Coil Over Bushing Failure

Started by restorejag, October 03, 2013, 07:44:56 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

tzorzo

I have just installed Moss coil Overs and after reading above comments begining to wonder wether the cost and effort are worth it. if you guys are on average getting 500 highway miles from a set of bushes there is a major problem in manufacture and I would think  both GAZ and Moss have a case to answer in selling sub standard components, that by the way are of a safty nature.
Has anyone taken GAZ and Moss to task on this issue.

mstemp

Tony,

I believe Mike A and myself have both taken Moss to task. Simple answer is change out the bushing if you don't want to do it again at a later date. Maybe we were both just unlucky, maybe Poly is the wrong material. Just be sure to keep an eye on them over the first few 1000 miles.

trewjohn2001

Any updates on this issue?  I´m just about to fit my Moss coilover kit.

Cheers

John

trewjohn2001

Anyone using the same Moss kit in Europe can use PowerFlex PF99-111 - they are 95 shore.  Don't know what the Moss ones supplied are but they feel softer than the powerflex bushes.  Again you need 3 sets - one set you will need to cut up to make a spacer for the bottom shock eye.

Definately something amiss with the Moss Supplied Bushings.  One shock was ok but when I took out the bushing from the other it completely disintegrated. It's more like crumbly wax than Polyurethane.  Kit is maybe 8 months old and never been assembled.
image.jpg

Moderator

I tried to ignore this thread, hoping it wouldn't effect me. I installed the Moss/GAZ shocks shortly before driving to Palestine TX for BritishV8 2012. I drove to Omaha for the 2013 meet, and I've been driving a lot since then... so I guess I probably have at least 7 or 8 thousand miles on the bushings. I'm not getting any front suspension noise and I don't feel any slop in the front suspension with my car on jackstands. I can't see the upper ends at all without taking things apart. The bottom bushings look distorted, but I don't think they've collapsed or crumbled as bad as what's shown in photos above.  

Now, I'm thinking of taking off on a long road trip. (There's going to be a great vintage car race at Watkins Glen.) So, I may try making/installing some nylon bushes in a hurry. Anyone have tips about making/using nylon bushes?  If I need replacement bushings in a hurry, do you think I might find something suitable at NAPA or CarQuest? Rubber maybe? We didn't always have polyurethane options, did we?  Or should I just get in my car and drive? They really don't look THAT bad.
1971 MGB GT V8
Buick 215 w/ Rover heads, custom EFI & crank-fired ignition.
Custom front and rear coilover suspensions.

BlownMGB-V8

Curtis, might I suggest some alternatives to nylon, as it is known to absorb water?

The traditional choice in a more or less inert engineering plastic is Delrin. And that works fine but is quite hard, therefore does not give much isolation, and pretty much requires a lubricant to avoid squeaking. I would characterize it as a "dry" plastic. Probably more suited to competition uses.

I think UHMW (ultra high molecular weight polyethylene) would be about the best choice. It isn't quite as hard as nylon (but close), does not absorb water, has a "soapy" feel and is relatively self lubricating. Commonly used in equipment as bearing surfaces to lessen sliding friction. Generally a good bit harder and more durable than polyurethane, which is highly dependent on the particular additives used. Does not deteriorate with age. Available in standard forms, bar, sheet, rod, etc.

Jim

ex-tyke

QuoteThe bottom bushings look distorted, but I don't think they've collapsed  

Mine too!   ...this is the second driving season for the Moss/GAZ suspension. I've reconciled the fact that I'll be changing out the bushings this Winter probably with the Energy Suspension 99105G bushings.
 Moss clearly has some homework to do to ensure a longer lasting product.

mstemp

Curtis & Graham,

At least you got some miles out of them!
Nylatron, Delrin, Rubber, interested what you guys end up trying. Front inner control arm bushings are the same size for the top, bottom needs the extra set cut to make up the extra width.

classic conversions

Plain rubber bushings do not work on a vertical loading, A arms rubber bushings are loaded sideways and it is minimal.
High performance shocks use Delring bushings and Teflon (different compounds). To effectively use rubber bushings in a shock were the loads are vertical, will not work.

