I think I am about 6 weeks away from pulling the original engine and tranny and starting my 5.0 Ford and T5 swap in my 1980 MGB.
I am still struggling a little with clutch "linkage". Is this the way to go for a slave cylinder system?
http://www.novak-adapt.com/catalog/clutch/kit_hcrf.htm
That pull type slave might be a solution - the clutch M/C is 3/4" bore, so you'd need the 3/4" bore slave.
Be advised that the clutch fork length might be problematic with tunnel clearance and interference needs to be checked.
A lot of us use a push type slave with about 3/4" cut off the fork end.
Clutchslave2.jpg
I think the photos in this article do a particularly good job illustrating clearance issues for the MGB/SBF/T5 combination, and how a Nissan truck pull-type slave (like Graham's) helps to solve them: http://www.britishv8.org/MG/MartynHarvey4.htm
Ah yes, I see the difference. Any idea what Nissan Truck that part comes from. It looks like the most compact solution.
Keith,
Here's a typical ebay auction for the Nissan clutch slave...Readily available from Rockauto or any major auto parts store.
http://www.ebay.com/itm/Clutch-Slave-Cylinder-Nissan-Datsun-521-620-720-Truck-/320951135949?pt=Motors_Car_Truck_Parts_Accessories&fits=Make%3ANissan&hash=item4aba2daecd&vxp=mtr
That Nissan setup is a push cylinder, just to avoid confusion (probably obvious). I did something similar, but of course I made it much more complicated and painful than it needed to be. I'm good at that.
Push cylinder does package much tighter than a pull setup.
Graham, Is that your setup? What are you attached to other than the tab below the reverse lamp switch?
Second attachment point is the other tab (hole added of course)......evident from another photo angle.
Clutchslave3.jpg
Very nice. I decided against that slave cylinder because the bleed fitting was on the bottom, but I should have went with it. Much cleaner. My setup works very well, but the bracket is much crazier.
QuoteI decided against that slave cylinder because the bleed fitting was on the bottom...
True...but it actually bleeds very well.
After having done this, I don't see how it can be done without shortening the arm. My attempt!
Paul
100_3079.JPG
That's pretty slick!
My kids, more often than not tell me I'm wrong about everything, so I thought I'd ask. I was told that the actuation rod should be adjusted so the throw out bearing rides against the pressure plate. Is this correct? I had planned to use a return spring like Graham but was told, by the same people, that with the bearing against the plate I didn't need a spring. Being an "Old School" kind of guy I'm a little uncomfortable with that, but as I said, I'm often wrong. What do you think?
Paul
I'm not sure but I believe it's dependant on the bearing you're using. The one I got did say it was designed to be stay in contact with the plate. I'm going off memory, but I belive it said 4-5lbs of pressure. I don't have a way to measure that so I just adjusted mine to be in light contact. 4.5k miles so could prove to be wrong still, but so far seems to be working fine.
QuoteI was told that the actuation rod should be adjusted so the throw out bearing rides against the pressure plate. Is this correct?
The Ford release bearing is of the "constant running" variety and is installed with a 4# pressure against the clutch fingers -( no bearing to diaphragm clearance required)
My return spring is installed just for assurance that the whole linkage remains in contact (but in theory not required)
Great question, and I'm glad to see the answers you guys have offered. My To-Do list has "Decide about return spring for TOB".
Other than wear, I've also seen comments on noise. If it sounds OK, I'll go without one. I used a "Perfection" clutch kit (nothing fancy).
If it was me I'd use Paul's linkage and Graham's bracket for the perfect setup.
The return spring is more of a personal preference thing.
Pretty much every throw out bearing available these days is capable of "constant contact" use.
The deciding factor is your slave cylinder.
Most newer designs have an internal spring in them to force the piston out.
This takes up all of the linkage clearance and gives you a constant contact system.
The advantage is no more clutch adjustments and no pedal free play.
The clutch feels much more direct and with no free play the leverage can be increased slightly for a softer pedal.
The down side is a minor acceleration of clutch finger and throwout bearing wear. As well as wear to the clutch arm from the constant movement.
