BritishV8 Forum

General Category => MG Sports Cars => Topic started by: Scott Costanzo on October 22, 2013, 09:12:39 PM

Title: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on October 22, 2013, 09:12:39 PM
I'm starting this thread to document my LS4 conversion since this forum is specific to the MG.

I'm going to try to have it ready for Colorado Springs next July. It's aggressive. I'm going to use a "phased" approach which worked really well when I did my V6 conversion. Basically, the first "phase" is to get the thing on the road. This means compromises will have to be made. For example, I would love to do a cam/intake/decent headers and get close to 400 hp. (which is so easy to do with this platform) but that takes time, money and isn't necessary to get the car running. I wanted to let you know my approach so when you see me about to do something that makes you want to cover your eyes, you'll know there is some reason behind it. :) I've babbled enough so now on to a status.

The conversion is actually underway! I'm excited. I had hoped to test fit the motor last night but couldn't quite do it. I am close though. This picture shows where I'm at for now.

LS4FirewallMods.jpg

My current goal is to get the engine positioned and the mounts fabricated and installed. Next weekend is going to be extremely busy (moving mother-in-law) but I hope to find a few hours to play. I'll post again as progress is made.

Scott
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: RMO 699F on October 22, 2013, 11:09:15 PM
Scott, looking good! Keep the updates coming!!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on October 23, 2013, 10:21:34 AM
Interesting to notice that the firewall trimming does not impinge on the foot area, sort of an important consideration. Looks like the throttle cable is unaffected as well from what I can see.

Jim
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Jim Stabe on October 23, 2013, 01:57:00 PM
Why don't you start a project journal?
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on October 23, 2013, 06:26:50 PM
QuoteInteresting to notice that the firewall trimming does not impinge on the foot area, sort of an important consideration. Looks like the throttle cable is unaffected as well from what I can see.

Jim,
So far so good. I traced the rear of the engine on some foam cored wall board and I'm using that as my pattern. There is an area down low, marked on the picture below that I think I'm going to have to remove for the starter mount. It's only about a 1/2" of floor there right up against the frame rail. We'll see. I'm really anxious to start fitting the motor as you can imagine.

LS4FirewallMods.jpg

It's the little green thing on the left.

Scott
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on October 23, 2013, 06:47:11 PM
QuoteWhy don't you start a project journal?

That's a really good question, Jim. I gave it a lot of thought and decided I liked giving everyone the opportunity to ask questions or add comments and keep everything all in one thread. The alternative is to have the journal and then a second thread for the latter. This site seems to attract mostly fellow hobbyist so it's more of a mature (I don't mean old), technical, respectful and open audience. I'm not sure if you followed the LS4 thread in the drivetrain section but that approach worked out really well there and I expect it will in this thread too. Now if this were the other, inferior site, it would be an entirely different situation. I won't rant but I would never do a build thread there. :)

Scott
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on October 23, 2013, 07:01:58 PM
Scott, Did you have to notch the 2.2 bellhousing for starter nose clearance? The Ls4 being a little wider than the Rover V8, blockhugger headers might work through the fender RV8 style. I think the updated  shielded oil relief valve is the fix for the oil consumption. The 42lb relief valve would be good if not using the DOD. Project looks good!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on October 24, 2013, 05:58:25 PM
QuoteDid you have to notch the 2.2 bellhousing for starter nose clearance? The Ls4 being a little wider than the Rover V8, blockhugger headers might work through the fender RV8 style.

Jim,

Yes, I will have to notch the bellhousing. I'm going to wait until I get the clutch here. I still need to measure how far the input shaft goes into the crank and sort that out too...in good time. Right now I'm concentrating on getting the engine installed. As soon as that is done it will be on to the manifolds/headers.

Scott
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgbreis on October 28, 2013, 12:08:35 PM
Interesting, looks like almost exactly the same firewall cuts I made for a sbf. It seems like the shift in popularity from Rover swaps to Ford swaps started about 10 years ago, I think we might be seeing a shift from Ford to LS in the near future. I'm enjoying following along, Scott!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on October 29, 2013, 08:11:26 PM
I didn't have a lot of time this past weekend but I managed to find a few hours to do an initial fitting of the engine. Although it's still early in the process, I was very pleased with what I found. Obviously, nothing is in it's final position in any of the pictures that follow. Another few hours will be needed to get there. First, some pictures of fitting the motor will be shown, then the current state of the engine bay modifications. It will take a few posts to get everything uploaded.

This first picture gives a general view a few feet away from the car.

LS4Engine1.jpg

This next one illustrates one of the two main reasons I decided to go with the LS4.

LS4Engine2.jpg

You can see the harmonic balancer fits behind the rack. I thought there was a good chance it would. The only modifications to the firewall at this point are those detailed in the one of the previous posts above. It just fits and I'll need to find another 3/16" to 1/4" or so on the firewall so the motor can be tilted the required 3 degrees. I also want to give myself enough room between the rack and the balancer to slip a belt on, just in case. Still a long way to go here. Oh, the other reason I went with the LS4 is the small bellhousing.

The next series of pictures show the sides of the engine/engine compartment just for reference. It's hard to see on a photo but there is more room on the sides than I would have thought.

LS4DriverSideUp.jpg

LS4DriverSideDown.jpg
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on October 29, 2013, 08:20:39 PM
LS4PassSideUp.jpg

LS4PassSideDown.jpg

I did have to notch the crossmember. The front of the oil pan kept the motor about an inch higher than desired. One of the main requirements of this build is absolultely no hood modifications.

LS4CrossMemberNotch.jpg

Here is the current state of the firewall mods. Essentially no changes...I did tweak the left side a little.

LS4CurrentFirewallMods.jpg

This does it for now. It was really exciting for me to see the motor in the car.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: RMO 699F on October 29, 2013, 09:32:36 PM
Great progress Scott, keep the updates coming!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on October 29, 2013, 09:36:45 PM
Scott, COOL!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: rficalora on October 30, 2013, 12:44:01 AM
Great work Scott.  Could you tell if the steering shaft will work to the stock location or will you need to reroute it with an extra U-joint or two?

Just read that the LS4 was made for FWD applications.  What bell housings work with it?
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on October 30, 2013, 11:51:51 AM
Very good work. So far it doesn't appear there is any reason for concern. A bit tight where the steering goes through the firewall. What do you have in mind for headers?

Jim
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgbreis on October 30, 2013, 02:41:14 PM
I bet you could cut up a set of these and make some LS/RV8 headers pretty easily.

http://www.speedwaymotors.com/LS1-Block-Hugger-Tight-Fit-Headers-Plain,4614.html
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on October 30, 2013, 03:40:59 PM
Ryan, the LS motor is wider than the Rover or Ford. I'm thinking they will work as is, with the hole in the fenderwell lower. Probably right over the frame piece.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on October 30, 2013, 07:32:39 PM
Everyone, thanks for the feedback and suggestions.

Jim B., Ryan, Jim N.: I'm going to be fabricating my own set of headers but I appreciate the suggestions.

Rob, Jim B.: The steering seems to be ok as far as interference with the block. What isn't clear at this time is where the two rear exhaust ports will end up when the engine is positioned properly. This picture gives a little more detail on what is going on back there.

LS4PassSideCloser.jpg

If one of the ports ends up opposite the shaft then I'll have to get another u-joint and re-position things. The odds here favor having to modify the steering, I believe, and it will probably make things easier in the long run too. We will see.

Rob: Here is a picture of the bellhousing I'm using. It's the same one I used on my V6. It's the small GM bellhousing pattern.

(http://forum.britishv8.org/file.php?6,file=13599,in_body_attachment=1)

Just about any of the many RWD bell housings with this pattern will work. I'm using a Ford T5 so that pattern probably looks familiar to you. It fits the B transmission tunnel very well. I'll have some additional pictures in the not too distant future...I hope. :)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: jim0899 on October 30, 2013, 07:45:07 PM
Looks good Scott, I'll be following this project, great way to show your progress and get feedback.  I have a small block Chevy installed, gathering parts for my LS conversion.
smallIMG_1543.jpg
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on October 30, 2013, 08:49:40 PM
QuoteLooks good Scott, I'll be following this project, great way to show your progress and get feedback. I have a small block Chevy installed, gathering parts for my LS conversion.

Glad you're here Jim. You're the 4th Jim who has posted in this thread!

I hope you post more about your project. Very interested in your approach.

Scott
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on October 31, 2013, 10:38:59 AM
Scott, from that last shot it looks like you might be able to extend your rack pinion shaft a couple of inches and clear your exhaust ports by getting the u-joint back into the firewall cone. If you have access to a lathe or someone with one it's pretty easily done, or you could run down here one day and we could do it. Something to keep in mind. The more direct the steering the better. Also since the cone is toast it wouldn't take much to modify that too and there is a little give in the column position.

Jim
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on October 31, 2013, 06:51:07 PM
QuoteIf you have access to a lathe or someone with one it's pretty easily done, or you could run down here one day and we could do it. Something to keep in mind.

Jim,

Thank you for the offer! With some luck, I should have the motor positioned by the end of the weekend. It will answer several questions. I'll keep you informed.

Scott
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on November 03, 2013, 08:23:42 AM
Made some good progress again yesterday but still have a ways to go. I got engine close to where it will ultimately live and was curious about hood clearance. I was very happy with the what I found.

LS4HoodClearance.jpg

The next couple of pictures show what I have in mind for the final layout of the engine bay. Again, it is what I was hoping for when I selected this motor. Of course it isn't done yet so things could change.

LS4EnginePositionDS.jpg

LS4EnginePositionFront.jpg

Further changes to the firewall were needed to get the engine where I wanted it. The most significant change was to the heater shelf. I wasn't really concerned with maintaining the original heater box but I believe I can modify it to fit. This will be a phase 2 task, for phase 1 I'm going to put sheet metal covers in place.

LS4CurrentFirewall11022013.jpg

You can see on the left side that the opening has been enlarged as well. #8 spark plug will be living back there and I need to provide some clearance and access to it. More trimming will be needed there. The right side is pretty much the same although I did do some trimming on the back side to fit the engine. I was running out of time but I mounted the bellhousing on the motor and quickly tried to fit it. The oil pan was hanging up on the crossmember as I was trying to angle it into the engine bay. I will be trimming it a bit more. The next step is to ensure the engine/transmission combination fits properly.

For those of you who might be considering this swap, keep in mind that I'm working with a chrome bumper B and my goals for this conversion are driving engine placement. I know nothing about rubber bumper B's, but I understand that the front crossmember is deeper and the firewall is modified for the Rover V8. It might be possible to fit an LS4 in one with no or minimal modification. It would be interesting to see. I would expect even more options if you're running a Fast Cars crossmember with a chrome or rubber bumper model.

The most interesting news from yesterday's efforts (well, interesting to me at least :) ) is it looks like it may be possible to route the headers without modifying the steering. I don't have any pictures at this point but the u-joint falls between #5 and #7 exhaust ports and the shaft appears to be low enough to allow the header pipe to fit. We will see. #7 spark plug is pretty close to the u-joint and I don't believe the original boot will work so that's another issue on the to do list.

That's it for now.

Scott
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Moderator on November 03, 2013, 09:58:48 AM
That certainly is looking good!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on November 03, 2013, 10:25:23 AM
Very interesting.

Jim
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on November 03, 2013, 07:53:36 PM
Scott, Looks like  time to look at heat/air under the dash.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: 74ls1tr6 on November 04, 2013, 06:28:04 PM
Hi Scott,

I'm kind of right there where you are at cutting the fire wall out. On the passenger side head, it does sit father back on that side than the driver side. How much room do you have there with what you cut out already? I noticed you cut out some of the center section out. What measurement did you leave yourself from the head to the center section?? So far I just cut straight off that shelf along side where the head goes, but I do have a 71 which may have more room. I did move my radiator all the way up to the cross section up front. I'm using a 24"wide x 19" tall radiator. So I also cut into the frame rail all the way out to the inner fender. Welded a c channel back in to reinforce the area.

Bought a HF plasma cutter....should have had one along time ago!!! Cut for engine clearance and cut for Vintage Air clearance in about an hours worth of work. It would have taken me days to a week to cut out what I did with a mini grinding wheel or Saw's all.

Looking good Scott !!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on November 04, 2013, 08:24:43 PM
Hi Calvin,

I was wondering where you were with your B. I'm leaving myself about a 1/4" between the motor and the firewall. I'm cutting the minimum into the firewall and I'm following the contours of the engine which is why part of the heater plenum is still there. Your 71 and my 68 should be exactly the same at the firewall/transmission tunnel. Outside of some touch up I'm done with my trimming except for by the #8 spark plug. What are you doing there?

Sounds like you're making some great progress too. The plasma cutter sounds great...I would have to be careful to not get carried away with it. :)

Say hi to Brenda

Scott
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: rficalora on November 04, 2013, 08:52:49 PM
RE: Bought a HF plasma cutter....

I told you they are cool.  Still wish i hadnt sold mine, but needed the money at the time.

Calvin - are you using an LS4 too?
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BMC on November 05, 2013, 02:59:43 AM
Further changes to the firewall were needed to get the engine where I wanted it. The most significant change was to the heater shelf. I wasn't really concerned with maintaining the original heater box but I believe I can modify it to fit.


After reading that I wanted to report you to the moderator but then realized he is on your side. Herumph. I guess this is not a Purist site.

On a more serious note, I have been following your progress with great admiration.

Do you have a photo of the pulleys and how much clearance you have between those and the steering rack and if that was at firewall cutout #1 or the second firewall trim? Without seeing the front, I can't quite tell how the rear trimmed out fits into this equation.

Thanks for keeping us post Scott!

-BMC.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on November 05, 2013, 07:44:30 PM
Brian,
I don't have a photo of my current pulley clearance but I'll get plenty once things are in place. For cutout #1 I had just enough room to fit the engine between the firewall and the steering rack. There wasn't enough room to tilt it at that point. The second trimming allowed me to tilt the engine into the proper position. I'm aiming for just enough room between the rack and the front pulley to allow a belt to be slipped through in case it needs replacing so that will be about 3/16" give or take. I also had to allow for the bellhousing at the upper two bolts. The bellhousing is an inch thick in that area not counting the two bolt heads. That is why you see the heater plenum cut out the way it is. I am going to rebuild the plenum when I put the firewall back together so much of what you see missing will be replaced. Hope this answered your question.

Scott
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: 74ls1tr6 on November 09, 2013, 06:27:06 AM
Hi Rob,

No I'm using the ls1. Both the ls4 and ls1 are pretty close in size I believe.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on November 09, 2013, 07:59:27 AM
The crankshaft is 13mm shorter, but the main thing is the accessories are more compact & driven by a single belt to save space. It's a 5.3L vs 5.7L Comes with LS6 heads, though. Lots of upgrade potential

I'm sure Scott has read this several times. I'll stick it here for future reference:

QuoteDuring the research phase, I quickly realized that while 303hp in stock form isn't a slouch, it seemed GM outfitted the LS4 with good heads and compression but with smaller/more restrictive intake and exhaust components than the other RWD LS(x) applications. If it made 303 hp with all these restrictions, I was curious to see what would happen when all these restrictive components are removed/upgraded.