Standard shocks use rubber bushings, this bushings are pressure fit to the shock and it is a different compound. Once the rubber is pressed into the shock it is contracted which makes it harder.

If a rubber bushing is found that fits the shock in questions, then it can be pressed in to the shock with a sleeve to further compress the rubber.

BlownMGB-V8

Stay away from teflon too since it creeps under load and deforms easily and permanently. Glass filled teflon is better but still deforms and is slightly abrasive. Delrin will wear unless lubricated, is the best for holding shape under pressure, but does not absorb side loads well because it is so hard. There is no ideal material for such high loading and the ultimate solution is to replace them regularly. Hence the "Race Only" designation. I'd try UHMW and if that doesn't work go to delrin and live with oiling and the squeaks(maybe). Or switch to heim joints which will still need replacing but at longer intervals.

Jim

Scott Costanzo

Ok, I'll bring this back from the dead in an attempt to get a "final" answer. Has anyone used the Energy Suspension 99105G bushing? If so, what is the verdict?

mgb260

Scott, Mike Stemp did in the first page in this thread. I don't know if Graham has yet.

jjohanski

What is the latest on all of this?  Has Moss changed the busing material in the shocks?  There is an ongoing discussion on the MG Enthusiast sight with a picture of a failed shock bushing but the picture does not show the bushing that Moss or Gaz used in there setup.  The bushing appears to be a Prothane brand and it looks to be too big?  Anyone know?  Thanks for any input.

ex-tyke

I can't speak to any bushing changes made to the Moss product since the early failures...Kelvin would know.
 I can say, that since changing to the Energy Suspensions 99105G bushings, that although they seem to hold up longer, today, they are also showing signs of distortion.
For the record, here's a photo of the early Moss bushings after 2 driving seasons.
Moss bushings (R).jpg

RMO 699F

I really do not know a lot about the poly bushings..but do have some experience with injection molded parts from my years at Chrysler...if during the molding process those parts get "too hot"", they will look ok but start to crumble prematurely..moss needs to do an on site visit to the bushing supplier to review their processes...e.g. if the supplier is using a small percentage of reground/obsolete material in the process to save money parts can and will fail prematurely...if "virgin material" is used the part should to standard...

BlownMGB-V8

One of the properties of plastic parts is that they are "plastic". In other words as an amorphous solid the material can continue to flow from a high pressure area to a low pressure area, the rate being dependent on the pressure. You can see that in Graham's old bushings where they have gotten thicker on one side and thinner on the other. Finding a composition that resists this flow adequately yet is still compliant enough to absorb shock loads and has sufficient ductility in shear is sort of the holy grail of suspension bushings. A hard rubber is fairly good at it but has limits. Polypropylene was once considered the cure all but it really hasn't turned out to be all that and some formulations are better than others. By and large longer lasting has meant stiffer, with Delrin at the upper end of the scale.

In practical terms what this means is that you find the hardest formulation of poly that you can live with and change out the bushings when they approach metal-to-metal contact, or install delrin and live with the squeaks. Maybe install grease zerks. But each time you remove compliance from the suspension you get more harshness. This applies to the tires as well. So the road to good handling might be paved with loose fillings and other bolts and nuts.

It's a highly loaded component. 500+ lbs on each bushing as a constant load and several time that as impact loading. Of course it will take a beating. Just one of the compromises inherent in the coil-over design. It's why they are used primarily for racing or custom applications where they are likely to have more frequent replacement. You'll note, even the stock MGB spring coil sits on a rubber seat IIRC. Well, maybe it doesn't, I'm not sure anymore, but it should.