For slaves without the internal spring your only option is the return spring with an adjustable link for free play.
Setting this type of slave up for 0 clearance is an invitation for disaster.
It's called an interference fit. Because when it goes wrong it interferes with your bank account.
The advantage is longer component life.
The down side is regular clutch adjustments and the loss of movement due to the necessary pedal free play.
That probably just muddied up the water. But you know, I gotta say something.
Cheers
Fred
I have a CNC slave cylinder and have no idea if it has a spring in it or not. I've decided to run a spring and connect it to the cylinder bracket. By the way it has a real rod on it now rather than the bolt.
Paul
IMG_0505.JPG
The CNC slave cylinder does not have an internal spring.
What are the Pro's and Con's of the CNC not having an internal spring considering an external spring is used? Obviously the external spring keeps the return pressure on the rod so the piston can't retract and the rod fall out. I assume the internal spring pushes the piston back as well???
Paul
Internal spring pushes the cylinder out, so it does the opposite of a return spring. It make sure the system doesn't go slack, where the external return spring makes sure the sytem does go slack (if it's adjusted with slack in it).
Just finished taking out an IHTO, and going external on my 300 Buick with GM T5. I used the Nissan 3/4" bore slave with internal spring. Wow! I should have done this years ago. Lighter pedal with way smoother engagement.
Slavecyllinder.jpg
Clutchfork.jpg
Transbracket.jpg
I think I'm hearing it might be a good idea to replace my 7/8" bore non-spring CNC cylinder with something else. I've also thought of changing my -3 AN line to a -4 but I'm not sure it would make that much difference. Opinions please.
Thanks Mike, I'm rather proud of my linkage and throw-out arm; the bracket not so much, though it works ok, it's a bit ugly.
Paul
Paul, Dorman part # CS37498 Rockauto.com for less than $10
Paul,
If you already have the parts, then I see no reason to change them.
The spring type slaves exist only to remove the need to adjust the clutch from time to time.
This lowers warranty claims for the OEMs dramatically at a very small cost per unit increase.
If a cable or mechanical self adjusting mechanism could be made reliably and cheaply. We would never have seen a hydraulic clutch.
Put a return spring on your current setup. And check the pedal free play every once in a while. Just like the old time mechanical linkages that we (most of us) are all used to. And your dancing in the rain.
As far as the -3 line. That's 3/16ths which is more than big enough for a 7/8ths slave.
If you're fighting a slow actuation then you have a much faster left foot than I do.
Cheers
Fred
Thanks for providing the part # Capt'n Been trying to decide what to use for a slave cyl and that looks perfect .
Hope You don't mind your idea being used on a Triumph. ;-)
Been quietly waiting for Mike to show off the pics of his latest tweek to his car. Did an outstanding job, as usual.
Mike, That is the H body Buick V6 bellhousing, originally cable clutch, pivot like late Ford. The best one to use behind a Buick V8. What throwout bearing are you using, GM T5 or Buick V6 original?
Thanks guys, it worked out well. The bearing and fork are S10 OE, cheap. I'm running a Tilton 74 series master 3/4" bore. It bolts right up to the late pedal box. Did have to fab a push rod. Mike
Hey Mike, Can you provide a arts ;list for that clutch actuating rod from your slave cylinder? Looks elegant and simple and I want to plagerize it!
I replaced my Mcleod hydraulic throw out bearing with a clutch fork and Wilwood pull type slave cylinder. I am using a Buick 215 bell housing and a T5 Transmission. The clutch fork has been cut off so it will fit in the transmission tunnel. With a MG clutch master it provides about 1/2" of pull which is plenty. Material from the clutch fork and bell housing needs to removed / ground away to provide clearance. The picture doesn't show the return spring I added. You will also replace the hydraulic fittings provided by Wilwood with ⅛" NPT to 4 AN 90° brass fittings.