So I spend some time figuring out what was different on the LS4 vs. the RWD LS(x) engines going component by component and compiled the following list of planned performance upgrades:
**LS4 78mm MAF upgraded to 85mm MAF
**LS4 76mm DBW throttle body upgrade to 90mm LS2 DBW throttle body
**LS4 76mm Intake manifold upgraded to 90mm LS2 Intake manifold and matching LS2 fuel rail
**LS4 28lb injectors upgrade to 34lb LS2 injectors (came with the fuel rail)
**LS4 stock camshaft (197/197 .286/.286 @ 114LSA upgraded to a 224/231 .332/.338 @ 113 lsa (some will say this is too big...)
**LS4 stock exhaust manifolds upgraded to LS7 hydro formed exhaust manifolds

These upgrades should do wonders to help the LS4 pump some air and make some power. All these upgrade components except the camshaft were purchased used off LS1tech.com or Ebay to help keep the upgrade costs down, but in total they were still higher than the initial engine purchase.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on November 09, 2013, 12:34:25 PM
Yeah, I have a copy of the dyno chart of that build 380HP.
LS4F40Dyno.jpg
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on November 09, 2013, 04:30:08 PM
http://www.gmls4.com/

At the wheels, no less!

QuoteList of mods:
Car is an 88 Fiero that weighs 2807 lbs.
5.3L LS4 - stock heads and lower end
224/232 New Era DoD camshaft with pushrods/springs
Stock LS2 intake, injectors, Throttle body
Stock LS7 MAF and exhaust manifolds
4" cold air intake
Magnaflow 3" in dual 2.5 out exhaust
2006 Pontiac G6 6 speed manual FWD transmission (F40)
12lb aluminum flywheel
Spec stage 4+ 10" clutch
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on November 09, 2013, 04:52:55 PM
He forgot to mention the heavier valve springs that came in the cam kit. Max power at 7000 RPM! It would be beneficial to advance 4 degrees to move power curve down. Plus if he milled the heads .030 for that extra .5 from 10 to 1 stock it would be over 400HP!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on November 10, 2013, 08:42:27 AM
Yeah, the LS4 has some potential but I should notice a difference going from about 170 hp to the stock 300 hp I would imagine. :)

Made more progress yesterday. The engine/transmission is in the car at the moment. Still need another day or two to finish the fitting phase. It's amazing how fast the day goes. I spent more than 8 hrs. yesterday and it felt like I was at it for only 3 hrs. Here are a couple of pictures that show how the bellhousing is fitting.

LS4bellhousingfit1.jpg

LS4bellhousingfit2.jpg

LS4bellhousingfit3.jpg

This last one was a quick shot at the end of the day showing the transmission is actually in there. It is tight but it does fit.

LS4transincar.jpg

Won't have any time to play with the car next weekend but I'm hoping to get a good start on fabricating the motor mounts Thanksgiving week.

Scott
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on November 10, 2013, 01:01:33 PM
Scott, I don't know what you have decided on for mounts but, for the 4.9 Cadillac I settled on a LS type adapter plate with solid style SBC upper mount(picture shows rubber mount) and Jeep urethane lower.
916180161_L.jpg
trd-4214_w.jpg
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on November 11, 2013, 10:03:06 AM
Jim,
I'm going with the Barry 22000 mounts per a recommendation by Curtis. Specifically, the 22001-14.

I had an unexpected hour to play yesterday so I worked to position the motor a bit more. You can't tell very well from the picture below but the motor is sitting on some temporary "mounts" at the front and I have the transmission cross member in place and supporting the rear. The only place it is touching the body is at a bolt at the rear of the head on the driver's side that I'm using to hold the chain for the hoist. That, of course, will be removed.

LS4TemporaryMount.jpg

The setback is just where I wanted it and it is tilted back about 3 degrees. I think I'm going to lower it maybe 1/8" from where you see it here. There are many details and I'll do a more complete write-up when I'm sure it is in the final position.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: classic conversions on November 12, 2013, 08:43:56 PM
Is looking good, the only problem I see and it is not a big deal, is the throttle pedal. It is going to be the same issue as the Cobra.

Avoid solid mounts on the aluminum blocks, although the blocks are very strong, a few LS engine mounted solid found themselves with holes in the side of the block at the drag strip seen them.
Use some sort of cushion.

Great work.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on November 24, 2013, 10:20:58 AM
Played with the car yesterday and made further progress. It's in the tedious phase making sure everything fits right. Replaced the front cross member pads with polyurethane. Also put the starter on to make sure there were no surprises there. As I mentioned before, it is tight but at this point it does fit with no further modification to the firewall. I think one more fitting session should answer the remaining questions about the steering and where the final position of the motor will be. No photos as there really isn't anything new show at this point.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: pspeaks on November 25, 2013, 01:30:24 PM
I've only owned one Chevy engine in my life and  know nothing of LS engines, but I really enjoy this thread.  I wish more of us had done this, a lot of good information.


Paul
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on November 26, 2013, 06:26:47 PM
Well, got a question answered last night. :)

LS4SteeringShaft.jpg

This is the steering, FYI.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: billymgb1000 on November 26, 2013, 06:58:30 PM
100_1343.JPG
100_1344.JPG
Here are a couple of pics of my ls1 and the steering shaft
100_1596.JPG
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: billymgb1000 on November 26, 2013, 07:31:42 PM
Hello Scott my name is Bill G I did this swap myself last winter I went with a ls1 4.8 I also went with edelbrocks carb conversion I only use the crank and cam sensors my mgb is a chrome bumper early 74 so I had cutting also what I did was to raise the body off the crossmember by 2 inches and made rear shackles 2 inches longer I wanted that stance and look I am not into slamming it to the ground the roads where I live wouldn't allow it anyways I did not want a hood scoop but I had to go with one by raising it I did not have to cut the crossmember up  the steering shaft is a bi%$# but it can be done I noticed someone suggested the block hugger headers that's what I bought I was going to buy the ones you totally build but the tech at jegs said buy the huggers and cut the flange off and reangle it and weld it why weld 15 spots when you can weld 4 instead glad I did that I went with a turbo 350 auto because of 4 back surgeries and a bad left leg I raised the tunnel by one inch worked great I did not have to move the rear cross member just change the mount even the drive shaft is the exact same length I bought new springs all the way around added 2 extra on the rears also traction bars and I made a panhard  back to the steering shaft I had to lift my motor just a little from where I had it and weld 2 flanges on that header just ask me anything you want I will help you any way I can good luck
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on November 26, 2013, 10:48:37 PM
Honestly I would like to see what it looks like with the engine a little farther forward. I always felt that the straighter the steering shaft the better, and would rather lower the rack than add universal joints.

Jim
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on November 27, 2013, 08:00:15 AM
Bill,

Thanks for the feedback! I'm finding that pictures can be difficult to interpret sometimes but it appears that my engine might be about an inch lower and about an inch further back than you are so I'm going to have to lower my steering shaft about an inch or inch and a half to gain clearance.

Jim,

Thanks for your feedback! Yes, of course I would have preferred to not do any modifications. :) The steering issue is not unexpected at all. My plans for this project hinge on the motor being positioned where it is in the above picture so that won't be changing. I'll be using another u-joint down by the rack.

Actually had the opportunity to play with the car two nights in a row! Last night I got the motor into position finally. Didn't get any pictures but I'm very pleased with the way it's fitting. Hope to actually start on the mounts this weekend.

Hope everyone has a great Thanksgiving!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on November 27, 2013, 12:27:29 PM
Scott, I kinda like the 2 ujoint steering better because you can rotate the rack or shim to change the angle of the shaft.. You can do the lower ujoint without welding by grinding flats and using 17mm DD Jeep pinch to 3/4" DD lower joint, 3/4"DD shaft to 3/4" 48 spline MGB upper joint.  Plus the aftermarket ujoints are a lot smaller. There is a thread on the Mgexperience board I'll try to find. Found it:          http://www.mgexp.com/phorum/read.php?40,2467295
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on November 27, 2013, 03:32:45 PM
Good advice Jim. I've been looking at the Sweet u-joints as they look very compact. I am currently using a Borgeson u-joint as a direct replacement for the stock u-joint but I like the idea of using a DD shaft in the middle...phasing the two u-joints should be a no brainer and much easier to implement too.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: pspeaks on November 27, 2013, 03:41:22 PM
Sweet also makes a 3/4"-48 that works on stock MGB steering columns and shafts (401-51010), it's what I used at the firewall.   This is a little unusual but it has been done, Sweet universals can be disassembled like a drive shaft universal and the ends swapped to connect pretty much any kind or size shafts together.  I only mention this to point out there is not much limit to what you can do but for anybody who decides to try this, keep in mind the needles are rather small and the caps can easily be damaged in putting them back together.  The 1" Firewall bearing I used is an actual roller bearing with a rubber seal and is available from Granger (4X730).  Be advised however the stock 1" shaft after being compressed to a DD is no longer 1" and the diameter has to be reduced a few thousands of an inch.  Yes, there are probably much easier ways to do your steering but I liked the way it looked.  



Paul
IMAG0155.jpg
IMAG0152.jpg
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on November 27, 2013, 03:56:35 PM
QuoteSweet also makes a 3/4"-48 that works on stock MGB steering columns and shafts (401-51010).

Appreciate it Paul!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on November 27, 2013, 04:29:46 PM
Uni-steer and Flaming River make the lower joint you need  or you can shim the stub at the rack and weld 3/4" round to 3/4" DD. The MG shaft is slightly smaller than 3/4". That is why I recommended the 17MM DD Jeep pinch to 3/4" DD. You could also use the Borgeson MGB 48 spline to 3/4" DD vibration damper ujoint.. Speedway Motors  carries the DD shaft. Rig it up with wooden dowels first and it will be perfect.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: pspeaks on November 27, 2013, 04:42:20 PM
Yes, I made all my shafts out of 3/4 dowel rods first and then transferred that to steel.


Paul
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on November 28, 2013, 10:16:18 AM
I know Scott has picked his motor mounts. Here's another mount option.

http://liquidironindustries.com/GM-LS-Motor-Mounts.html
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on December 02, 2013, 10:37:46 AM
Made more progress this past weekend. Measured for the motor mounts and cut the frame mounts. Next step is to assemble the mounts and weld them to the "frame" rails. I keep mentioning that there are a lot of details and this is not an exception. I'm going to wait until I actually complete a task before I share the details so I don't pass on misinformation as some of the details are in flux until the task is actually completed.

I don't think I shared a picture of the engine/transmission combination yet so here it is.

LS4EngineTrans.jpg

I measured the steering shaft and got about .730". Jim N., I know you are recommending the 17 mm DD u-joint but after considering things, I'm going to do something different. (What else is new :) ). I believe I'll be going with a 3/4" DD u-joint mainly because I have some concerns with how the 17 mm pinch u-joint is going to fit with the clearances I have. I'll shim it with .01" shims.

I'm still making good progress and having lots of fun...I'm trying to make sure I get something done every week. Also still very excited about the big changes this will be making to my car.

If you have any questions, I'll try to answer them.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on December 04, 2013, 08:07:49 PM
Not sure this is the right place to post this but I thought this might interest some of you. The following pictures will give you an idea of how a RWD car/truck motor (4.8/5.3/5.7/6.0) might fit in a B with the same set back I'm trying to achieve with my LS4. Although it may seem like it to some of you, I'm NOT bashing those motors. They have been and are successfully used in MGBs regularly. I suspect there will be many more of them used in B conversions in the future rather than the LS4. Also, the majority of them will not be placed as far back as I'm going with the LS4 and therefore the firewall mods won't be nearly as extensive as depicted here.

Anyway, what got me thinking about this is the fact that you can see much of the SBC bellhousing bolt pattern on the LS4 block so it illustrates some of the differences quite well in these views.

I think it's pretty obvious but the red marks are the large bellhousing bolt/dowel holes and the green is roughly what would need to be removed (in my estimation so take with a grain of salt) to accommodate the larger bellhousing if the motor were set back this far.

LS4DrivBell.JPG
LS4PassLowBell.JPG
LS4FireWallMods.JPG
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: TXS67BGT on December 07, 2013, 09:55:47 PM
a 98 Camaro steering has a nice set of ujoints, diameter is smallish and good for high angle change. look how chevy packaged the camaro steering
STEERINGCOLUMN122711003.JPG
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on December 08, 2013, 01:49:25 PM
More progress this weekend. I decided to attack the steering before the motor mounts as I needed to know where the steering ended up before positioning the motor mounts. I went with the Sweet steering u-joints. 3/4" 48 Spline for the steering column end and 3/4" DD for the remainder. I took the advice from Jim and Paul and used a 3/4" wood dowel for fabrication....excellent idea! Here is the result.

LS4SteeringMod.JPG

I lowered the steering a little less than 2" at the firewall. It actually wasn't very difficult to do. I modified the pinion shaft myself. Took my time and the u-joint is very snug with no play. I need to order a DD shaft, finish the set screw modifications for the u-joints and weld the cone into the firewall. FYI, the DD shaft will be a hair less than 14" long. I believe this is the easiest approach to the steering issue. I really wanted to keep the rack in the factory location and messing with the rack mounts to lower the stock shaft looked time consuming. Ignore the brake lines, they will all be replaced and rerouted before I put the car back on the road. You can see the position of the steering wheel after the lowering here.

LS4SteeringPosition.JPG

It raised the rim of the wheel about an inch or so.

There is a fairly big hole from trimming the passenger side firewall but it really is pretty much dead space from the perspective of usable space in the foot well. You can see from this shot what I mean.

LS4FootwellRoomPass.JPG

So motor mounts should be next and then the exhaust. I figure if I can have those tasks completed by early January I should be about where I need to be for the V8 Meet....we will see.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on December 08, 2013, 02:18:06 PM
Scott. Good Work! You could still rotate lower end up or down if needed for clearance without moving the rack too much. Use angled washers for angle iron on upper and lower rack mount with longer bolts.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on December 22, 2013, 09:15:28 AM
I'm slow but getting there inch by inch. Just about got the motor mounts there. This first picture shows the mounts tacked to the "frame rails".

LS4MotorMountsTackWelded.JPG

I need to remove the passenger side mount and shorten it so the mounting hole sits closer to the frame. I should be able to complete fabricating the mounts on the engine side once that is complete. In the following pictures, the engine is positioned where it will live going forward. This first shot shows the clearance on the pulley. I was actually able to get a belt between the rack and the pulley so that was good.

LS4PulleyClearance.JPG

This next picture illustrates, I think, just how compact the LS blocks are.

LS4SideView.JPG

This view makes the B engine bay look big front to back. It fills the bay up side to side, that's for sure, but it does fit. As you can see in the next picture, there is plenty of room for the header pipe and spark plug wire now. Moving the steering shaft down was well worth doing.

LS4ExhaustClearance.JPG

I should have a few days/evenings to work during the holidays so I'll keep plugging away at it. I hope to order my header pipe today.

Merry Christmas everyone!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on December 22, 2013, 02:21:47 PM
Scott,Looking Good!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on December 29, 2013, 09:57:25 AM
Not quite there yet with the motor mounts but getting dangerously close. This first picture shows the drivers side engine mount tacked together. I'm pretty pleased with the way things are turning out.

LS4DrivMount.jpg

The next shot shows the same side with the engine in the car.

LS4DrivSideMount.jpg

Except for permanently welding the engine side of the mount, adding a couple of gussets and drilling a hole for the rubber mount this side is done. Oh, I will need to make sure the steering shaft has clearance on the mount as well. Still a few tweaks needed on the passenger side and then the transmission mount needs to be completed. Hope to get it there in the next day or two. It will be nice to have the motor permanently installed in the car.

While I was working on the car, this came.

