6. Then dropping off the bottom of the curve are the blower installations for the stock 4 banger and high winding 4 cylinder builds. The Buick V6 would currently be here too, just because very few have been done and those that have were low powered N/A builds. Very good torque though. In reality, the SBF only inhabits a very specific part of the spectrum. It is not competitive below 300hp because of cost. It is not competitive above 600hp because of block strength. A 300hp range seems like a lot but again the bell curve comes into play and is centered pretty closely around the 375hp factory crate engine, so the practical range is a lot closer to 325-400hp.

So there you have the basic distribution. The real sleeper in this whole mess is the 300 Buick. Competitive with the 302, it is very likely the cheapest swap that can be done, with the most bang for the buck. It's cheaper because a late model car has only one issue with it and that is hood clearance. It's cheaper because it uses a $25 bellhousing instead of a $200 one and a $30 flywheel instead of a $200 one. It's cheaper because the headers and motor mounts for this swap have been around longer than any others. It's cheaper because there are no new problems to be solved and a well trodden path to follow. Finally, and far from least, it has as much or more performance potential as any other reasonable candidate. It can be easily stroked to 350ci and this has been done and proven. The block is good to 1000hp with power adders. And as we speak TA is selling their first run of heads for it. Work with the 350 has shown that a roller cam can be made to fit it. Crank trigger ignitions are in use. Rover EFI can be used with a set of simple spacer plates, which are available. Roller rockers have long been available. Modern neoprene crank seals are commonplace. Engine management is a phone call away, in the flavor of your choice. What's left to turn this into a thoroughly modern engine? The proper selection of pistons, rings and rods? Not really a problem. Oh, and although the SBB community sort of looks down at the '64 alloy heads because they do not flow nearly as well as the later iron heads, they beat out anything and everything in the 215/Rover (BOPR) community short of aftermarket and those engines (BOPR) can easily top 250hp, so the alloy 300 heads are an excellent low cost light weight choice.

Speaking of weight, the BOPR shaves approx. 30 lbs off the stock vehicle weight. The '64 300 adds back about 60 lbs. And an extra 30 on the front end of the car will not even be detectable. But the extra power and torque sure will be.

AL WULF

Jim,

I have a rebuildable '64 Buick 300 with the aluminum heads and  four barrel intake.  I did manage to get a bellhousing for $25,00, but have not been able to find a inexpensive flywheel.  The flex plate that came with the engine is 13.42" OD, 160 teeth with a 12-14 pitch.  I think to make the flywheel ring gear compatable with my starter motor I would need a manual tranmission  flywheel with the same OD and teeth count as the flex plate.  I know that Poston makes a flywheel but I think it costs more than
$30.00. So I assume that there must be another GM engine that uses a flywheel that will work.   I am also interested in the source for the spacers to fit a Rover EFI manifold, and neoprene crank seals.  Seems like fitting a valley cover under the Rover manifold could be a bit of a challenge.  

I would have used the Buick 300, except that I got a good deal on a Rover Hotwire set up which bolted onto the Buick 215 that I was using.  Two years ago I replaced the 215 with a Rover 3.9, which seals a lot  better on both ends of the crankshaft than the 215.  

Thanks in advance.

Al

BlownMGB-V8

Al, I think the 300, 340, and 350 all used the same flywheel and all were externally balanced and used the same flange pattern and bellhousing. Mike Moore or Jim Stewart should know the specifics. I'm hoping for someone to tell me if the balance is the same but I suspect that it is.

There is an Australian company that makes the spacers. I don't recall at the moment who they are but I bet Dellow or TRS would know.

The tray is a fairly easy part to make. Two 45 degree bends, some scribe lines and some trimming. I think I made mine out of 1/4" aluminum stock but it could be 1/8" or thinner and do just fine. Once you locate the 4 corner bolt holes just lay a gasket on it and the rest is fairly easy. The guys who make the spacers may sell the tray too.

TA Performance carries the crank seals but they are available from other sources. The front seal is the same one the V6 uses and the rear IIRC is a 460 Ford. When Rover upgraded their gaskets it really made a difference but you can do the same thing with "Right Stuff" sealant. It is especially good for gluing down the tray.

JB

BlownMGB-V8

Al, one of the Buick guys says he's using the 350 flywheel on the 300 with no problems. They both have the pocket for balancing in the same place. The 300 wheel has a circle of holes around the outside for inserting pins for fine balancing, the 350 is drilled.

JB