Part Name - PN - Price - Source - Fits Vehicle Notes
Clutch Fork - 14550 - $29.79 - Rock Auto - 80 Camaro V6 229 cid - Dorman
Release Bearing - 908244- $22.89 - Rock Auto - 80 Camaro V6 229 cid - SKF Part Number N1488
Slave Cylinder - 260-1333 - $76.50 - Wilwood
IMG_1262.JPG
Here is a link to a video showing the clutch in action.
https://youtu.be/jEZ_EHly7W0
More Pictures
IMG_1261.JPG
More Pictures
IMG_1264.JPG
More pictures
IMG_1256.JPG
More Pictures
IMG_1272.JPG
Looks nice Jim! We're you having issues with your HTOB?
Yes the HTOB was releasing slow when the car was warm. I replaced the clutch master which had no impact. I haven't torn into the HTOB to see what was wrong. The first HTOB I installed lasted 10 years and I had it rebuilt by Mcleod as a preventive measure when I had the engine out for a paint job. The rebuild only lasted 3 driving seasons. Now if something goes wrong with the hydraulics I can make the repair without pulling the engine. The reliability on this set up still needs to be established, season one starts soon.
Good evening Gentlemen,
I'm inspired by this thread! Inspiration always leads to questions...
I have a 215 4-speed bell, mated with an adapter to a Ford Mustang V8 T5. I'll use a ford 10.5" clutch. I'm hoping I can stitch together a slave setup without TIG-welding my bellhousing.
Do GM clutch forks and T5 input shafts mate to Ford throwout bearings? I have tried to find OD measurements for TBs on the web, but haven't had luck. If they do, I think I can copy Jims setup exactly.
It looks like Mike's slave setup uses a fork with a 2-1 ratio with equal diameter slave cylinders.
Jim, does your cut Camaro fork have a 2-1 ratio as well? Same size master and slave?
I was admiring some Jeep forks on the web, and was wondering if they might work without mods:
http://www.the-jeep-guy.com/Transmission.htm
A few of them on that website appear to be 2-1, very short, and of a vintage that might share some dimensions with the Buick 215 (Jeeps had a v6 derived from the 215 for a while, I think).
Any advice on the right fork/slave/TB recipe for a Buick/Ford setup would be much appreciated.
Dave
Dave, The cable type clutch fork they use has the pivot ball on the opposite side from your 215. The Ford bearing retainer and throwout bearing has a larger diameter than the GM. You could use the cable type Ford fork and move the pivot to the opposite side. The same size master and slave works OK but a size smaller master will give an easier pedal and longer throw. This link may help:
http://www.mgexp.com/phorum/read.php?40,3509466,page=4
QuoteI have a 215 4-speed bell, mated with an adapter to a Ford Mustang V8 T5. I'll use a ford 10.5" clutch. I'm hoping I can stitch together a slave setup without TIG-welding my bellhousing.
Are you married to the Ford clutch for some reason? You could use a GM bearing retainer on your Ford T5 and keep all the components GM. You'd need to find (or have one made) a disc that matches up to the Ford input shaft. Seems an easier way to go to me.
The S10 clutch fork uses the far side pivot but is NOT a cable piece as it has a dimple in the actuator end and no cable slot. This makes it perfect for a push cylinder. It is also quite short which is helpful in those close confines.
I'm using it with a standard (but modified) BOP bell and the S/C will be positioned between the tranny mounting ears, bolted to the bell using a 3/4" Isuzu slave. Flange mount. I added about 1" to the mount surface of the bell and a bit of metal where the pivot rod goes on the other side.
Jim
I have a ford foxbody clutch/pp setup in hand, but I'm not otherwise committed to a ford solution.
I was looking at my 90 Mustang foxbody Ford clutch fork, and it appears to have the same distance between pivot stud and input shaft centerlines that the Buick 215 bell does. I need to confirm using precise means, but using a measuring tape it looks to be exactly the same.
If I cut the Ford fork in half and weld the "tail" onto the opposite end, and use an adjustable Ford-shaped pivot stud, I think I'll be good to go with a pull-type slave. What could go wrong?
Probably a lot. Will follow up with details this weekend.
Here's a photo with the Isuzu slave:
IMG_0018.JPG
Jim