LS4HeaderPipe.jpg

I used Ken Hiebert's suggestion and went with Columbia River Mandrel Bending. Of course, I only ordered one pair of exhaust flanges instead of two and forgot the O2 bungs so they will be getting another order. :(

I'll have more detailed descriptions and pictures once the mounts are completed.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on December 29, 2013, 10:59:22 AM
Scott, the mounts look strong but there is a weakness that you might want to consider while there is still plenty of time to address it. I've been thinking about whether or not to say anything and have decided I should.

The attachment to the frame rails in itself is strong enough and well designed, but it is welded to thin material, and I'm not sure it will hold up. Over time I can see the frame rail developing stress cracks around the mount welds because the stresses are concentrated in a relatively small area. You might want to think about what you could do to spread out the loading, and there may be some fairly easy way to go about it. I'd guess the torsional loads are going to be the biggest factor.

If you hadn't welded them on yet it'd be a fairly simple matter to plate the rail with some 12 or 14 gage under the mount. If you do that (meaning cutting the tabs off and rewelding) do not run your front and rear edges of the plate vertical. Best practice in frame repair is to spread the load by using round, diamond shaped, or diagonal front and rear edges to spread the load out on the frame. If I was doing it I think I'd also drill some holes in the plate under the tab and use those to spot weld the plate to the frame before welding the tab on. That will let you get by with thinner and lighter plates.

I know I just made more work for you, but hey, I'm only here to help!  ;)

Jim
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Charles on December 29, 2013, 04:48:24 PM
Scott, Nice shoes, I had a pair like them once. Dog carried one off, someone threw the other away. I was lost till I found a new brokein pair.
I agree with Jim B, I don't know why, is there room to add a plate from the rear cross member bolt to the welded engine mount?  The metal of the frame is light weight and now it is brittle due to welding, with no way to relieve stress. I am enjoying your post and efforts. I am just starting my 60v6 swap.
charles
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on December 29, 2013, 08:04:38 PM
QuoteThe attachment to the frame rails in itself is strong enough and well designed, but it is welded to thin material, and I'm not sure it will hold up. Over time I can see the frame rail developing stress cracks around the mount welds because the stresses are concentrated in a relatively small area. You might want to think about what you could do to spread out the loading, and there may be some fairly easy way to go about it. I'd guess the torsional loads are going to be the biggest factor.

Jim, thanks for the feedback, sounds like a good idea. Not sure I'd cut the mounts off but I think I can strengthen them anyway. I've welded the mounts directly over a supporting tab for the rear crossmember bolt so it isn't quite as weak as it might appear.....still needs something more. I'll get it done before I put the car back on the road.

Scott
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on December 30, 2013, 10:02:24 AM
Ok, I know what I'm going to do about strengthening the mounts. I'll run a couple of gussets on top of the current mounts to the very top of the "frame rail". For good measure, I'll weld the seam at the top of the rail as well. That should address Jim's concern about stressing the thin metal on the side of the rail and will be fairly easy to accomplish at this stage of the fabrication. I'll have to get creative around the steering shaft.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on December 30, 2013, 08:33:39 PM
Scott, Just a suggestion but, an easier way is to use a plate like on your motor about 3" wider than the mount on each side and same height as frame, notched to go over lower mount. Grind and weld in frame seam. Matching top frame plate and little square piece under mount. Weld all together. No steering issues. Hey, did you get your clutch stuff yet?
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: DiDueColpi on December 31, 2013, 04:10:25 AM
Ditch the rubber X frame mounts and build a tab down to the X member.
Stronger body, stronger mount, better suspension but more noise.
Good trade off.
Cheers
Fred
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on December 31, 2013, 11:38:52 AM
QuoteJust a suggestion but, an easier way is to use a plate like on your motor about 3" wider than the mount on each side and same height as frame, notched to go over lower mount.

Jim, I appreciate the suggestion. I considered that approach earlier but I think adding an upper gusset to each side will be just as strong and will be easier/quicker to complete.

QuoteDitch the rubber X frame mounts and build a tab down to the X member. Stronger body, stronger mount, better suspension but more noise.

Fred, thank you! Interesting suggestion. The cross member pads you see there are brand new, never used urethane pads I just put in last month. I know they aren't like a solid mount but they will do for now. They should be much better than the 46 year old, flattened rubber pads I pulled out of there. I'll file this suggestion away for when I get to the suspension. I have a pair of GAZ coil over shocks I want to use on the front end...had them for over a year but just can't seem to find the time to put them on. How would you implement the solid mounts, steel replacements for the pads?

I think this might be good time to say a few things that have been on my mind lately. I REALLY do appreciate the feedback I'm getting from everyone. I would have done a journal if I didn't want feedback. It seems like I'm always ignoring some of the advice I'm getting but as "Project Manager" for this project I have to keep in mind the overall plan/timeline I'm working toward. When I get a suggestion that affects the overall plan in some way, even though it might address the current task, I have to look at the effects of implementing that suggestion. So far the plan is working out really well so I'm not inclined to make any changes to it unless a huge issue comes up. I trying to not let this become a multi-year project and constantly changing the plan is a sure way to get there.

Anyway, what I'm trying to say is although it might not seem like it at times, your comments are very welcome. One of the main reasons I'm doing this is to learn and I guarantee you I will be making mistakes.

Happy New year!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on December 31, 2013, 04:24:47 PM
Don't forget, someday, someone doing a similar swap, will do a search & find this thread. The additional ideas presented here may be fuel for thought for them. Thank you, Scott, for the non-journal approach.

I'm with Fred, though.  I looked over your pics & I kept thinking subframe mounts. Hey, they are available for Ford.  Maybe time for some Chevy subframe mounts.  :)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on December 31, 2013, 05:31:25 PM
I'm not a fan of subframe mounts. I used those on my original conversion and the stancheons were plenty strong but the (215) motor mounts needed a through bolt to counter mount separation from torque and even then they weren't good at torque resistance due to being close together. They also weren't all that easy to get the bolt in and out when changing the engine. But the worst thing was that the torque caused the frame rails to crack around the subframe mounting tubes. All four of them. Now granted I was also running stiff lowered springs and competition shock valves and I drove it hard so it was undoubtedly the combination that did it, but I had less torque than an LS4 I think. I just don't see running engine torque through the subframe to frame mount as being a great idea. It seemed like it until I tried it, but also consider if you will, the subframe attachment is designed to move. Consider if you will, the massively larger and greatly more widely spaced mounts of the cradle used on the TR7 and all modern cars by comparison. The MGB attachments are not really designed for it.

We're transferring a lot of torque to a small vehicle with thin structure and all that torque goes directly through the motor mounts. You have a factor of about 10:1 between what is seen at the axle and what is seen at the engine in 1st gear but the axle mounts are spread out over a considerably greater distance. In the case of the MGB, the length of the spring leaves and doubled, yet some still feel the need to add channels to support the front spring hangers, and doublers spread the load out into the body.

At the front, the stock mount brackets are fine for the 1800 and the later mounts are OK for the 3.5 and arguably for the 3.9 but more powerful engines require more substance. (Even the stock mounts sometimes crack so that part of the car definitely is not overbuilt.) The first consideration is distance between the mounts, since this directly affects the amount of torque that can be absorbed. Shorter distances require larger cushions, stronger brackets, and more load spreading.

This is a big part of the thinking that went behind the head-to-frame mount design I created for the MG-Roadmaster and my blown 340. It gains at least a couple of inches on the lever arm length, allowing smaller cushions to do the same job. It uses a reinforcing plate on the rail to spread the load out. And it uses a vertical tube to simplify install/removal. But everything is a compromise so it requires realignment of the pulleys and leaves scant space for the wiring to sneak past.

Scott, I think the gussets you have in mind should do pretty well, though they won't do much for ease of installing/removing the main bolt. A gusset of some type to the front and rear might also be helpful. The larger of an area of the frame rail that you can tie into the better.

Jim
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgbreis on January 01, 2014, 03:05:29 PM
I think Jim makes a good point, I was concerned about welding my mounts to the frame rail so I bent a sheet metal cap over the rail to weld the mount to. On the other hand, it's not like you're going to experience a catastrophic failure. More likely cracks as Jim said. You do have quite a bit of surface area where it welds to the frame, a lot more than mine. I'd do the same as you, add the gussets and move on to the next hurdle! You're going to have a lot of hp and torque, but it's not like you're going to hook up hard and transfer all of it to the mounts.

Good luck with the headers, I sure wish mine had turned out a little nicer.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: classic conversions on January 01, 2014, 10:49:07 PM
First weld a flat piece of steel to the frame rail, this gives a foundation, then weld the motor mount pads to the lat steel that is welded to the frame. This should be key to fit on top of the rail and welded for added support.
similar to the original MGB mount.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on January 02, 2014, 11:02:39 AM
Everyone,
Thanks again for the great feedback! I hope to have a few hours this evening to devote to the mounts.

Carl, if someone wanted to go with subframe mounts (despite Jim's concerns) it would be very doable. With the setback I'm using the stock LS motor mount location lines up quite well.

Hope everyone had a good new year.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: DiDueColpi on January 02, 2014, 08:37:37 PM
I guess that I should have elaborated a little more on the tab idea.
I would do a 3/4 wrap around the frame rail with 0.250" material
It's overkill for the purpose but it lets you wrap it under the subframe mounts and eliminate the bushings.
Drill it with lightening holes and trim it out as Jim described before welding it in place.
A tab down from this plate would then tie into the subframe making it a solid structure.
The motor mount would be welded to the plate on the vehicle frame much as it is now.
I'm in total agreement with Jim regarding mounting the engine from the subframe.
The loading and severe angles required would cause a failure sooner or later.
My intention is to make the subframe and vehicle frame one solid structure.
With so much material removed from the firewall you need to buy back some structural support.
And this is an easy place to start.
A nice solid trans X member. Yes an actual X shape. Tied in well to the vehicle frame.
With forward facing struts that would bolt up to the lower portion of the front subframe.
And rearward struts that would tie into the rear spring mounts.
Would give you a pretty solid base.
A well designed roll bar or cage (better) would add even more stiffness to the structure.
Anything that can be done to improve the body rigidity should be contemplated.
Because that thing is going to want to pretzel up bad.
Hope that's useful.
Cheers
Fred
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: TXS67BGT on January 03, 2014, 08:31:54 AM
for your reference, a removable trans mount, pretty stable after I put the tunnel back in. angle the tops of the plates toward the center a couple of degrees to ease installation and put 2-3 sheets of paper between the plates when fitting, leaves a tiny gap
TRANSMOUNT011.jpg
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: 302GT on January 04, 2014, 07:22:43 PM
I originally mounted my 302 on the frame the same way. The frame rails cracked in under 1000 miles. The cure was to make braces from the top of the frame rail down to the mounting pads. On the left side the front brace had to have a hole for the steering shaft to pass through. The cracking problem was worse on the right side because that gets a downward force during acceleration.

I have just puled the engine and transferred the mounting pads to the front subframe because I like the idea of another set of rubber (urethane) pads between the engine and the car. Certainly, the subfrane metal is much thicker than the body frame rails so I do not expect problems with it.

In terms of the engine torque cracking the frame rail tubes holding the subframe attaching studs; I am not convinced that engine torque is the problem. I would think that side forces from cornering would stress the frame more, and Jim's car has by far the widest tires (and hence the largest expected cornering forces) of any of the converted MGBs I am familiar with. But if Jim never exploited the cornering capabilities of the car, then maybe it is engine torque...
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on January 04, 2014, 07:32:31 PM
Oh, I exploited it Larry. I exploited the H*ll out of it. ;)

Jim
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: classic conversions on January 04, 2014, 10:47:10 PM
I did not know that Jim's car ever run................................Just kidding Jim LOL

Forces do have an effect on cracking material, but vibration is the biggest culprit on stress, does not matter how smooth the engine is or how good the mount are.

Take a look at the CB B frame mounts and how they were welded, that is how any mount that is welded to the sheet metal frame rail should be fabricated. for any engine that is going to have the mounts welded to the rail.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: TXS67BGT on January 05, 2014, 08:15:51 AM
agree with bill, vibration is the major factor in stress cracks, continual back and forth working of the metal. the bigger area you spread the load onto, the less likely a crack, no abrupt or straightline ends to the reinforcement plate the better, hence diamond shaped plates, round the corners and stop the edges of the backing plate where the base structure has a change in material direction
FIREWALLANDFRAME001.JPG
FIREWALLANDFRAME006.JPG
struct1.JPG
1st pic shows what was removed, 2nd general idea of material added back and 3rd is some doodling I did to get an idea of tying the structure together. hope this may help
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on January 05, 2014, 11:41:38 AM
Thanks Bill, you're so kind. ;0

Jim
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on January 06, 2014, 10:24:25 AM
Made more progress yesterday. I modified the engine side mounts to fit inside the gussets I'll be adding to the frame side mounts and drilled them for the through mount bolts. Still need to complete the transmission mount and add the gussets to the frame mounts. Inching my way there.

Again, I appreciate all the great comments/feedback!

Scott
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on January 08, 2014, 09:09:41 PM
QuoteJim's car has by far the widest tires (and hence the largest expected cornering forces) of any of the converted MGBs

Well, hopefully his new tires will be stickier than those old hard shoes he's been sliding around on.

I usually find it hard to argue with Larry, but............. we really need a good Skidpad Competition!  ;)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on January 13, 2014, 08:24:29 AM
Although it isn't obvious in the picture below, the motor is actually bolted into the car finally!

LS4BoltedIn.JPG

So the engine is exactly where it will live now. Here are some pictures of an engine mount and the transmission cross member in place.

LS4MotorMtBolted.JPG

LS4TransMount.JPG

I decided to wait on the mount gussets we discussed earlier until I'm sure the steering is where it will ultimately live and that won't happen until the manifolds/headers are built. So those will be next. Here are the initial cut outs for the exhaust.

LS4ExhaustCutOuts.JPG

I'll go into more detail on what I have in mind for those in my next post.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on January 19, 2014, 08:33:03 PM
Unfortunately, it was a little too cold this weekend to work out in the garage so I went to plan B. I've been reserving/planning some of the tasks that can be done inside just in case. I worked on the throttle body, cleaning it up a bit and flipped the throttle shaft lever around for a RWD application. It's originally from a 2000+ Northstar. Here's a picture of it.

LS4NSThrottleBody.JPG

I also worked on the wiring harness a little. I'm 3/4 done with removing unneeded wires and adding missing wires. This is a little out of sequence and I'll add more about it later..oh well. I'm using the very common "0411" PCM which I got off of a 4.3 S-10 in the junkyard...also got the wiring harness from the same vehicle. Of course I need to get the correct code for an LS motor flashed onto the PCM as the 4.3 code won't do at all. I've communicated with Sinister Performance about getting that done when I'm ready. The guy really seems to know what he's doing. Anyway, the wiring varies on this PCM from application to application so adjustments are needed. It's actually pretty easy to remove add wires from the PCM plugs. Here's a picture of removing a wire.

LS40411Plug.JPG

This view is with the retainer's removed from the plug. Once you get them off you simply push the wire up and it pushes the connector out of the plug...no special tools required. To add a wire you push the wire down into the plug, through the seal and then carefully spread the plastic retainer a little to allow the connector to seat. There are two plugs, one has blue retainers the other red. Each plug has 80 slots for a total of 160. The nice thing is they all are numbered as you can see from this next shot.

