I saw the photo of the dor of Martyn Harvey's project and he seems to have a different sort of electric window setup. So what's the latest?
Jim
Here is the link to Rob's electric window thread:
http://forum.britishv8.org/read.php?8,2955
He used a unit from some sort of Toyota pick-up if I recall (could be way off on that, just what I seem to recall).
I got the AutoLoc ones (PW5500). The motor can be remoted. Haven't installed them yet; hope to soon. Will let you know how they work out if you're not past this by then!
I thought I'd try this set up from Victoria British. It was quite inexpensive and on sale when I bought it some time last winter.
It is a very easy installation. I hope it's going to be reliable.
Any photos you guys could post would be a big benefit.
Jim
I have the ones from BV. I will dig them out, take several photos for you today Jim, and post.
May be installing mine this week; will take pics if i do.
Janphotowindow09001.jpg
Janphotowindow09002.jpg
Janphotowindow09003.jpg
Janphotowindow09004.jpg
Janphotowindow09005.jpg
Janphotowindow09006.jpg
Janphotowindow09007.jpg
Made in Taiwan---------------------<
Janphotowindow09009.jpg
Janphotowindow09010.jpg
Janphotowindow09012.jpg
Janphotowindow09013.jpg
That's the sort typically referred to as a "Universal" kit by the Hot Rod vendors isn't it Calvin? I read mixed reviews on those when I was researching. Most folks with smaller/lighter windows seemed to think they worked well; folks with heavier/older cars & those with tight cranking regulators had trouble with them. I'll be interested to hear how they work for you.
This one came from British Victoria. I don't know if it will work for the TR6 at this point. It hasn't even seen a door yet. It will be interesting and will let all know how it goes. Probably will make better parts for it it the end, or even go a different route.
Taiwan made Hmmm!
Interesting that y'all are adding weight with this mod.
A local club member plans to do track days at VIR. He welded in a a really tall roll bar & stripped out the door guts. It's amazing how light an MGB door is without the window glass & regulator! Hmmm. :)
Agree on added weight. Just need to make another car for autoX ("dreaming")
I know if I was single and didn't have a wife, my build would be way lighter without all the ceature comforts added, so to even make the build, needed to sell her on the idea first, but had to add what she wanted. Have learned if wife is not happy, no one happy! :-)
The AutoLoc PW5500 I'm bought (yet to install) keeps the glass, but loses the regulator... The replacement track, motor, cable is probably 1/3 the weight of the MG regulator. But, i think the glass is where the real weight is.
QuoteHave learned if wife is not happy, no one happy! :-)
Words of wisdom for all husbands. Know it, learn it, live it!
Rob,
You're right. Hmmm, I don't use my windows much anyway, so maybe the hot ticket would be your lightweight power windows plus lexan. End result, lighter & that window crank handle will be out of my knee's way for good!
When I worked for Volvo Trucks (and "WhiteGMC"), we were building such wide truck cabs that there was no possibility a driver could manually roll down a passenger-side window without standing up and walking over. We always offered two power-window options: you could get a motor on just the far-side window or on both. (On the earlier model trucks you could get either air or electric windows - so actually four options!)
An MGB or a TR6 is so narrow that the usual main reason for power windows is gone, at least for gorilla-armed people like me. This Sprite owner retrofitted MkI (bugeye) doors to his MkII to lose window weight: http://www.britishv8.org/Other/RichardBondy.htm To each their own!
I used a set that I bought from Moss Europe. They work well and have been installed for 5 years now. I cannot remember how much I paid for them, but I do recall that they were an easy installation. The window regulator is now out of my way on the door. I'll post pics soon.
Where about are you electric window guys running the wiring into the door.
The reason I ask is I shaved my door handles and the looms I used (SS Braided door looms) failed very quickly and I am looking for a better idea
Thanks
Bruce
Bruce, anytime you place wiring where it will flex you will have failures. Probably the most reliable contact for power windows and door locks is through a spring loaded contact strip such as then ones sold by Painless Performance. The windows and doors will only work when the doors are closed, but then you shouldn't need to operate them when open anyway. They make a 5 contact strip suitable for a door with electric windows, power locks, and a doom light switch. http://www.painlessperformance.com/webcatalog/largeview.php?SearchField=40025
40025.jpg
By the way, I worked on the AutoLoc PW5500's today... no good. Channel can be cut down to fit with the motor remoted, but there's no place it'll fit... it's too big to fit between the glass & the inner door panel. I'm back to the Moss sissor type regulator as the only good alternative.
Thanks Bill
Looks exactly what I should have .
I have send a letter off to Painless with regards to the contact dimensions in hope it will cover the hole I have already drilled.
Bruce
My last trip to the pick-n-pull I grabbed a pair of electric window mechanisms out of a Mazxa RX8 and have been adapting one of them to my passenger's side door. Been a bit of a struggle but I finally got it to work and I have a bunch of photos I can share with y'all, though there were so many revisions along the way that some details will have to wail until I get the driver's side done. No photos in this post but I'll get them added soon.
