Did a compression test on my stroked Olds 215, not good. #4 cylinder at 50 lbs.

Started by Gswest236, April 24, 2025, 09:43:55 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

mgb260

Scott, when you cleaned out the lifters did you push down with a pushrod to check plunger travel. If assembled upside down internally they would act like solids.

BlownMGB-V8

I've seen coil bind break the ends off rocker shafts. Most likely that's your issue. One way to check it is to slip a piece of cardboard between the coils of the spring and crank the engine over by hand. The spring should not be trying to cut the cardboard in half. You need a bare minimum of .030" at full lift before the coils stack up and a little more doesn't hurt. Also check the valve seals to see if they are being stamped. If it's enough to break a rocker shaft there should be permanent damage if the clearance is inadequate. It's not likely to be an oil problem, and it's unlikely the cam or lifters are damaged. These heads have a shorter spring stack than some others so this sort of thing can happen if you don't pay close attention. Just because some builders can get away with .700 lift does not mean you can. What is your valve lift? Stock was around .4 and when you get to .5 you need to be careful.

Jim

mgb260

Jim, He's using the same ChevyZ28 springs that Jon is. The Crower 50233 cam has around .500 lift. One rocker is broke, not the shaft. The spring installed height is 1.65 instead of the common 1.7 with those springs due to the shorter Rover valves. .050 lash caps were used to correct the geometry.

mgb260

Scott's valve springs were supposedly good for .550 lift. The guides were cut down for Viton seals. Coil bind is 1.16. Plus .050 for the shorter installed height.
The math doesn't add up. At 1.7 installed there is only .540 and at 1.65 there is only .490 So valve spring coil bind is the problem! Ebay advertised these as good for .550 lift, only good for .500:
 
https://www.ebay.com/itm/353712244161

mgb260

The machine shop should have cut the spring seats .060 deeper. They should have tested for coil bind with his cam specs. The Ebay springs are good for .500 lift, not .550 as advertised.

mgb260

Scott's cam specs:

https://crower.com/printcamcard/?part_num=50233&x=0&y=0

I bet the exhaust pushrods are bent the worst.

mgb260

Machine shop specs for Scott's valve heights:

Even worse coil bind numbers! They must have assumed lower lift cam, but they had his cam and they SHOULD have checked the specs.  They SHOULD have  machined the spring seats deeper. I'd call them and explain the issue and they should make it right at no cost. Those springs should have 1.72 installed height ideally for .500 lift to prevent coil bind. .030 safety factor.

mgb260


Gswest236

Thanks for the input guys! Firstly, when I took the lifters apart to clean, I did them individually so as not to get mixed up. so, I don't think I did 16 of them backwards. Took them apart cleaned, reassembled them. Today I took each pushrod out one at a time and checked for straightness. Of the 16, 14 are bent. Cylinder 2 intake was not bent, Cylinder 8 exhaust was not bent. The worst 4 were #6 exhaust, #4 intake, #2 exhaust, #3 exhaust. Those were so bad no roll test was necessary. The others were less obvious until I rolled them across my welding table. So, The cam is probably toast right? Should I pull the cam without taking the motor out to check? What's insane to me is the motor ran and idled after advancing timing a bit. Jons Specialty seemed to be knowledgeable, and he did modify the heads for the new larger Valves. Was he supposed to modify the spring perches as well?
I appreciate the help guys. I'm not shocked that I have an issue, kind of expected something would be off. What's important to me is to get it right. The heads have to come out but do I need to pull the motor is the question.

mgb260

Scott, Just pull the intake and heads.I bet the cam is fine. Once you get the intake off you will see the cam and lifters. Don't take anything apart that is unnecessary. He had your cam to check the cam bearing fit. He, or one of his workers did not check the lift needed. The Rover valves are shorter than the Olds valves, so he should have cut the spring seats deeper to allow for .500 lift and proper spring height. I'd call him Monday. If a reputable business he will make it right.  Have you checked the oil pump relief spring?

Gswest236

Thanks, I'll call Jon Monday. I'm assuming we can't see if he machined the area for the springs by these pics. Are his numbers (thanks for posting the pic) telling you he didn't account for the shorter valve stems?

Gswest236

I haven't pulled the oil pump relief spring yet, but will tomorrow. Then I'll take the head and intake off.

mgb260

Scott, did the math on posts above. Installed height minus coil bind. Then subtract .030 for safety.


mgb260

Scott, Maybe someone at the machine shop used Rover cam and spring specs because they used Rover valves?

BlownMGB-V8

Please don't get in too big of a hurry to take things back apart, it might not require as much as you think.

Specifically, your cam and lifters should be fine. Bearings are fine. Oil pressure is a little high. Your coil bind problem probably can be resolved by just changing the valve springs. Try to avoid cutting the seats and only do that if you can't get the right springs, there's little enough metal there as it is. You can change the springs without pulling the heads off.

Springs are available in such a wide variety that I'd be astounded if there isn't one with acceptable pressure and rate that can be installed at your height and have a considerably lower coil bind height than the ones you are using. You might have to buy more expensive ones with better wire and maybe even an oval cross section but they are out there.

Jim