LS40411Numbers.JPG

This is the current status of the harness. :)

LS40411WiringMess.JPG

It actually isn't nearly as bad as it looks. All the wires are numbered and there are plenty of wiring diagrams around to help with the harness construction. I need to finish going through one more row adding/removing where needed and then I'm going to label the wires and then I can start assembling the harness. It is time consuming. I've got about 2.5 hrs. into it so far

It's supposed to warm up a little so I hope to get out in the garage tomorrow and start the headers/exhaust.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Jim Stabe on January 19, 2014, 08:58:12 PM
Looking at your last picture - I feel your pain

Wiring1.JPG

Wiring2.JPG
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on January 20, 2014, 08:01:28 PM
QuoteLooking at your last picture - I feel your pain

:-) believe it or not I actually enjoy wiring...not sure I'd want ro do it for a living though.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on January 21, 2014, 02:09:13 PM
>  :-) believe it or not I actually enjoy wiring...not sure I'd want ro do it for a living though.

...yeah, that's sorta how it starts out. Then it begins to slide downhill. Do enough of it and you *can* learn to hate it, just takes practice.

Jim
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on January 21, 2014, 02:50:49 PM
You guys are scaring people with those wireballs! LOL They are all going to go back to carbs now!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on January 26, 2014, 07:57:53 PM
Didn't get out to the garage again this weekend...it seems to be getting colder rather than warmer...oh yeah, it is winter isn't it. :) So I worked down in the basement again on the wiring harness and my radiator. This first picture shows things a bit more organized than the last picture I published.

LS4BeginngHarness.jpg

All the unneeded wires are removed and 99% of the remaining are labeled. As you can see they are bundled into the beginnings of a stand alone harness. It's to the point that I can start assembly of the harness as soon as I get some measurements off the car. It will be very short as I'm going to mount the PCM under the dash on the passenger side.

An LS motor requires a radiator with a 1 1/4" inlet and a 1 1/2" outlet as well as a port for the steam vent tube. My radiator had 1 1/4" inlets/outlets and no allowance for a steam tube so it had to be modified. The first picture shows the installation of the steam vent port.

LS4SteamVentTube.jpg

A member here sold me a pair of 1 1/2" fittings one of which worked out perfectly. This next picture shows how the 1 1/2" outlet was added.

LS2RadiatorOutletMod.jpg

Here is the completed radiator. Still needs to be pressure tested. It wasn't very difficult to do at all...very pleased with the way it turned out.

LS4CompletedRadiator.jpg

Bit by bit it's getting there.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on January 27, 2014, 06:52:05 AM
Looks good Scott! What was the original application for the radiator?
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on January 27, 2014, 07:50:30 AM
QuoteWhat was the original application for the radiator?

Jim, not 100% sure but I suspect it's a 6 cylinder Ford Mustang radiator. I got it essentially new off of Craigslist from a guy cleaning out his garage. Paid $20.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on February 02, 2014, 07:12:32 PM
Finally got out to the garage and got started on the headers/manifolds. Here are a few preliminary pictures showing what I have in mind. I have about 5 hrs. into them so far. Keep in mind I am very slow.

LS4InitialHeader2.JPG

LS4InitialHeader3.JPG

Obviously I have a ways to go. This is where I ended up at the end of the day today. I'll document my progress as it is made. I am under no illusions that these are anything more than a way to route the exhaust gases out of the engine and into the exhaust pipes. These should get me going however. I'll revisit the headers in phase 2 a couple of years down the road.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on February 09, 2014, 08:02:59 PM
More work on the manifolds. I don't believe I mentioned this but I'm using 1 5/8" pipe running into 2" exhaust pipe...not far from what the factory used for this motor. I've got the driver's side fabricated and tacked together pretty much, just need to finish welding everything up on it. Here are a few pictures.

LS4Manifold1.JPG

LS4Manifold2.JPG

Not my best work but I'm trying to get them done quickly and make sure they don't leak. To make what you might describe as a collector I did the following, sorry I didn't get a picture before welding. I'll try to remember when I do the passenger side.

LS4Collector.jpg

What I did was cut down the vertical line, there is another one 180 degrees behind the visible line. Then mostly cut the horizontal line, leaving a small section on each side and spread the two half's to fit onto the manifold. Hope this makes some sense.

I'm actually moving pretty quickly compared to when I built my V6 equal length headers. Those took pretty much the whole winter/spring season (Jan-May) to build and I still ended up rushing at the end to get the car on the road for the V8 meet. Funny thing was that particular year my HTOB gave out just before the meet so I ended up missing it anyway...very frustrating.

This might be a good time to review where things stand. I'm making good progress but I'm not where I hoped to be at this point in time. (Are things ever on schedule in this hobby? :-) ) My goal is still to make Colorado Springs but I'm not going become a slave to a schedule. I actually really enjoy the process...love to work with my hands. Once you add a hard completion date to the mix it suddenly stops being fun...been there, done that. So whatever time is takes is what it will take and we will see where we are at the beginning of July.

So here are the major tasks that remain:
1. Finish the manifolds/exhaust
2. Complete the wiring
3. Put the firewall/cross member back together
4. Address the front accessories (water pump, alternator and pulleys)
5. Replace the fuel pump with a unit that will run an LS motor
6. Prepare the motor:
     a. Replace the timing cover
     b. Replace both front and rear crank seals
     c. Check the bellhousing run-out
     d. Measure for and mount the clutch
I'm sure I'm forgetting something but these should cover the major things that are left. Lots of little details, of course. It might not sound like it but I'm very happy where things stand and I haven't run into any show stopper's to this point. Let me know if you have any questions.

Scott
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: 74ls1tr6 on February 09, 2014, 11:16:19 PM
Scott,

Good progress. Is it possible for you to at least run 2 1/2" off the collector back to the back? These engines respond well letting the air out. Just a thought!

My headers are 1 5/8" primaries going to 2 1/2" at the collector (it is choking my exhaust airflow). The more I read I should be at 1 3/4" primaries minimum to 1 7/8"  and then running 3" on out at the collector. These LSX engines want to breathe

 I'm going to run 1 3/4" on Brenda's GT and try going bigger on the way out half way down underneath the car to help the engine have better exhaust airflow.  It is a Bummer because I bought everything in 2 1/2" except the mufflers. So my thought was to use the 3" oval pipe going into a 3" muffler after an X pipe for clearance.

Also, I have now 2 Ls6 intakes, 28lbs stock injectors and TB, oh I think you are fly by wire right...Hmm that is 58 tooth wheel on the crank instead of 24 . You might want the LS6 intake, It would do wonders for your engine.

Here is some very cool information about a swap that uses the same engine as you. It has some awesome fabrication going on.
An 88 Fiero (sp) LS4 swap   http://ls1tech.com/forums/conversions-hybrids/1588653-88-fiero-formula-ls4-f40-6-speed-swap.html
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on February 10, 2014, 01:23:30 PM
Calvin,

Thanks for the feedback! I'll answer below:

QuoteIs it possible for you to at least run 2 1/2" off the collector back to the back? These engines respond well letting the air out. Just a thought!

Yeah, I know this isn't optimal. I have an existing exhaust which is 2" pipe going into a Y and then to 2 1/4" out the back. I'm going to keep that for now just to make things easy. Down the road I'll want to build a serious exhaust, probably dual.

QuoteAlso, I have now 2 Ls6 intakes, 28lbs stock injectors and TB, oh I think you are fly by wire right...Hmm that is 58 tooth wheel on the crank instead of 24 . You might want the LS6 intake, It would do wonders for your engine.

Absolutely will be replacing the intake down the road. To make things easy and to get the car on the road I'll be sticking with the stock intake for now. I have a 24 tooth wheel on the crank (black crank sensor).

QuoteHere is some very cool information about a swap that uses the same engine as you. It has some awesome fabrication going on.
An 88 Fiero (sp) LS4 swap [ls1tech.com]

I followed this build over the past couple of years. Lots of good information. Really admired his fabrication skills too. Also like the power he's getting out of the LS4. :)

Anxiously waiting to see photos of Brenda's B!

Take care

Scott
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on February 10, 2014, 04:32:50 PM
Scott, Headers look nice! Kind of a Tri-Y design. Later on you can replicate with bigger pipes. Are you going to have them coated (Jet Hot) to help relieve the heat a bit. Good work!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on February 10, 2014, 07:15:08 PM
QuoteAre you going to have them coated (Jet Hot) to help relieve the heat a bit.

Jim,
Thanks.

No plans to coat them at this time.

I've got some family things coming up so there won't be much progress over the next couple of weeks I don't think. :(

Take care

Scott
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on February 14, 2014, 11:56:16 AM
Hmm, consider it Scott.

Coated heaters in an MGB go a long way toward helping prevent overheating.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on February 18, 2014, 09:57:15 PM
QuoteHmm, consider it Scott.

Coated heaters in an MGB go a long way toward helping prevent overheating.

Carl and/or anyone, can you go into the specifics on how this would help? I can see if you aren't moving and your fan isn't running that having more heat in the engine bay might cause the engine temperature to rise faster. I don't see much advantage if you're going down the road or if your fan is running though.

Seems like the money could be better spent elsewhere.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgbreis on February 19, 2014, 01:00:26 PM
As an alternative to the bright (expensive) ceramic coating, I have had good luck with the black satin coating from Techline.

http://www.speedwaymotors.com/Tech-Line-Coatings-Black-Satin-Ceramic-Header-Coating-4-Oz,25581.html
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: britcars on February 19, 2014, 02:45:03 PM
I've ben using Tech Line coatings for many years.  Good stuff.  You can buy direct from them and save $$$.

http://www.techlinecoatingswebstore.com/Exhaust_Coatings-Exhaust_Coating_Black_Satin_Header_Coating_4oz.html
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on February 19, 2014, 05:24:56 PM
I'll endorse Techline too. I've used their CermaChrome with excellent results but they have a no-polish version that would be easier and claimed to be about as good.

Jim
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: rficalora on February 19, 2014, 11:20:23 PM
a bit off topic of the thread, but does the ceramachrome look like chrome - as in is it a viable alternative to plating.  Plating prices seem to have about trippled in recent years.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on February 23, 2014, 12:55:27 PM
QuoteCarl and/or anyone, can you go into the specifics on how this would help? I can see if you aren't moving and your fan isn't running that having more heat in the engine bay might cause the engine temperature to rise faster. I don't see much advantage if you're going down the road or if your fan is running though.

In a perfect world, we are always moving down the road.  No stop lights, no traffic jams, no incredibly slow drive-thrus. :)  These days you can just about count on some kind of traffic issue on the interstate when traveling.

I can't state that you will have big horsepower gains with ceramic headers. Jet Hot & Swain Coatings do claim better than 50% reduction in radiant heat & surface temps of the headers. That equates to a significant reduction of underhood temps when not moving. Might help with too warm footwells in the Summer, too. For those that don't have holes in their fenderwells, the fan is not always able to push all that hot air out of the engine compartment.

In 13 years my car has never, ever overheated. Even in Texas.  Ceramic coated headers & Y-pipe, engine driven fan (instead of puny aftermarket electric), & no holes in the fenderwells. Of course, my car doesn't make much HP, either.

 Scott, I understand since you plan to build another set of headers. I'm sure you will be coating those. They will also last much, much longer with an inside/outside coating.  ;)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Moderator on February 23, 2014, 04:09:33 PM
I wish Doug Brown were still with us. (Really good guy! Sadly, he passed away shortly after attending our 2012 meet.)  Doug owned <a href="http://powdertechcorp.com/">Powder Tech</a>. His guys applied an Electroless Nickel plating to my fuel rail, throttle linkage, etc.  Doug and I had also discussed the idea of using the EN on my exhaust headers, after I get around to building them. One big advantage of EN is that it coats the inside and outside of a part equally. Traditional plating leaves the insides of tubes with little or no protection. As I recall, Doug felt that the EN coating would protect my headers very well indeed. However, the color of the headers would be affected by heat. (I think I recall him saying that they'd yellow more than my fuel rail, etc.  Typically the Harley Davidson crowd won't accept yellowed chrome, but I couldn't care less.)   EN should be significantly cheaper than conventional chrome plating. It doesn't have the environmental issues, and thus the waste disposal costs. The key to a pretty coat of chrome is prep - lots of polishing labor beforehand and more between layers - and chrome shops generally want to keep polishing in-house so they can control quality and also make more money. With EN, you'll probably do nearly all your own prep and there's only one layer. The shops that do EN are typically less concerned about getting a show quality finish, and more concerned about meeting industrial performance requirements. We also talked about how EN could be applied before a ceramic / powder coat coating. When I finally get around to building a new set of headers, I'll look into EN again and let you guys know what I find out.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: britcars on February 23, 2014, 10:42:14 PM
Carl, I used Tech Line's Cermakrome on my headers.  They were blasted with glass beads after curing in an old kitchen oven. Came out sort of a semi-gloss finish.  Five years old with no issues yet.
I also used their PowerKote on the piston tops and combustion chambers (Rover 3.5) and their Dry Film Lubricant (DFL) on the cam, bearings and piston skirts.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: 302V8 on February 25, 2014, 07:37:40 PM
Your LS4 conversion is looking fantastic Scott ! Well done.
Keep the photo's coming...........

Cheers
Pete
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on February 26, 2014, 07:33:08 AM
Thanks Pete, I appreciate it. Just got back from vacation so I need to get back at it.

Scott
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: pspeaks on February 26, 2014, 02:30:32 PM
As we're discussing header coatings I don't think this is much off topic.  I'm having my headers ceramic coated and was told even with a coating the heat has to go some place...well, that sounds reasonable to me.  Apparently the hot spot is where the header connects to the exhaust pipe which is in the area of the front wheel and brake area.  Has anyone experienced a problem with this or is the powder coater just being couscous?


Paul
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on February 26, 2014, 03:25:50 PM
Paul, I had both the the headers & the Y-pipe ceramic coated. Hopefully most of the heat goes out the tailpipe.  :)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on February 26, 2014, 03:36:48 PM
You will have a hot spot somewhere down the pipe past the header, I don't know for sure if this happens with equal length headers though and may check that out later. Anyway the hot spot is where you put your crossover pipe if you have one. The ceramic coating heat shield effect is enough to make the difference between an instantaneous burn on contact, and being able to pull away unharmed.

Jim
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on March 09, 2014, 09:15:19 AM
Got back out to the garage yesterday, finally! I was a little under the weather with a virus last weekend although I did get some work done on the wiring harness. As you can see below, I got the right hand side manifold fabricated and about halfway welded together.

LS4PassHeader2.JPG

I'm about 2/3 done with the exhaust at this point and the most of the time consuming fabrication has been completed. I hope 1 or 2 more sessions will get it there.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on March 09, 2014, 10:23:02 AM
Scott, those headers look good enough that you may decide not to replace them! Most would be quite thrilled with what you have constructed.

Jim
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: hirot on March 09, 2014, 10:57:09 AM
Paul, I wrapped mine, I don't think we do coating (easily) over hear yet. The headers are wrapped to the bottom of where they all join together. Initially I didn't wrap where the 4 pipes join at the top and the point between the pipes glows cherry red....worrying....wrapped that bit quickly.
The exhaust/header joint doesn't appear to go red or get too hot. However, you don't half get hot feet when you stop in traffic and I mean hot. I wrapped the brake/fuel pipes and wiring near the headers using the slide on tubing and all seems OK. You can hold the headers when the engine is hot.

Still not sure whether it was all a good idea in that I reckon the headers will corrode/crack as all that wrapped heat isn't healthy.

Scot your conversion looks wonderful.

Ian
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on March 09, 2014, 07:03:10 PM
Scott, Looking good!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: RMO 699F on March 09, 2014, 08:31:12 PM
Good work Scott!!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on March 09, 2014, 09:27:05 PM
Thanks for the compliments everyone, I appreciate it!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: 74ls1tr6 on March 10, 2014, 12:03:37 PM
Question Scott?