Now the Mazda unit is not the ideal, but it is usable. It is cable operated with a fairly typical motor/gearbox reducer unit and the linear motion device is a metal track with a plastic slide that attaches to the window glass with two 6mm screws. This can be fastened to a modified piece of the old mechanism. There are two flex cables joining the track to the gearbox.
The RX7 track is 3" too long The Mazda3 track is an inch or two longer than that and has longer flex cables. A Mazda6 track would be similar, perhaps a bit larger. Any of these could be used, in retrospect the others would allow positioning the motor forward of the window track in the area where the original crank was located. But the track and one cable have to be shortened to 11-3/4" of travel.
The RX7 track has 14-3/4" of travel. To shorten it, the lower clip must be removed from the "T" shaped cutout, 3" cut off of the length of the slide, and a new cutout made in the track. I used the old end and scribed the shape, drilled around it with a 1/8" bit, used a chisel to cut between them and filed off the nubs. Crude but effective. Shorten the opposite cable.
To do that I made a new cable end out of brass. You can use 1/4" brass rod, drill a 1/16" hole in it and then cut it to length. I marked the cable, taped it with masking tape, cut the end off with a zip wheel, slid off the tape, threaded it into the hole and slid it up to the mark. Then silver soldered it, trimmed off the excess and reassembled. Perfect.
Positioning of the track can be tricky. It has two mounting studs, one of which is removed when you shorten it. I made a metal bracket to attach the remaining stud to two of the original mounting slots in the door, allowing the track to pivot. To attach the slide I cut the MG window attachment off the stock mechanism. This has two spring loaded pins on a sliding bar. I welded a reinforcing strip to the center of the bar and then drilled and tapped that to bolt on the slide.
Now, the angle of the slide needs to be pretty close to the angle of the window tracks. It is possible to cock the window and this was where the trouble occurred. I ended up with the new track very slightly angled forward at the top and it has worked for me. If your reinforcing strip is long enough you can have several sets of mounting holes at different angles. Each may require slight variations in your pivot bracket but the sliding bar will allow some movement. Any angle other than the one that matches the window tracks will cause the cables to flex or the motor to move, another instance where the Mazda3 unit may be better suited. I originally came home with Mazda3 tracks but returned them to get the RX7 ones. In retrospect I think that was a mistake as the motor sat right on top of the front window track and there isn't much sheet metal there to bolt it to.
Now the switches are another item entirely. I came home with two passenger side door switches. The motors have 2 leads, you switch them to reverse. Simple enough. Any double pole double throw switch will do that. However, that's not how they wired them. They had a driver's side master. So these switches are more specialized and so far I have not been able to sort out how to make them work with only one switch. It must be possible, I just can't see how.
One side of the switch has 3 contacts. Spring loaded to center of course. The center contact makes with one pole in standard NO fashion. The other contact is the same but also closed when the switch is centered. So one contact is ON-OFF-OFF and the other is OFF-ON-ON.
The other set of contacts is reversed but shares a connection with an adjacent pole, in other words the switch sections have one pole bridged. Between that and the center-ON bit I haven't been able to come up with a circuit that works without shorting out. But it has to be possible right? I mean, you can raise and lower the passenger's side door without touching the other switch so there has to be a way. I just don't know what it is.
Anyway, photos later.
Jim
You guys have probably seen these folks advertising in street rod mags http://www.specialtypowerwindows.com/ but they have them that fit in the early cars and are not terribly expensive.
Dave
Dave, the ones I was able to find said they needed 8" below the window. Clearly you had a different one in mind. Looks like price is around $400?
Here's the RX8 window mechanism, laying on the MGB door, approximately in the location where it will be mounted, though the track is 3" too long.
IMG_0001.JPG
Here you can see the difference in original curvature, and reduced to match the MGB window.
IMG_0006.JPG
Here the end is cut off and the new T shaped cutout drilled. Some chisel and file work and it is ready.
IMG_0009.JPG
This is my pivot bracket. Eventually I welded studs to it once I knew where I wanted them.
IMG_0015.JPG
My outlay so far is $80. I found a diagram that I think explains the switches, both set of contacts are grounded in the center position and power is applied to the unbridged contacts. I should be able to work with that.
Jim
Real sports cars don't even have side windows, much less electric windows. Just when I thought you ditched the sissy shifter, now this....
It's lighter than the mechanical window mechanism. Works better too.
Jim
I like the lighter part. Maybe even swap the glass for Lexan.
If you did that you could dispense with shortening the track if you wanted. Just provide a stop. Save several lbs that way.
Jim
I got the Mazda window switch to work so that's a thing. The red and the green wires to the motor, Green and yellow to + and the other two to - and it works just fine. Minor adjustments to the track for better speed. Need to make a bezel to mount the switch in the door panel and hook up power. On to the other side.
