Needle roller conversion for MG. B steering

Started by Wilcat1@sky.com, May 02, 2014, 02:55:51 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Wilcat1@sky.com

Hello All

First mail from me to you

My problem relates to the purchase of the recently available needle roller kits for the MG B  steering, normally only available  via the MGOC in a converted and refurbished  king pin c/w a surcharge on the return of the old top trunion.

The conversion set of rollers etc came from SC parts, unfortunately no instructions were forthcoming. You get a steel cup/roller cage/and two steel washers for each side. Not having started the task yet, I think it might be possible to fit the 'cup' into the trunion first or last  !

Can anyone advise re the fitting sequence of these parts, looking at the system it seems as though the lighter of the two steel washers should fit up into the trunion, then the roller cage cage and finally the heavier of the two washers,  this heavier washer would rest on the top of the stub axle, the thinking is that any shims that might be necessary  could be added  above the top washer. Lubrication would be via the MG's exiting top grease nipple on the stub axle.

I have two  V8 conversions ( both Rover engines)' and the intention is to fit both cars with the above, . I would add that the roller bearings appear to be German manufacture  and came direct to me in  Northern Ireland .

Any feedback re the fitting sequence  of the parts, and if possible the benefit that are experienced would be appreciated.

Wilcat1@sky.com

further to my previous mail on the subject.  SC have mailed me to state that the machined 'Cup' faces up and it's base  bears on the top of the stub axle, effectively this would produce a reservoir to contain the grease and should  also prevent  road dirt getting into the bearing surface.

Still looking  for  experiences that users of these roller bearings can relate. -  in other words is it worth the effort/time/expense  to replace the original  tried and trusted MG system.

Hate the heavy steering!  cannot justify the £1250 cost of power steering, the lady of the house would not be amused.


Best wishes to all

ex-tyke

William, here's my take on your 'heavy' steering problem - replacing original steering column bearings with needle bearings isn't going to reduce steering effort - at best they may extend the period before steering shaft play is noticeable.
If you are not using excessively wide tires, there's more than likely a fundamental problem with a steering component (steering rack, kingpins, etc)....a 'notchy' feeling in the steering (between lock-to-lock) is steering shaft to steering column misalignment (at the u-joint}
 I'd start by ensuring all steering components are within spec and properly lubricated and if I were to spend some money, a pair of caster reduction wedges would be a better bet for reducing steering effort.

mgb260

Graham, He's talking about the kingpin bushings. I know Speedway Motors sells them for old Ford and Chevy straight axle kingpins.  I have thought about trying them. You can reduce caster also. Another thing is wheel offset for less scrub.

ex-tyke

QuoteHe's talking about the kingpin bushings...
Ok, Jim, thanks for clarification....!  
...but I'm still sticking with my original reply that there must be some other fundamental issue with the steering.components/maintenance/geometry.

Moderator

Welcome to BritishV8, William!


I don't know anything about the roller conversion mod... but I share Graham's instinct. For a quick-and-easy reality check, I'd put the car on jack stands and make sure the steering goes lock-to-lock without friction or binding. If the steering rack hasn't been lubed in this century, doing so might help a lot.
1971 MGB GT V8
Buick 215 w/ Rover heads, custom EFI & crank-fired ignition.
Custom front and rear coilover suspensions.

BlownMGB-V8

I gave this some thought. The weight of the car is indeed supported from the top kingpin washer so unless it is kept in a constant state of lubrication it will add to steering effort somewhat and a roller thrust bearing here will help reduce steering effort. Keeping the dirt out will be the issue as they are not fitted with a seal. You can probably get the bearing and hardened seats (washers) from your local bearing distributor much more cheaply though.

I also agree that steering effort should not normally be high but opinions vary as to what high is. Wheel offset has much to do with steering effort.

Jim

MGBV8

As does the diameter of the steering wheel.

I'm holding out for ball joints.  ;)
Carl

Dan B

This is a somewhat popular upgrade on a TR7, installing needle bearings on the upper strut mount.  Some people say it makes no difference, or very little, while others swear by it.