Where you engine is mounted now, would there be enough room to run the header collector, down along the frame rail along with the primary tubes? I'm going to attempt this if it is possible with our GT!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on March 10, 2014, 03:05:30 PM
Calvin,
Interesting question. Quick answer is no. Where the engine is sitting at the moment, I don't see how you'd find room for 4 pipes in any configuration. Believe me, I HATED cutting into the fender well so I thought long and hard about how it could be done. I believe I could have snaked a 2 inch pipe between the starter and the motor mount on the passenger side but only just...I don't believe a 2.5 inch pipe would fit. On the driver's side, depending on where you place your steering, there is a bit more room along side the engine. I considered building something similar to what I have now and routing the header pipe around the outside of the steering shaft and then down and out the bottom. In the end, it would have taken more time to do that and if I ever hoped to go to a real set of headers, I would have to go through the fender well anyway. That's how I ended up where I am.

It might be possible if you moved your engine rearward another 3 or 4 inches and went with head mounted motor mounts. You would still have to get creative with routing your header pipe though and you might have to go with a smaller diameter header pipe than you'd like to get it all to fit. I think it's one of those things where you'd have to try it to see if it would work. I'd be very interested to see what you come up with...hope you share some pictures with us.:)

Scott
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on March 16, 2014, 06:39:34 PM
Made a little more progress again this weekend. This first shot shows the right hand side manifold pretty much welded up. The only welding remaining is the front primary tube (#2) to the flange. Not real happy with the welds but there shouldn't be many leaks if any. I'll check for leaks after I finish the front tube.

LS4PassSideHeaderDone.JPG

This next picture shows the other side of the fender well.

LS4PassSideExhaust.JPG

Didn't quite have the time to finish the exhaust back to the existing portion I have done but really close. I hope one more session will get me there for both sides. It is time consuming but I'm not complaining.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: classic conversions on March 18, 2014, 06:57:46 PM
You just increase your engine torque  with the Tri Y header set up. nice.

Planing on doing the similar for the headers for our V8 Ford kit.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on March 26, 2014, 07:54:40 PM
Got to within about 2-3 hrs. of completing the headers/manifolds and joining them up with my existing exhaust. Here is the drivers side in the wheel well.

LS4WheelWellDS.JPG

Except for completing the welding on the collector flange on this header/manifold, both sides are complete. I just need to finish the driver's side down pipe back to the existing exhaust and I should be there. I'm going to hold off for just a little bit on the O2 bungs. I want to get the wiring routed to make sure I have them in the optimum spot. This next picture gives an overhead view of the engine with the manifolds in place.

LS4EngineHeaderTop.JPG

This next picture shows a top view of the engine/firewall. (I suddenly got the idea of doing overhead shots if you haven't noticed :) )

LS4TopFirewallView.JPG

So I've been planning how I want to handle the remaining tasks and decided to finish the wiring harness and getting it completely installed in the car...this really isn't a change. After the wiring will be putting the firewall back together and then doing most of the engine tasks which, as I've mentioned before, include a new timing cover, front and rear crank seals, swapping the valve covers from side to side, mounting flywheel/clutch and other minor tasks. The goal is to get the engine permanently installed and then handle the remaining tasks. If I get the above done by the beginning of June, I may have an outside chance of making the meet. I just noticed Larry's post about the dyno at the V8 Meet and I'd sure like to get this thing on one.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on March 26, 2014, 08:24:05 PM
Scott, thanks for the new engine bay view!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on April 01, 2014, 08:04:24 PM
The exhaust is more or less done. It was a bit of a frustrating weekend. What should have taken around 2 hours ended up taking about 5. Then I was just about done welding things up and ran out of welding wire. Oh well. I didn't get very good pictures either unfortunately. I ran out to the garage quickly during lunch and snapped a few. Here is one of the driver's side down pipe.

LS4Exhaust1.JPG

It and the rest of the exhaust are all bolted together and on the car so it was good seeing that. I'll need about another hour or so to finish welding it up.

I bolted the coils back on the heads and set the intake on the engine in preparation for continuing with the wiring. It's nice to see it sort of back together now with the manifolds in place....as I keep saying, bit by bit.

LS4WiringHarnessStart.JPG

I'm in the process of mounting the throttle body so I can get the wiring to it done. I hope to start to see some major progress on the wiring in the next couple of weeks. I've got a list of stuff to get at the junkyard including pieces for the harness so I'll have to plan a trip for this month.

On a slightly different subject, I have to get the drive shaft shortened by about a 1/2"-3/4". Found a local place that will do it so that is on the list now too.

I hope the pace picks up a little now that the weather is starting to warm up. I am really pleased that I was able to make as much progress as I did considering the lousy weather we've had this winter. I think I was able to accomplish something every weekend I had time to work on the car.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: 74ls1tr6 on April 02, 2014, 09:28:45 AM
Scott,

Keep going you are making good progress. The exhaust is a exhausting process for sure. You now will feel everthing will move faster. Can't wait to see first start up video. This will put a big smile on your face for all your labor involved. :-)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on April 02, 2014, 12:13:51 PM
QuoteCan't wait to see first start up video. This will put a big smile on your face for all your labor involved. :-)

Thanks Calvin. If I can catch a couple of breaks, I hope to experience that event sometime in June. :)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on April 06, 2014, 11:55:23 AM
Wiring is well underway now. Here is a front shot showing the current status.

LS4FrontWiringHarness.JPG

Here are a couple showing both sides.

LS4PassSideWiring.JPG
LS4DriveSideWiring.JPG

The injectors and coils are all wired up. The TPS, IAC, MAP, and crank sensor wires need to be shortened. Still need to wire up the MAF, cam sensor, O2 sensors and knock sensors. Of course a fuse box will be needed to power everything like the PCM, injectors, coils, fuel pump and O2 sensor heaters. The alternator will be mounted on the passenger side and that wiring will be added to the passenger side as well. I've got some high temperature wiring harness wrap that I'll use on everything once the harness is done. It's really starting to look like a part of the car now, if you know what I mean?
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: kstevusa on April 06, 2014, 01:26:29 PM
Scott, your work looks great!  I'll drink a DIckel & 7-Up  just to toast your craftsmanship!.   Guess Arite will have to wait also.  Until we meet again:-)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on April 07, 2014, 07:03:45 AM
Thanks Kelly! I'm all in for some Dickel & 7! :)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on April 13, 2014, 02:05:08 PM
Spent most of yesterday at the junkyard so didn't get a lot done wiring wise. Got some terminals for the fuse box I'm using and several plugs that were missing.....O2 sensor, knock sensor,  and alternator. Also got an alternator mount from a V6 car that will be adapted to the LS4 and picked up a throttle cable and throttle pedal too. I'll go into more details about these things later on. Of course I forgot something even though I had it on my list...OBD2 data link connector, oh well.

Did get something accomplished though, pretty much finished the throttle body adapter. Here's a picture of the throttle body in place.

LS4ThrottleBody.JPG

Here's one with of the adapter plate itself.

LS4ThrottleBodyAdapterPlate.JPG

I realize it's not perfect...the whole build is "blue collar" to some extent, especially compared to what Calvin and Brenda are doing, but I'm not taking the time to make things perfect. What is there will work and that is what is important to me at this point.

Just about everything is in here now so the wiring can be completed. For the next couple of sessions that will be the focus. I'm going to take Jim Stabe's suggestion and go with the F6 wiring loom stuff. Should look good.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on April 13, 2014, 06:25:33 PM
Scott, You're making steady progress! I'm looking forward to the water pump/front pulley solution. You will be starting it up before you know it!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on April 22, 2014, 09:14:51 PM
Made some great progress last weekend but not much you can really show with pictures at this point. Here is one that shows the completed wiring at the front of the motor.

LS4WiringHarnessProgress.JPG

Except for the O2 sensors VSS, and knock sensors, all the engine controls/sensors are wired. Next on the list is getting the fuse box squared away and the grounds securely bundled and bolted to the block. Here's a picture of the fuse box that will be used.

LS4FuseBox.JPG

The engine harness itself will be pretty much stand alone when it is complete. Power to the fuse box will come off the starter solenoid for those components that require power when the key is off and from a white wire on the B harness for those components that require key on power like the injectors, coils, and fuel pump. The alternator warning light will be wired to the alternator plug, the engine speed output from the PCM will be wired to the tach and the B coolant temperature sensor will mounted and wired into the passenger side head. That's pretty much it as far as the interface to the existing harness is concerned, not counting the wiring to the starter. Hope to have more pictures and details as progress is made.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBGT? on May 01, 2014, 03:40:41 PM
Hey Scott,
Really nice work!  You've got some talent!
I was wondering about how you were going to get filtered air into the throttle body.  May I suggest moving the radiator forward & tilting it back just like a late C4 Corvette, then use a late C4 Corvette air cleaner box.  It's specially designed for hood clearance with an oval intake over the radiator support as per the attached photos.
DSCN0108.JPG
DSCN0109.JPG
DSCN0110.JPG
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on May 01, 2014, 07:49:02 PM
Hey Artie! Glad you're here and thanks for the complement! Thank you for the suggestion as well! I'm actually moving in that direction.

I have three main goals in mind for this project; no modifications to the bonnet (hood for you Corvette guys :-) ), keep the steering rack in the stock location, and the radiator pretty much in it's current location. So I'm really going to be working to avoid moving the radiator forward. What I'm planning longterm is to fabricate a fiberglass snout very much like what you are suggesting which will go over the radiator and then fabricate an air box for a flat air filter in front of that....with the MAF in the middle...kind of hard to put into words. I'll be lowering the radiator about an inch. This will be an early phase 2 task though. For the short term, I'll use a rubber duct of some sort and a cone air filter. Won't look great but it will duct clean air to the engine. That's the plan for now.

On another subject, the wiring harness is ever so close. Hope to finish and get some pictures up soon.

Take care

Scott
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on May 01, 2014, 08:02:13 PM
Looks like you've been cleaning your engine again! :)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: 74ls1tr6 on May 02, 2014, 10:05:58 AM
Hey Scott,

I have the air cleaner somewhere that I got off the Camaro Ls1 from the Tr6. I will find it measure and post some photos of it. Maybe you can use it for the cost of shipping? It is setup like you had mentioned in your plan. Maybe you can make it work somehow. I believe I have the ducting that goes with it too.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on May 02, 2014, 10:48:28 AM
Hi Calvin,

If you have the time I'd love to see some pictures. Definitely interested if it looks like it could work.

Thank you!

Scott
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on May 02, 2014, 04:06:09 PM
I really like the over the radiator snorkle approach.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on May 04, 2014, 10:32:05 AM
QuoteI really like the over the radiator snorkle approach.

So do I Carl. It's going to be really tight though. It would be easier with the MAF behind the radiator so I'm thinking that I need to get an LS1 or LS6 manifold first as they place the throttle body further back. Again, this will be a phase 2 task.

Didn't get too much time to work on the car, it's the wife's birthday weekend. I did get the F6 stuff and started installing it on the harness. Here are a few pictures.

LS4Conversion068.jpg

LS4Conversion070.jpg

I really like the look and it's pretty easy to install too. You have to melt the ends once you cut them as it looks like the material could unravel. One other benefit is it comes apart easily if you need to get into the wiring for some reason.

The mess you see on the left in the second picture isn't nearly as bad as it looks. Everything is labeled and, for the most part, ready. The fuse box connectors are done except for the cooling fan relay signal from the PCM. Just need to put the connector on it. Also, the OBD2 connector power needs to be run to the fuse box as well. Other than that, 4 or 5 miscellaneous tasks need to be completed and the wiring should be done. I hope to get the motor ready to pull by the end of next weekend with a little bit of luck. Next up is putting the firewall back together.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: 74ls1tr6 on May 05, 2014, 01:26:07 PM
Scott still looking for the air box!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on May 05, 2014, 02:05:05 PM
Calvin, absolutely no rush at all. Please don't take time away from what you need to do for this.

Thanks!

Scott
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: 74ls1tr6 on May 07, 2014, 10:58:44 AM
Ok Scott,

Have some photo's of the air cleaner box off a 2002 Camaro Z28. Also have some of the throttle body tube, and if you need one a computer holder.
By the looks of the air cleaner box you could trim down the sides and it could be usable? Looks like it hangs on the radiator top?

2014-05-0707.36.40.jpg


2014-05-0707.36.57.jpg


2014-05-0707.37.28.jpg


2014-05-0707.37.40.jpg
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on May 07, 2014, 07:13:43 PM
Calvin, you have a PM!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb4tim on May 09, 2014, 11:47:14 AM
Something like an airbox is the kind of stuff I'm going to enjoy making with my fiberglass experience.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on May 27, 2014, 07:12:16 PM
Haven't been posting because there wasn't anything new to report. Still making steady progress.

The wiring harness is, for all intents and purposes, done. What remains is better done with the engine out of the car. As anyone who has done something like this before knows, there are a million details to deal with...all part of the fun in projects like this.

I use the original gauges and I was planning on drilling out a head to accommodate the "B" temperature sender. Fortunately, I came to my senses before making that stupid move. What I did was chucked the sender in my drill press, turned it down to the correct diameter, and threaded it to fit into the existing hole at the back of the passenger side head. This picture shows the LS temperature sender along side the "B" unit. The thread is 12mm X 1.5, FYI.

LS4TemperatureSensors.jpg

This one shows it in the head. I needed to make sure it was going to fit correctly before pulling the engine to put the firewall back together.

LS4MGTempSensorInstalled.jpg

So I'm making slow but steady progress on the firewall. I'm tackling the hard side first and expect the remainder is going to go more quickly. You can see my approach in the photo below.

LS4FirewallStart.jpg

I spent a lot of time measuring and fitting the steering column before welding things together and I'm going to tweak what you see here a little more before finishing that side. I'm using 16 gauge steel if you're wondering. I'm working now to finish the engine compartment completely. That includes finishing the firewall, cross member, running new brake lines, finishing the motor mounts, and mounting the steering rack and steering shaft. Hopefully another few weeks will do it.

One other bit of news is the car won't be ready for Colorado. I'm sure that isn't surprising to anyone, it was a long shot. So now I'll be shooting for the fall get together in Townsend. We will see.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BWA on May 27, 2014, 11:38:41 PM
Scott it is looking good!!
On my TR6 I used the stock TR6 temp sender and mounted it into the aluminum thermostat housing on the 3400.
My buddy that did the electrical work told me that it would have to be properly grounded.  I told him is it not grounded to the engine via the aluminum housing.  He replied that it is better to have a separate ground to the sender than have it ground through the aluminum body.  So I made a washer with a tag on it out of copper and it is held in place by the sender.  The ground wire then plugs onto the tag.

Cheers
Byron
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on May 28, 2014, 07:35:40 PM
QuoteOn my TR6 I used the stock TR6 temp sender and mounted it into the aluminum thermostat housing on the 3400.
My buddy that did the electrical work told me that it would have to be properly grounded. I told him is it not grounded to the engine via the aluminum housing. He replied that it is better to have a separate ground to the sender than have it ground through the aluminum body. So I made a washer with a tag on it out of copper and it is held in place by the sender. The ground wire then plugs onto the tag.