Jim
Finished the job today and here are a few cues:
The track gets shortened 3" to 11-3/4" of travel and then you have to use every bit of it and it has to be trimmed at the bottom to match the bottom of the door and positioned right against it. No extra space. At the top it interferes just a bit with the lock rod but it works. The track has to be accurately parallel with the front window track and fixed at that angle so it doesn't move. This positions it near the rear of the door latch cutout. I cut out the section of the original regulator that engages the slide across the bottom of the glass, trimming the pieces it pivots on to make a pair of round buttons that help when installing it in the slide. A piece of 1/8 x 1/2" flat steel about 8" long tackwelded into the channel between the buttons gives enough thickness to drill and tap to attach the track slide to the window. Position of the first hole is roughly an inch from the end which in combination with the track location sets the raise limit. I mounted the track first then marked the flat, then drilled and tapped for two 6mm screws. This attachment also has to match the track to the angle of the front window channel. I trimmed the door to mount the motor. Used new rocker switches which fit in the original crank handle cutouts with trim pieces and wooden stops glued to the back to prevent rotation.
Mounting the track in a fixed position helps to prevent cocking of the glass when the window raises or lowers Any lack of precision in matching the front angle will cause the track to fight the channels but the bottom slide can compensate by moving.
The end result is quite good. Just like the windows in a brand new Mazda 3. Quick up and even quicker down. Total cost was $100. The weight of each unit is 1 pound less than stock, however the switch, wiring, and slider from the original regulator eats into that by a few ounces. Still, noticeably lighter than stock.
I think there are probably better choices available. I used the RX8 units. The Mazda 3 ones have longer cables and will allow positioning of the motors farther forwards in a dead space and this can be done without cutting the door for motor clearance so those should be better. More has to be trimmed from the track but that does not change the work required to do it. I thought the RX8 ones would work better but they did not. There may be something else that is a better fit, there might not be. Overall, definitely worth doing and the second door was much easier than the first one.
Jim
I don't read instructions.....I just look at the pictures. What? No pics? :)
Nah. I didn't have time to take them on this one. But the good news? I'm to the point where I can drive my car again. That's worth every picture I didn't take.
Jim
A body shop/hot rod shop guy here was going to experiment with some Cobalt rear window motors/cables. It looked like they could work using the existing window tracks. I haven't talked to him lately though.
Will there be a problem with the later MGB doors that have the internal crash beam?
I can reach the passenger window crank while driving so I see no need for electric door windows, but the rear windows in the GT can only be reached by getting out of the car since the set head rests interfere with reaching back while seated. Making these electric is worthwhile to me. I have heard of attempts to use minivan motors for swing out side windows but never a completed installation.
I used to feel the same way about it. But, for a number of years I had trouble with the windows being stiff. Which was also leading to circles in the door cards where the knob dug in. And leaning over and pushing a button is a good bit easier and less distracting. The weight loss is just an excuse. Am I getting lazy? Nah, just getting older. I want to keep driving it after I can't work on it any more. Selfish that way.
Should be no problem with the door beams since it's all on the inside of the window.
Jim
Update to electric window thread, my windows are still working fine and I like them a lot. MX3 donors should be pretty common at the pick-n-pull.
Jim
This looks promising:
https://www.speedwaymotors.com/Universal-Aftermarket-2-Door-Power-Window-Conversion-Kit,112892.html?utm_medium=CSEGoogle&utm_source=CSE&utm_campaign=CSEGOOGLE&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=23022589191&gclid=Cj0KCQiAsNPKBhCqARIsACm01fSVx-Ad1aCbTvn61TKSAZlRECjO4diQJt0m77k5COTCWkMlN4geU90aAuAJEALw_wcB(https://www.speedwaymotors.com/Universal-Aftermarket-2-Door-Power-Window-Conversion-Kit,112892.html?utm_medium=CSEGoogle&utm_source=CSE&utm_campaign=CSEGOOGLE&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=23022589191&gclid=Cj0KCQiAsNPKBhCqARIsACm01fSVx-Ad1aCbTvn61TKSAZlRECjO4diQJt0m77k5COTCWkMlN4geU90aAuAJEALw_wcB)
It depends on the dimension between the rail that connects to the glass and the bottom of that track. I don't recall the exact dimension, but there is only about 2-3" of space between the bottom of the glass and the door shell bottom panel.
It might be a usable option. Rob you are so right, there isn't any room to spare. On the Mazda conversion I used all the room that was available and it was just enough. It meant *accurately* trimming the length of the vertical lift rail, and of course the cable to match. I don't think it's likely to find one that is exactly the right length out of the box unless it's the Moss conversion and of course you won't buy that for one or two hundred.
On the plus side I didn't find shortening the unit that difficult and it does have springs which allow some fudge factor. On my conversion the trickiest part, as I think I described, was in making and positioning the brace that ties the vertical rail to the inner door panel. My design allowed a bit of lateral flex to allow for small misalignment between that rail and the window tracks. It may not be the best design, but it has worked well for 7 years now and hasn't changed so I think I can give it a good recommendation. A little fiddly perhaps but doable with common tools. That "T" shaped cutout in the rail can be done with a Dremel for instance. Welding studs or nuts in place is helpful but not the only answer.
Sorry I didn't have more detailed photos but it's not overly complicated to do and in my opinion well worth it. I have no doubt you guys can figure it out, and maybe post some better pictures.
Jim
I don't understand. I can reach the passenger side window crank with my right hand, driver's side with my left. What are you guys even talking about?