DiDueColpi

As everyone said, the wheel and tire combination along with steering wheel diameter will have a profound effect on steering feel and effort.
A smaller steering wheel or wider tire with a bigger offset will increase steering effort.
And feedback to the steering wheel will become unacceptable.
As well, lubrication is critical.
 Use a good quality moly or graphpite enhanced high pressure grease.
The steering rack has a huge potential to increase steering effort. It is designed with an internal rubbing block that controls the pinion to rack clearance. When run dry, this system can cause significant drag.  
A near stock setup in good condition will steer easily when lubricated well.
So here are my thoughts.
Once you've been through the rest of the steering system. And it is deemed to be in good shape.
Then have a look at the king pin assembly.
The needle bearing conversion for the top thrust washer makes sense. But it would need to be of very good quality to endure the full weight of the car.
I would not consider a needle bearing conversion to the king pin bushings though.
On the surface it seems to be a great idea.
The problem is with the large side loads and limited movement that these bushings are subjected to.
Brinelling of the kingpin would happen very quickly and lead to a very notchy steering.
Bushings, in good shape, with their lubrication slots intact are your best bet.
If the steering is still too heavy after all that. Then I would consider an electric conversion.
The prices are dropping and the packaging is hard to beat.

Cheers
Fred

Moderator

I think someone on this forum previously advised that all current aftermarket MGB racks (from Moss) use the "rubber bumper" gear ratio rather than the quicker/earlier "chrome bumper" ratio. If so, fitting a new rack to a chrome bumper MGB might be a relatively easy way to decrease steering effort somewhat.
1971 MGB GT V8
Buick 215 w/ Rover heads, custom EFI & crank-fired ignition.
Custom front and rear coilover suspensions.

mgb260

Curtis, the later RB would be easier to steer than the CB quicker ratio. I think the RB is approximately  3.5 turns, while the CB is 2.5 turns.

MGBV8

I now understand why I never could relate to the heavy steering remarks.  My MG is a '79 model.  ;)
Carl

BlownMGB-V8

Does make a difference. The earlier cars are a bit quicker and more sensitive of course... ;-)

Jim

MGBV8

Too quick maybe, when that 16.5" steering wheel gets replaced with something a good bit smaller like a 14".
Carl

mgb260


MustangSix

Needle bearing kingpin conversions have been used for many, many years on early Fords (1928-1948).  Those, combined with a Torrington bearing between the axle and kingpin thrust surfaces significantly lower steering effort.  

Except for the added fiddly nature of installing bearings vs. inserting and reaming bushings, they work well and last as long or longer than the original bushings.

I have them on my deuce roadster; if the cost isn't an obstacle, I wouldn't hesitate to use them in an MG when the time comes to rebuild the kingpins.

mgb260

Jack, Yeah, I've seen them in Speedway Motors catalog for Ford and Chevy kingpins on straight axles.

BlownMGB-V8

So how do those work? Just insert a caged needle bearing in place of the bushing? Use the new kingpin as the inner race? Is the bushing bore used as the outer race or does that have to be machined out for the outer race? Or are the kingpins also turned down for a hardened inner race?

I suppose if you were going to go that far with it there might not be that much more effort in fitting another thrust bearing to the top as well.

Jim

mgb260


BlownMGB-V8

I have some old arms stashed away. Some time when things slack up a bit I'll pull them out and look up some bearing numbers and see if anything matches up.

Jim

Wilcat1@sky.com

Hello all

We seem to be  discussing two separate issues - the king pin bushes that are pressed into the  steering hub through which the king pin operates when the steering is moved, the second issue and the one I am interested in is the  thrust bearing located in the top steering trunion

The trunion thrust bearing  effectively carries the weight of the car, and with the assistance of the steering hub permits the wheels to steer the vehicle.

The roller bearing are manufactured to replace the flat bronze bush in the top steering trunion, they come with two hardened steel washers  that  provides the operating surface on both sides of the roller bearing.

My query is to establish the value of this system in reducing the amount of effort in steering the car. - RB MGB,s have very heavy steering


Have we a member who has fitted these roller bearings and can indicate the success or failure  re the steering effort

MustangSix

No experience with an MGB, but as I mentioned, I have them on the Deuce in addition to the roller bearings on the kingpin.  It's a torrington thrust bearing that fits between the axle and spindle on the Ford to allow it to pivot easier.  It's the same idea as the MG bearing.  Picture below.

They do reduce steering effort over a plain bushing a little, but they certainly won't be like power steering, if that's what your after.  

http://static.speedwaymotors.com/RS/SR/Alternative/91032352~1_L.jpg

Wilcat1@sky.com

Hello Jack

You are on target,  the rollers in web page above are the items I seek advise on re their application  on my MGB.  It's not a big job to fit them(' about a mornings work). Conversely if  reports are negative re their application they will just stay n the box.