Thanks for the feedback Byron. Interesting. I ran the same sender on the aluminum lower intake on my V6 and it seemed to work without issue. Was your buddy worried about gauge accuracy? Is there that much of a difference between an iron block and an aluminum block? Just curious.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on May 28, 2014, 08:14:50 PM
Scott, I've heard of Teflon thread tape causing issues with grounding sending units. Hey, you're getting there!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BWA on May 28, 2014, 09:06:17 PM
Scott I talked to my electrical buddy and he has 2 reasons:
1/ On the 3400 all sensors that attached to aluminum bodies came from GM with both a power lead and a ground lead.
2/ With dis-similar metals you get corrosion issues, oxides that build up and create resistance.  Aluminum is bad for this.

On your fuel lines will you have to go to  larger lines for the bigger thirsty er er er engine?

Cheers
Byron
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on May 29, 2014, 06:47:48 AM
Jim,

Thanks. Still have a little ways to go but progress is steady.

Bryon,

Sounds like a really good idea and I"m not trying to discount it but interestingly, the grounds from the sensors go to the grounds in the PCM which usually are grounded to the engine. Mine are all to a common point on the passenger side head.

I'm already running 3/8" line for my supply (from my V6 swap) and that is what the LS4 needs so I should be good there. It's a returnless system so I'm going to run a Corvette fuel filter/regulator which has a single 3/8" outlet to the engine but allows you to run a pump that recirculates and it has a 3/8" supply and 5/16" return on the tank side. I'll go into more detail when I get to that point. I'm in the process of acquiring what I need for the fuel system now as a matter of fact. The AN fittings aren't cheap!

Scott
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on June 10, 2014, 09:10:33 PM
One inch at a time! So I'm still putting the firewall back together. It's pretty tedious work but I'm pleased with the result. I'm doing the most complex stuff first and I believe I just about have that part complete. Hope to have the firewall done at the end of this coming weekend. I'm taking my time because this has to be done right. It's amazing how fast 8-10 hours can go by. Here's where it sits at the moment.

LS4Firewall3.JPG

One thing I didn't realize about the MGB firewall before I started this is the heater plenum seems to be an important part the unit body in that area. It contains some of the thickest metal I've cut into.

I've been wondering about the bellhousing alignment and thought it would be better to do the measuring now rather than wait and then find an issue at an inopportune time. Good thing I did. So both the bellhousing face and bore runout were measured. I got about .014" on the bellhousing face and a measured value of about .020" on the bore runout which means it is about .010" off center. Both are out of spec so something will need to be done. There are a couple of ways to handle this, another bellhousing, offset dowel pins, and/or shimming the bellhousing. I checked into getting the bellhousing machined but that will be a last resort. Most likely I'm going to have to go with another bellhousing but I'm going to try shimming it first to try to get the bellhousing face parallel and then see where the bore runout ends up. The spec is 0" to .005". Oh, I can't seem to find the right sized offset dowels pins. The small GM pattern uses dowels that are about .71" in diameter, I believe, and they are hollow too. The available pins I could find are a much smaller diameter so it appears they won't be an option in this case. Should be an interesting exercise.

In other news my friend Artie, who I think most of you may know, will be coming out to Ohio during the week of the V8 meet and we're going to try to get some major stuff done on the car. For those of you who don't know him he's a British V8 wanna be and a Corvette guy. :-) My wife will be away so there shouldn't be a lot of distractions. Should be a lot of fun and I'm looking forward to it.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on June 10, 2014, 10:25:50 PM
Scott, I ran into that exact problem with a D&D bell I used on my original 215 conversion, although I think your runout is a little more. I made offset dowel pins on the lathe and cut a large screwdriver slot in the end so I could turn them. They weren't very hard to make but without a lathe wouldn't be easy. For the angular misalignment I wouldn't hesitate to cut the block face of the bell, even with a coarse file.

Jim
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on June 11, 2014, 06:21:14 AM
Thanks for the advice Jim.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: 74ls1tr6 on June 17, 2014, 05:05:42 PM
Scott,

Package should be there next Tuesday!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on June 17, 2014, 06:57:13 PM
Thank you Calvin!!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on June 23, 2014, 02:09:57 PM
Made some visible progress this weekend. The engine bay is done except for a small section near the starter, finishing the driver's side motor mount, some minor clean-up of the exhaust openings and preparation for paint. I'm very pleased with how it turned out. Here is where I am at the moment:

LS4FinishedFirewall.JPG

I also got the cross member buttoned up and the upper gussets welded to the passenger side motor mount:

LS4FinishedCrossmember.JPG

LS4FinishedPassMM.JPG

Next up is assembling the steering and getting the engine/transmission back in for a final check of clearances. Then getting the engine changes done and putting it into the car permanently.

Got another bell housing but haven't had a chance to check it on the motor yet. Keeping my fingers crossed on that one. The original bell housing was too far off to use without spending a lot of money.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on June 23, 2014, 03:07:29 PM
Scott, the only issue I can see there that you might want to think about has to deal with front/rear stiffness of the  column mount where the original sat in a cup. Don't know if it is an issue or not, could be a factor in crashworthiness maybe. I'm sure functionwise it'll be fine.

Jim
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on June 23, 2014, 05:01:45 PM
Jim,

Thanks for the feedback. It's pretty stiff, I used 16 gauge steel throughout. I haven't noticed any flexing at all to this point but I will double check and deal with it if I find anything.

Take care

Scott
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on June 23, 2014, 11:19:57 PM
Should be fine.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBGT? on July 01, 2014, 10:35:45 AM
Lookin' good Scott!  17 days until I'm there to help...
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on July 02, 2014, 06:20:43 AM
Looking forward to it Artie! Continuing to make slow but steady progress.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on July 07, 2014, 12:41:58 PM
Made more progress over the last two weeks. I'm tackling easier, less time consuming things now so more tasks are getting done. The first set of pictures show the engine in place with the rebuilt firewall.

LS4CompletedFWOverhead.jpg

LS4CompletedFWSideViews.jpg

I still have a few minor things to complete in the engine bay but the list is getting pretty small. We are going to paint it when Artie gets here so next weekend will focus on getting ready for that.

I moved to the engine preparation tasks this past weekend. I swapped the valve covers from side to side. I did this so the vent lines on each valve cover matched up with the flipped intake manifold. I've had the engine for over a year but never opened it up. I was pleased with what I saw when I removed the first valve cover.

LS4ValveCoverRemoved.jpg

I also replaced the timing cover. The main reason I did this was the original LS4 timing cover has the cam sensor positioned 180 degrees from the position of the RWD LS motors. Obviously, the signal from the cam sprocket reluctor will occur at a different time. I did a lot of investigation but couldn't tell if the 0411 looks at a rising edge, falling edge or just an edge and didn't want to take the chance of finding out the LS4 cover doesn't work when everything was together. An added benefit is the water pump fits without having to modify the timing cover.

LS4TimingCoverWaterPump.jpg

Had other good news as well. First, I got my PCM back from Sinister Performance. Once everything is together, it should run. He based the tune off of 2001 Camaro/Firebird code. The second bit of news is I measured my new bell housing and it just meets spec. The face of the bell housing was out of parallel .005" and the bore just a shade less than .005".....all good.

The crankshaft has a locating bushing for the converter and I'm in the process of trying to remove it so I can install my pilot bearing. I believe I need a bigger slide hammer...it is a b!tch to get out of there....always something! :) Let me know if you have any questions.

Scott
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: ex-tyke on July 07, 2014, 04:54:16 PM
QuoteI believe I need a bigger slide hammer...it is a b!tch to get out of there....


Have you tried the grease and pilot shaft trick....ie pack the bearing cavity with grease insert, a pilot shaft of suitable diameter and hit the shaft hard with a hammer - hydraulic pressure should pop out the bearing.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: kstevusa on July 07, 2014, 06:09:58 PM
alternately, some people use Ivory Soap rather than grease and the clean-up is easier.  same principle, just not as messy.  Once you are successful. pour yourself a Dickel, job well done :-)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on July 07, 2014, 07:33:01 PM
Graham, Kelly

Thank you for the advice. I'm reading from several sources that there is an oil galley plug in the end of the crank in an LS motor. I can feel it if I stick my finger into the crank. It's sheet metal and there is a good chance it will collapse if I tried the grease/soap approach unfortunately. I just got back from an Autozone where I rented a big honkin slide hammer and a fitting made specifically for removing pilot bushings. I think this should do a bit better than my Harbor Freight POS.

I'm a firm believer in any excuse for a Dickel by the way! :)

Scott
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on July 14, 2014, 07:00:40 AM
Scott, A couple of questions. Is that the Camaro/Firebird water pump? Is your new bellhousing a 3.1 like the old one? You are getting closer all the time!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on July 14, 2014, 09:30:19 AM
Great call, Scott.

Apparently, some of the LS variants (maybe most) have gun drilled cranks. Pretty obvious if the crank is out of the engine (unlike Scott's). That soft plug in the back keeps the oil in the engine.  ;)  Therefore, the hydraulic method using grease, Ivory Soap, bread, etc. cannot be used.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on July 14, 2014, 10:39:02 AM
Jim,

I'm using the shortest pump available. It's from, I believe, an LS2 Corvette/GTO/Cadillac. The bellhousing is from a 94 S-10 2.2, same as the first bellhousing I used. I will have to notch the bellhousing for the starter pinion but it will only take about a 1/4" notch in the edge. I measured it this weekend but didn't cut it yet. I'll get some pictures eventually.

I did get the bushing out of the crank. It was actually easy with the proper tools. Took less than 5 minutes. Carl, I'll try get a picture but after looking at the "plug", it may not actually have one. It's difficult to tell. I wasn't going to take the chance with the hydraulic method though....that would have been a huge mess if things went bad.

Lot's of stuff going on work and car wise at the moment but I hope to have the motor "permanently" installed at the end of week after next when Artie is here. We will see.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: kstevusa on July 14, 2014, 11:10:09 AM
Fred, Barney and I were discussing the "Plug" and agreed the plug idea was rubbish.  another Bowtie secret we had not heard of.  Guess we would have screwed up the job and used the "old way"   All the progress has left us dinosaurs in the muck.   Guess that's why our engines are conventional.  Keep up the good work and hope to see you in CS.  We are traveling in "the Big Silver Bird"
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on July 14, 2014, 11:24:48 AM
Kelley,

If you were using an LS you would have researched it and come up with the same approach I'm quite sure. :) I don't think of anyone in our group as a "dinosaur".....it's a bunch of really smart people actually.

I won't be going to CS unfortunately....I am going to miss not seeing everyone.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on July 29, 2014, 08:32:00 PM
Lots of stuff happened over the last couple of weeks. I'll try to document the highlights here. First, Artie came in and was a huge help. His strengths complement mine and we work really well together. I was going at it pretty good before he showed up trying to get the engine bay ready. So the first thing we did was do one final trial fitting to make sure the motor went in with no issues. Good thing we did because we had to make a few adjustments to the motor mount gussets that were added to the upper part of the mounts. Here are a couple of pictures of the motor going in and how the radiator works with the position of the motor.

LS4Fitting.jpg

LS4Fitting2.jpg

One thing Artie did that I'll always be thankful for is to talk me into painting the engine bay. I was so focused on getting the mechanical side done that I didn't give it the thought it deserved. I hate to admit it but I was strongly considering a sponge brush and some Rust-Oleum. :) Anyway, Artie talked me down from that cliff. Here's a picture of the progression. One thing I didn't capture, unfortunately, was how hard Artie worked on cleaning up the engine bay. You can see the result of his hard work in the first shot below.

LS4EngineBayPaint.jpg

You can't tell very well from the pictures but it looks really good.

Artie also spent several hours cleaning up the engine. You can see from the first picture below how good it looks. I can't wait to see it in the car. The next couple of shots show the end of the crank (to complete the discussion from a previous post although you can't see in the hole very well) and the new pilot bushing installed.

LS4EngineAngles.jpg

So where do we stand at this point? In a pretty good place I think, all things considered. The car is actually going back together. We did encounter an issue with the pressure plate that slowed things down and prevented us from getting the engine installed. I'll go into some detail in my next post but I need to confirm a few things before discussing it here.

Things may slow down a bit because I promised my wife I'd back off a little after last week. For what it's worth, I'm estimating about another 40 hrs. give or take to get the car back on the road. Lots of little details left. I couldn't be more pleased with how things are progressing.

Let me know if you have any questions.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on July 29, 2014, 09:47:52 PM
Way to go, Artie! That clean engine bay will make all the difference. Just don't go by mine. :)

40 hours? Sounds like you can see the light at the end of the tunnel, Scott!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on July 30, 2014, 09:47:48 AM
That looks really good. You are going to be amazed at the difference.

Jim
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: pspeaks on August 02, 2014, 12:23:22 PM
Scott, as a Ford guy, I've only owned one Chevy engine in my life, I know absolutely nothing about the LS series, but as an amateur fabricator and unofficial student of engineering, I totally enjoy this thread.  Thank you for sharing it with us!

Paul
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on August 03, 2014, 08:25:17 AM
Thanks for the comments everyone.

Carl, I'm really bad at estimating time so don't hold me to 40 hrs. The end is in sight though.

Paul, glad you are enjoying it. One good thing about sharing it here is the audience, for the most part, understands the need/desire we have to do projects like this. My wife does not get it at all! :)

Scott
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: pspeaks on August 03, 2014, 05:12:15 PM
After installing the drive shaft and crawling out from under my GT, my buddy who owns the shop where it was done said "I would never have believed you could do it".  After seeing the pictures and reading the posts, I can only imagine the challenges you face.  Job well done!!!


Paul
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Charles on August 04, 2014, 07:12:56 PM
I too have enjoyed following your time building your new ride, thanks for sharing.  After missing CS you will need to come on down to Townsend and let some of us LOOK,TOUCH and FEEL. You will enjoy tooling around and smelling the new burn off.


Charles
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on August 04, 2014, 08:03:37 PM
Thanks Charles! I've had my room booked since June and I'm going to try to make it. I may come even if the car isn't done.

Paul, I'd enjoy seeing pictures of your work. :)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on August 06, 2014, 09:42:48 PM
I've been thinking about the point Paul made about the challenges we face during these projects. To me it seems like every problem is a series of smaller problems and the decisions you make to solve them are compromises that may create other problems down the road. The problem solving is one of the things I like most about the process. It is about impossible to document every problem in detail...I think it could end up being too much information. Anyway, this prompted me to discuss the flywheel/clutch in a bit of detail. Hopefully it won't be too boring. :) The components that go into it require lots of decisions especially since there are no "stock" components that were used on the LS4. It only came with an automatic. So, in my mind at least, there are probably more opportunities to screw up here than any other sub-assembly I'll be dealing with.

I had a couple of long conversations with LSC Performance, who made my flywheel, about what I needed. I sent along an S-10 flywheel for the starter ring gear and as a basic example of what was needed. For some reason, I had it in my mind that it needed to be a bit thicker than the sample flywheel and we discussed this. LSC recommended we just duplicate the dimensions of the S-10 unit and I decided to take his advice. Luckily, it seems to have been the right decision. Based upon how I implemented the starter mount, I have about an 1/8" or so of wiggle room. If I had gone thicker than that I would have had to modify the bellhousing more than I would have wanted to. Any thinner and it would have interfered with the starter mount. As it stands now it is just about right. Speaking of the starter and bellhousing, here is a picture of the modification to the bellhousing that was needed to account for the starter pinion. It isn't too bad.

LS4BellhousingMod.jpg

As for the clutch, here are some pictures of what I went with.