Jim

jjohanski

I talked with Moss yesterday and according to them the problem was solved in early 2019. I am interested in this because I am going to change to either a Moss unit or the Hoyle unit. It looks like both have had problems. Hoyle uses Autobush when they supply Polybushes. I think this is only for the A arm inner bushes. I am presently waiting for an answer. GAZ supplies the shocks and springs for both units along with the bushings. I do not know what bushings they use. If you go to the Autobush.com website they claim that their bushes only use a compound and grease secured from an American supplier, because of reliability issues. They guarantee there bushes for two years from date of purchase, which is the identical length of time for the GAZ shock unit supplied by Hoyle.
BTW I posted a picture of the current GAZ unit on MG enthusiast web site, so take a look and see if it any different than those supplied with earlier units as per Graham and others.
In summary, I have read somewhere on the internet that GAZ had a fire and that is what caused these problems, but I have not been able to verify that. To my mind, I think that Moss and Hoyle have any problems sovled as of now, but I don't know about longevity. Certainly, any coil over shock bushing should last longer than one or two seasons. They all support the weight of the car. Some are subjected to more load than others--the farther outboard the less the weight or force on the bushing. That is probably why the Hoyle and the Guzman units have less or no problem as apposed to Moss.
There ya go, just my two cents.

BlownMGB-V8

That's why we used solid spherical rod ends on the coil-overs in the MG Roadmaster and my roadster which operate at a 2:1 ratio. I think the Roadmaster has 9 seasons on it now.

Jim

ex-tyke

QuoteBTW I posted a picture of the current GAZ unit on MG enthusiast web site, so take a look and see if it any different than those supplied with earlier units as per Graham...
Here's the shock info that I have on file                  
                          Moss Coilover front suspension #268-208
                          GAZ Part#  GP8-1129
                          MOSS Europe Part#  TMG49025
                          MOSS USA Part#  268-199
Moss-GAZ shock.JPG

jjohanski

Graham,  This looks the same to me as I posted on the other web site.  I did query Moss Europe and got this answer:
Since posting this picture of the Moss Coilover shock unit, I emailed Moss Europe for an explanation of what happened.

 Here is my email:

Comment: Regarding your part no. TMG40750G (and similiar). I notice that you sell a replacement upper and lower bushing kit for this part number. May I ask why? I have read on the internet horror stories of bushing failures in very short times ranging from destruction to the hollowing out from load and consequent distortion of the bushing hole. These claims and your substitute bushing prompts my question. Please let me know what the present status is of these coil over kits. This and some others are presently on backorder--Is these because of bushing failures? Thank you for your help.

And their reply:

Hello James,

For years we have offered alternative bushes as (A) replacement and (B) upgrade.

Problem then occurred in 2009 with Gazzmatic poly bush supplier (Powerflex) as their factory burnt down. Gazzmatic found another supplier (they did not want to use superpro) but their bushes were not as good.

They have been trying out new design bushes over the years using bottom bushes such as fitted to Peugeot expert but these suffered distortion.

They have since used a bottom bush which is as used in their Jag range which has cured the problem,

We cannot build anymore kits at the moment as we are out of stock of 5/16unf bolt.



Regards

Mick Pratt

Technical Support

Moss Europe Ltd

Unit 16, Hampton Farm Business Park.

Bolney Way. Feltham. Middx

TW13 6DB

ex-tyke

QuoteThey have since used a bottom bush which is as used in their Jag range which has cured the problem
Part no?.... kit?.....
At least, the bottom bushes are easier to replace than the tops!

jjohanski

Graham,  
Spot on on the ease of replacing bushings.  Perhaps if you email Moss they will tell you the part no. of the bushing they now  use.  They do have the SuperPro and the part no.s are TMG49025ASPK for the top, and TMG49025BSPK for the bottom.  They are listed on the Moss Europe web site.

ex-tyke

Thanks for the SuperPro info, James. Have sent an inquiry off to Moss UK.

ex-tyke

As a follow up to conversations with Moss (UK), it appears that GAZ has released an updated  shock with a revised bottom eye/loop that precludes using the TMG49025BSPK SuperPro bushing...this part will only service the old shock eye.
 Here's photos of the original shock and bush (right) vs the new design shock and bush.(left)

GAZ shock lower eye design.jpg

GAZ shock lower eye design 2.jpg

jjohanski

I have just acquired the late build Moss Gaz coil over shock kit.  The bushings are indeed different.  Please see the picture for the look of the new lower shock bushing.
20200827_161832-01.jpeg