LS4Disc.jpg

LS4PressurePlate.jpg

I got it from Ram Clutches. Dale Knapke recommended that I go with Centerforce and I called them first. Very disappointed with the response I got from them....as soon as I explained what I was looking for they couldn't wait to get me off the phone. I don't deal with companies that treat me like that. Anyway, I based the clutch on what would fit into a Fiero 2.8 V6. Since those guys have been building lots of HP into them over the years there seems to be more than a few choices available. I explained the horsepower/torque I could be getting out of the motor and how I expected to use the car and they recommended what you see here. Again, I wasn't sure how it would all fit into the bellhousing or how it would interact with the flywheel position and transmission input shaft/bearing retainer. It was one of those things that I was just going to have to try to see if it would work. I'm certainly not declaring success yet but after some initial measurements and a trial fitting of the bellhousing/transmission to the motor it appears that it is going to work as expected.

This brings me to the issue we ran into a couple of weeks ago with the pressure plate. I'm using stock pressure plate bolts I ordered new from a dealer. They are 8 MM X 1.25. It seems that GM uses the pressure plate bolts to locate the pressure plate on the flywheel in their "small" bellhousing models like what was used in the Fiero. As I was playing with it during the trial assembly I noticed a lot of play in the bolt holes in the pressure plate. When I measured I got about 8.9 MM. The bolts measured about 8 MM. It just didn't seem right to me. So I did a lot of investigation and couldn't come up with anything conclusive. I confirmed from several sources that I was, in fact, using the correct pressure plate bolts. When I talked with Ram they stated that they have sold hundreds of these pressure plates over the years and didn't have any issues with them. I finally went to a local parts store and measured a stock replacement pressure plate and came away with the same measurement. So it appears that is how the manufacturer designed these components. I'm still not overly happy with the situation. I fabricated some spacers to take up the slack.

LS4PPSpacers.jpg

What I'm going to do is mount the clutch both with and without the spacers and put a dial indicator on it in both cases. Then it will be one of those "decision" times again. :)

I think this is starting to get a little long so I'll end it here. Let me know if you have any questions.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on August 07, 2014, 07:34:06 AM
Scott, Look for some stock Fiero pressure plate bolts. I think they have a shoulder behind the bolt head. You may have to use hardened washers under the bolts also as the stock flywheel was bored slightly. The solid hub clutch plate may require you to slip it a bit to start out. I always used a sprung hub on the street.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: pspeaks on August 10, 2014, 11:15:03 AM
Thanks Scott, I'm currently working on a "How It Was Done".  I hadn't planned on repainting but, as I had to replace the hood with a RV8, I might as well do some other body work as well like filling in the side lights and chrome trim holes.  This done with the cooperation of my health which is been a significant road block in my little MGB adventure.  


Paul
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on September 03, 2014, 08:53:34 PM
Wow, it's been almost a month since I posted any progress. Didn't mean to go that long. Progress has been made but the pace has slowed a little because of so much else that has been going on between work and home.

First, I did make a decision on the pressure plate issue. I decided to trust the GM engineers and go with the stock approach. I bolted up the pressure plate a few times and measured. It was centered every time. Also, after thinking about it, it didn't seem wise to add an unknown by using the spacers I made. So that phase is behind me now. It consumed a lot of time though.

The motor is bolted in and I started hooking up the wiring and doing some last minute routing and bundling. I still need to wire my wide band controller in. I'm going to try to wire the output of it into one of my unused rear O2 sensor pins on the PCM to see if I can log the wide band data along with the rest of the output. Should be an interesting exercise.  I didn't get any pictures as there really isn't anything to show at this point.

So the plan is to do the following, probably in this order:

Get all the wiring in place
Bolt up the starter
Assemble the exhaust
Get the fuel lines sorted and the new fuel pump in the tank
Fabricate the throttle pedal and throttle cable bracket
Miscellaneous things like adding oil to the engine/transmission, bolting on the shifter, etc.

At this point I may try to do a first start. Then the following things are left:

Fabricate the alternator bracket and pulley mounts at the front of the motor
Mount the radiator
Assemble and mount the intake tubing and MAF
Do the million other details that have slipped my mind at the moment! :)

Progress continues to be slow but steady and the to-do list is getting shorter. Most importantly, I'm still having lots of fun with the project and learning new stuff every day.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on September 04, 2014, 09:38:55 PM
Ran across this article and thought I'd share it. I found it very interesting for future reference. The LS2 cam looks pretty good!

http://www.carcraft.com/techarticles/1307_ls_cam_test_comparison/
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on September 05, 2014, 10:04:56 AM
Nice test. I like that they used the 5.3L for the cam comparison vs the larger 5.7 or 6.0L.

I think I prefer the early LS1 cam. Be good to lose a bit of torque off the bottom on an MGB to gain 63hp on top plus a 6500 rpm rev limit.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on September 05, 2014, 10:48:33 AM
Good point Carl. You could probably come up with a good used LS1 cam for $50. It's such a versatile platform, I really like it.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: TR6-6SPD on September 05, 2014, 01:33:10 PM
Scott,
I'll be attending LS Fest in Bowling Green this weekend. Live, breath and eat LS engines Saturday/Sunday.
https://www.holley.com/events/lsfest/
(next week is VTR in Dobson N.C.)
Carry on with your conversion. Looks great.
Ken
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: 74ls1tr6 on September 05, 2014, 08:09:10 PM
Sounds like fun Ken!

If anyone needs 2002 LS1 cams ....I have 2 stock one's in cam boxes that I have pulled out?

I'm running in my Ls1 and Brenda's Ls1 588/588 lift with 228/228 duration and 112 lsa. This cam is a good all round cam for the Ls1. The lower lsa brings to torque down to a lower rpm range. It still will make lots of power at high rpm. The duration isn't too high to mess with fuel mileage, and the bad idle issue with high duration cams.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBGT? on September 15, 2014, 01:38:36 PM
My opinion, I would choose the LS3 cam based on the statistical gains.  However, if you still stick with the LS1 I believe the later LS1 version (01 to 04) Calvin has is slightly better statistically than the earlier LS1 version.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on September 18, 2014, 07:24:14 PM
QuoteI'll be attending LS Fest in Bowling Green this weekend. Live, breath and eat LS engines Saturday/Sunday.

Ken, sounds like it could be a lot of fun, hope it was.


QuoteIf anyone needs 2002 LS1 cams ....I have 2 stock one's in cam boxes that I have pulled out?

Calvin, when the time comes for a cam selection, I'd love to pick your brain for a little bit.


Artie, thanks for the input. Maybe we can discuss in more detail in December?

So progress on the conversion is still being made but it's real hard to show in a photo. A lot of small, invisible stuff is getting done now. Here is the latest state of the engine installation.

LS4CurrentStatus.JPG

Starter is installed and wired up. Speedometer cable installed, clutch slave braided hose shortened and the slave has been clocked to fit better. All I need to do now is bleed it. Here is a picture for what it's worth.

LS4ClutchSlaveClearance.JPG

As you can see there is plenty of room.

My next minor milestone will be to power up the wiring harness and put a scanner on the OBD2 port to see what I've got. I still have to wire in the wide band sensor plug and finish the VSS wiring. Hope to get there in my next work session. I'm only getting one day a week to work on the car right now, unfortunately, and this coming weekend I'll be lucky to get a few hours in.....sucks actually. I can't think of a reason why a first start won't be possible towards the end of October but I almost hate to bring it up I'm so bad with estimating things. Anyway, I'll post another update soon.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on September 19, 2014, 05:24:50 PM
Scott, Good Progress! Looking forward to the start video. Did you replace the DOD lifters?
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on September 19, 2014, 08:31:34 PM
QuoteDid you replace the DOD lifters?

Thanks Jim. No, that's a phase 2 task. Much bigger fish to fry at the moment. It will be fun when I get to it though.

Take care
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on September 23, 2014, 08:59:32 PM
Got a little more time than I expected this past weekend. I was able to get the wiring harness powered up. So far so good. I had the IAT, CTS, MAP, and TPS sensors returning data. My O2 sensors got warm, hard to tell if they are working though. My fuel pump relay was energized for about 2 seconds at key on like it is supposed to do. I had 12 volts on both sides for the ignition and for the injectors. I bumped the starter for a moment with success. I didn't have any oil in the engine at this point or I would have tried to turn it over for a few seconds. I set the alternator in the engine bay and hooked the harness up to it. When I first hooked the negative cable up to the battery, my ignition warning light came on...this is with the key off. My first thought was WTF? So I nosed around for a little bit trying to figure out how that could be. Then it dawned on me that the alternator probably needed to be grounded so I tried that and everything was fine. Light comes on with key on and is off with key off. The other good thing was nothing started burning and the marshmallows I bought got to stay in the bag. :) It was good to see the car come partially back to life. I'm kind of feeling like if I added some fuel I would have a reasonable chance of the motor firing up. I'm far from declaring success at this point but at least things are moving in a positive direction.

LS4FirstWiringPower.jpg

Next on the list is getting the exhaust in place. I've identified some leaks in the headers I'm in the process of correcting. Shouldn't take a whole long time to get them sorted. Then it will be on to the fuel system.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on October 21, 2014, 08:21:25 PM
Hard to believe another month has gone by. I'm starting to sound like a broken record but I continue to make steady progress. The exhaust is getting pretty close. I got the driver's side done and I'm working on the passenger's side now. While I was at it I got my plug wires all squared away. This picture shows the finished product.

LS4PlugWiresExhaust.JPG

The 180 degree plug boots common to the LS motors wouldn't work very well with the exhaust and the space I'm working with in the engine bay. I decided to go with 90 degree boots. So I cut the 180's off of a new set of wires and added the 90's. Most all of you have done/seen this before but I thought I'd show how I approached it.

LS4PlugWire.JPG

LS4PlugWireCrimper.JPG

I used this Taylor crimper....you put it in a vise. It worked pretty good. Of course the last 4 looked better than the first 4 but all are secure and tested as good.

I've been doing little things toward the end of the day when I was tired. I got the clutch bled and it seems to work well. A little stiffer than stock but not bad at all. I mounted my PCM in the passenger foot well and I'm running my harness through the RHD pedal blanking plate and I started modifying the plate for the harness. I'll get some pictures as it get's closer. It looks like I might get a full day on Saturday to play with the car so I'm hoping to make some good progress then.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on November 12, 2014, 05:59:49 PM
Wow, I just noticed that this thread reached 15,000 views! Someone must be following this project?

So the fuel system isn't "complete" at this point but it is functional. What I mean by not complete is the lines/filter are all hooked up but not permanently mounted and my v6 fuel pump is still in the tank. It won't be sufficient for actually driving the car but should be ok for an initial start which is my current short term goal. I actually thought I had more pictures of the fuel system and I will share them when I get them but here's what I have for now.

LS4FuelFittings.jpg

You can see I've used the "secure" version of the AN push on fittings. The ends screw into the fitting which keep them from popping off the end of the line. I was surprised how expensive the fuel fittings were, didn't expect it. For my fuel pump, I will be using fuel hose designed to be used inside a fuel tank and that was outrageously expensive....oh well, I want it done right. This next picture shows the fuel filter/pressure regulator I'm using. I apologize that the picture doesn't show too much detail. The one that did show the detail was too blurry to use.

LS4FuelFilter.jpg

The filter was originally specified for a Corvette and has a built in pressure regulator. If you look closely you'll see that there are two push on fittings on then end that has the supply line installed. This allows you to use a pump designed for a two line system to supply an engine using a returnless one line system. I'll for sure get a picture of it installed and show you how I approached it.

So I put some hi-test in the tank and powered things up. I didn't push the return line securely onto the fuel filter so it popped off and I had some seepage from one of the unions in the steel line. Not too difficult to correct. I got the expected 58 lbs of pressure at the rails so was pleased with that. It was pretty much the end of the day at that point but I did try to start it with no luck. Haven't had a chance to do much troubleshooting but I suspect it isn't grounded sufficiently at this point. I could hear it try to fire so that is a good sign. I will go at it full steam this coming weekend. I did take a video of the first attempt and will hopefully get one when it finally fires. I'm pretty excited at this point.

Edit: corrected wording. Said fuel pump when I meant fuel filter.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Dan B on November 13, 2014, 11:00:05 AM
Good progress!  I am excited to see your car too, Scott.  You are like a Master Chef creating a gourmet.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on November 13, 2014, 06:28:26 PM
Thanks Dan! I liked the way you worked the "Chef" name in there! LOL. Hope to see you soon.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: kstevusa on November 13, 2014, 06:37:46 PM
When you guys quit blowing smoke at each other's rear, we can continue:-)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on November 13, 2014, 11:10:36 PM
QuoteWhen you guys quit blowing smoke at each other's rear, we can continue:-)

:)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on November 17, 2014, 10:44:44 AM
As I have mentioned in the past, making buckets of torque down low in the power curve makes no sense in a lightweight sports car. Traction will be an issue.

So, you might want to read this before picking out that new cam:

http://www.seight.com/torque.html
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on November 18, 2014, 06:43:52 PM
QuoteAs I have mentioned in the past, making buckets of torque down low in the power curve makes no sense in a lightweight sports car. Traction will be an issue.

So, you might want to read this before picking out that new cam:

[www.seight.com]


That was a great read Carl. Thanks for the link and the feedback. What you're suggesting is a great idea and something I'm going to pursue. I think we also talked about potentially configuring the PCM to help reduce timing (torque) under certain conditions, like mashing the throttle in first. I know this was possible with earlier versions of the GM code and suspect something similar is in the F-body code in my PCM. I'm for sure going to look into it.

Unfortunately, I didn't get out to the garage this past weekend. Went to a conference last week and picked up a bad cold there. My wife was insistent that I not go into the cold garage while I was sick. It about killed me on the one hand but it was kind of nice not doing anything for a weekend. That's pretty unusual for me. I did order a few more parts. :) So I'll be shooting for a first start next weekend. Hope to have a few evenings to work on the car during Thanksgiving week as well.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on November 19, 2014, 10:05:00 AM
I dunno, I always rather enjoyed having buckets of low end torque. Even not being able to deliver all of it to ground, sometimes that is the point.

Jim
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on November 20, 2014, 08:35:06 AM
QuoteI dunno, I always rather enjoyed having buckets of low end torque. Even not being able to deliver all of it to ground, sometimes that is the point.


Jim, I do realize you're just stirring the pot a bit but if I ever hope to beat out a 3.4 v6 I'm going to have to do something. :)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Dan B on November 20, 2014, 08:47:12 AM
He likes to cut donuts.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on November 20, 2014, 07:58:03 PM
It's not that so much as the 1 lane U-turn.

Jim
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: 74ls1tr6 on November 21, 2014, 10:46:12 AM
I'm with Jim on this one. I love to throttle control a car in the 1st 3 gears. ;)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on December 14, 2014, 10:33:01 AM
<iframe width="420" height="315" src="//www.youtube.com/embed/3kZfXo5BRC0" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: billymgb1000 on December 14, 2014, 10:54:00 AM
Congrats Scott
Isn't it so nice when a plan comes together. so what's left do you have the drive shaft all set ? I also noticed it sounds a little quite. Are you intending to have a sleeper?  Well all looks good so far good luck.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: 74ls1tr6 on December 14, 2014, 11:41:03 AM
Scott, Congrats on first start up video. Where is your water pump, you know I had to ask? I bet this feels real good for all your hard labor. These engines always start no matter how long they sit.

Awesome Scott!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Moderator on December 14, 2014, 11:42:20 AM
Fantastic!!!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: RMO 699F on December 14, 2014, 11:48:59 AM
Way to go Scott!!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Capt'n Moorgone on December 14, 2014, 11:53:31 AM
Great job Scott !  It's sounding like you'll be in Indy for sure! I like the frozen breath in your garage. Isn't winter in the Midwest a blast?   Mike
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on December 14, 2014, 05:05:57 PM
Atta Boy! Scott. Congratulations! Sounds Great!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on December 14, 2014, 07:58:55 PM
Thanks everyone! Here is another one with the O2 sensor screwed into the hole. I've got a hell of an exhaust leak to track down. You can see some evidence of it toward the end of this video. The first video is actually the first start. You can hear my wife come to the door to see what the noise was about....I'm trying to shush her and she proceeds to have a 10 minute conversation with me. LOL.

<iframe width="420" height="315" src="//www.youtube.com/embed/WfuSR0oJjLk" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

I'll do another post to detail the adventure I had the past couple of weeks but the bottom line was I had 2 wires crossed on the crankshaft position sensor.....that's a no start condition.

I'll try to address your questions:

Bill, the driveshaft is installed so theoretically, it should be able to move on its own at this point. I've got a little ways to go. Lots of small fabrication jobs at this point. I started the throttle cable today, I am getting there though. As far as the sound, it's difficult to capture on video. I don't think it's that quiet but I'm not looking for that open headers sound either though. I'm pretty sure my neighbors heard some noise! :)

Calvin, yeah it's pretty exciting to hear it come alive! I actually cleaned up the injectors before trying to start it. Soaked them in Seafoam and then used a 9 volt battery to work them a little. It sounded like a few of them were stuck as they didn't "click" right away. As for my water pump, I was thinking about saving some weight and going without one. Is that bad? :)

Mike, I'm giving up trying to predict when it will be ready but it seems like Indy mightbe doable. It actually wasn't as cold as it looked yesterday. It was 50 here today! Having said that, I just ordered cheap eBay insulated coveralls.....the Midwest can be challenging during the winter. :)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Charles on December 14, 2014, 10:35:32 PM
Scott, you are on the final lap.  I have been watching all the way, thanks for sharing. You called it fun sometime back, I think we all consider it fun. Again thanks for sharing.
charles
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on December 15, 2014, 10:17:03 AM
I know you are glad to see that. Tell you what though, this one will make your eyes wide. I know you will be careful, but even so I expect to hear back from you about just how much it surprised you when you do finally nail it. Congrats,

Jim
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on December 15, 2014, 10:33:05 AM
Final lap?  Looks like you are coming down the homestretch!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Jim Stabe on December 15, 2014, 05:07:19 PM
Scott

You should try to cure the exhaust leaks. I had some header flange leaks on my LT1 and screwed up the air/fuel balance at idle. I had to correct them before it could be tuned.

Try these http://catalog.remflex.com/ , they are the best I've seen and will seal up anything and they guarantee it. They are 1/8" thick and compress 50%
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on December 15, 2014, 07:21:15 PM
Great advice Jim. It will never run right with leaks. I'm suspecting the passenger side header isn't seated against the head for some reason. I need to pull it to figure out why. Those gaskets look great, I may have to breakdown and get a set. They aren't overly expensive either. Thanks for the tip!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Jim Stabe on December 15, 2014, 09:30:46 PM
I originally had a set of dead soft copper gaskets and they showed multiple black leak paths when I took them off. The Remflex don't leak at all.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on December 15, 2014, 09:38:16 PM
Interesting, plus you can buy the blank material.

Jim
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: kstevusa on December 16, 2014, 07:16:43 AM
Maybe i missed something, but doesn't anyone have their flange surface trued once they finish welding up thier headers? If headers are puurchased in the A/M, they can still be trued.  We used the Old Cyl Head machine;  One side required quite a bit to be removed to achieve a flat surface.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: theonlyiceman53 on December 16, 2014, 06:09:51 PM
Hey Kelly,
I build mine with the flange bolted to a spare cylinder head and haven't had any problems with sealing.  I always figured I would straightedge it and use a flapper wheel to true it up if I had to.  Don't even want to think about clamping it down in my mill!  
Cheers,
Bill
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on December 16, 2014, 08:25:35 PM
That's a good thought Kelly. I'll put a straight edge on it to check it. I'm betting the header itself is hanging up on something and I just didn't notice it. I haven't had a chance to look at it yet. I did that video at the end of the day and it wasn't apparent until then how bad it was. I'll get it off the engine first thing Saturday and take a closer look at it. I'm pretty sure I'm going to take Jim's advice on those manifold gaskets. They look like they will handle small imperfections really well.

So I've run the motor probably no more than 5 minutes total time and it's sounding better each time I start it. The audio recording isn't really capturing how it sounds but it is running smoothly with no obvious bad noises. Oil pressure is at 50 lbs. at idle. You never know with a junkyard engine. There was a date of October 2010 on the oil filter that was on the motor when I got it and the tiny bit of oil on the tip of the dipstick was really clean so I imagine that the car it came in was totaled not too far from that date and the engine has been sitting since. My cheap Chinese OBD2 cable gave out at the perfect time so I was unable to check for codes or take a log unfortunately. So I ordered another cheap Chinese cable to replace it. :)

I had a bit of an adventure as I was troubleshooting the no start condition. The first thing I checked were the grounds and couldn't see any issues there. I actually added another ground from the head to the body while I was at it. Next I checked the ignition wiring to make sure they were grounded and that the PCM control wires matched up to the correct cylinders. Same with the injector wiring. All was good there. I checked the voltage drop at the battery and was surprised that it was in the mid 8 volts while cranking. While trying to figure that out I noticed the ground cable eye that bolts to the body was cracked and the cable was hanging on by a thread...not good. So I replaced that with a much thicker cable and cleaned up the terminals and clamps while I was at it. That helped a whole lot. It got me to the low 11- high 10 volt range. The funny thing about it is the engine was turning over like it was a warm spring day the whole time. Anyway, I've got a battery kill switch I'm going to install and I'm going to run a cable to ground things at the transmission when I install it and that should make things even better. After all that, still no start. The next thing to check was the crankshaft position sensor which is behind the starter so that had to come off. Sure enough, two of the wires were crossed. I could have sworn I checked those. Funny thing is it was correct for the 4.3 V6 in the S-10 the harness came out of but not for the 0411 LS V8 motors. I spent time while I had things apart fixing a pesky fuel leak caused by a careless flare I did and tidying up the wiring that runs down the fender well. All things considered, all the troubleshooting was a good exercise and will result in a more reliable car in the end....all good.

The next few tasks are the throttle cable/pedal, which is in process now. Then then tweaking the transmission tunnel for the shifter...the engine is shifted back about an inch and a half from where the previous V6 motor sat. Then the fuel pump and a bunch of other small things like permanently mounting the PCM, putting the interior back together and adding the kill switch and the cable to the transmission. The largest fabrication task that is left will be the accessory mounts/brackets at the front of the motor. I've located a machine shop to handle one of the smaller tasks that I can't do myself. I'll give much more information about it as I get into it. I must be forgetting something but overall I'm closing in on it!

Gosh, as I'm proof reading this I realize I just wrote a book!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on December 17, 2014, 11:04:38 AM
Switched sensor leads is a common issue if using a VR sensor. Your voltage drop can be a real issue with an EFI system. Not unusual to have a motor that will crank OK but not have enough voltage to fire off. I'm not sure whether this is an issue with the coils (I suspect), the injectors, the ECM or the crank sensor.

Jim
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on December 17, 2014, 06:09:19 PM
Jim,
From what I'm reading, when you get to around 10 volts you start having difficulty firing the coils. The injectors seem to "fire" with a 9 volt battery so they may be more forgiving. A crank sensor signal is required for a start so I had a couple of issues going on. I'm anxious to see what it does once it gets into closed loop which won't happen until the cooling system is in place. Lots of details which is part of the fun.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: 74ls1tr6 on December 17, 2014, 08:56:13 PM
Scott, At minimum get your exhaust leaks taken care of between heads and 02 sensors. Its not as bad behind the 02 sensors to get it on the road, and get all the other stuff dialed in with the swap. That way your computer can do its job to keep it running smooth and idle right. Are you running a vss (vehicle speed sensor) sensor on your transmission? That can change idle once the cars starts to roll. Just some thoughts I went through.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on December 18, 2014, 07:42:35 AM
More good advice, thanks Calvin! Yes, I wouldn't even think about not using a VSS. I'm doing a home brewed one off the differential flange. Mounting it is one of those many small tasks that need to be done yet. I'll post some details about it when I get to it.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on December 18, 2014, 08:24:41 AM
Scott, Your swap is quite an achievement! As far as I know, the first LS4 RWD with block mounted starter! Others will soon follow.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on December 18, 2014, 10:17:46 AM
Seems to me you'd be better with a VSS mounted to the driveshaft near the transmission as it would not be moving around all over the place like the diff will. But then I suppose it will be moving forward and back. And a cable speedo would mean you can't use the electronic plug-in at the tailshaft. I think there was a combo cable drive VSS pickup but have no further info.

Jim
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on December 18, 2014, 12:40:45 PM
Jim N., Thank you, I really appreciate it!

Jim B., As always, I appreciate your input! The approach to mounting the VSS on the differential isn't my idea at all. A vendor, I think it was Jag's That Run, was offering a kit that used a GM sensor. I took their idea and did the same thing for my V6 swap. Ran that for almost 10 yrs. with no issues. I don't see any reason for changing the approach at this point. I've got it all wired up, just need to build the mounts. You bring up some interesting points though.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: 74ls1tr6 on December 20, 2014, 09:52:35 AM
Just a thought, I believe your VSS pulse is what an electronic speedometer uses. The Autometer speedo is what I have used, needs that pulse. I guess that is how your setup works too? Are you using electronic or mechanical speedo?
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on December 20, 2014, 05:10:49 PM
Calvin,
I'm using the stock gauges so a mechanical speedo. The main reason I'm including the VSS is because the PCM needs to know if the car is moving or not. Another reason is I'll be installing factory cruise at some point so it will be needed there as well. I'll be using a 4 tooth "reluctor" and Sinister configured code to work with it. Actually, I believe the PCM needs the number of pulses that will be generated per mile with your rear end and tire size. Sinister Performance sends a fairly long questionnaire you fill out before he does your PCM. Both the sensor and "reluctor" wheel will be mounted to the rear end so the gap will be static if I do my job correctly and make the mount ridged enough.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on December 21, 2014, 10:30:04 AM
Kelly was exactly right. The header flange is warped. It bows out in the middle so the middle two cylinders are leaking like a sieve. Need to address that soon. Made good progress on the throttle pedal yesterday. I'll share it when it is complete. Here's a shot of how the starter fits. Been meaning to get one of it for a while and finally had the chance yesterday.

LS4StarterInstalled.JPG
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on December 21, 2014, 11:36:06 AM
On the BOPR it is possible to separate the port flanges once the header is made, which goes a long way to eliminate the warpage problem. MLSS gaskets are a great option if they are available.

Jim
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: kstevusa on December 21, 2014, 01:51:55 PM
Scott, The machine we used was a giant Belt sander (rather than a circular stone on a table). Course medium and laid the flange flat on the belt and removed material until the pattern was even accross the entire surface.  Size- 2'W  X  4'L- pretty large belt sander :-)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on December 21, 2014, 04:40:55 PM
QuoteOn the BOPR it is possible to separate the port flanges once the header is made, which goes a long way to eliminate the warpage problem. MLSS gaskets are a great option if they are available.

Jim, that's an interesting idea. I could split it in half but not into fourths because of the way the bolt pattern is laid out. I'm going to think on that one.

Kelly, I'll figure something out. I don't have access to a belt sander like that though. Thank you for pointing me in the right direction! How's that Jag doing? Can't wait to see it!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on December 21, 2014, 06:35:53 PM
Scott, Maybe a hydraulic press to straighten?
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on December 21, 2014, 07:23:35 PM
QuoteScott, Maybe a hydraulic press to straighten?

Thanks Jim! That's exactly what I was going to try next time I get out in the garage. Won't cost anything and won't take long do, worth a shot!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on December 21, 2014, 11:02:00 PM
Cut the middle two tubes, straighten flange, bolt flange to two full length pieces of angle iron, & reweld center tubes.  :)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on December 22, 2014, 01:20:21 PM
QuoteCut the middle two tubes, straighten flange, bolt flange to two full length pieces of angle iron, & reweld center tubes. :)

Option #3. Thanks Carl! :) We're talking about less that a 1/16" so I'm hoping the press will get it close enough.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on January 10, 2015, 10:26:22 AM
Have made some progress over the last couple of weeks but the holiday season and a very busy time at work did slow things down a little. I did get the throttle pedal/cable about 90% there and started modifying the transmission tunnel to accommodate the new position of the shifter. The transmission had to move rearward about 1.5" for the LS4 compared to the v6 position I had it in originally. I actually have to work today but hope to get something done on the car tomorrow.

My wife and I visited Artie and his wife during New Year's week and had a fantastic time! Many of you here know Artie. Anyway, a friend of Artie's, Dave, stopped by New Year's Eve afternoon with this:

DaveG8.jpg

Pontiac G8. Dave's a real cool guy. His car has an LS2 that he put headers, a CAI and a tune on. It puts out about 375 HP to the rear wheels. I realized after thinking about it that I had never been in an LS car before so it was a real treat. He took us out on some back roads and I actually got to drive it too! It really moves that big car quite well and sounds great! It was interesting to get a little perspective on what to expect. He's putting out at least a 100 HP more than I will be but my car weighs almost 2000 lbs. less than his. Should be interesting.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on January 10, 2015, 10:35:54 AM
Donor car!  :)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on January 19, 2015, 08:58:11 PM
I thought I would do a quick update. Lots of little things are getting there. No pictures unfortunately but will do several next time I get out to the garage. I mentioned last time that the throttle pedal is just about there. I also have the transmission tunnel mods done except I'm waiting on a rivet nut to arrive to finish it. Today I got the VSS reluctor done and am very happy with the way it turned out. The sensor mount is underway and it should be completed next time.

Almost forgot to mention I managed to get the passenger side header straightened out. Used my press and slowly inched my way there. I also took Jim Stabe's advice and got a set of  the manifold gaskets he recommended. They're pretty thick, looking forward to installing them. Need to check the drivers side as well.

As everyone who has done this before knows, all these little things are very time consuming. I spent about 3 hours on the reluctor alone. It's stuff that has to be done. Inch by inch! :)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on January 20, 2015, 12:09:09 AM
Hey, You're getting there Scott!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on January 30, 2015, 02:54:15 PM
Thought I would give another small update. Things are still proceeding and progress is being made but the project is at the point where it's hard to notice much change from week to week. There are lots of little details to take care of with each task.The challenge is to keep pushing forward and not let the lack of visible progress make you feel like the project is in the doldrums. I've been doing fairly big projects on the car (nothing like this) during most of the last 10 winters and this is always a challenge for me. Once I start getting some of these small details out of the way more visible things can be completed. Further complicating things is it looks like I won't get my garage time for the next couple of weeks. Too much going on outside of the garage at the moment.Typing it out helps give it some perspective. :)

So, here is some visible progress that has been made. As you'll see, there are still quite a few little details to take care of with this task as well.

LS4ThrottlePedal1.JPG

This is what I'm doing with my throttle pedal. The angle is kind of bad in this picture but heel and toe should be much easier when this is complete. There is actually quite a bit of adjustment available. I want to make sure the throttle pedal is lower than the brake pedal and as far away from it as possible. The pedal is from a mid-90's Toyota Corolla. The cable is from a 2000+ Cadillac w/Northstar motor. The following pictures show additional details at the throttle body and through the firewall.

LS4ThrottleCable.JPG

LS4ThrottleCablePassThru.JPG

I'm currently working under the car on mounting the VSS to the differential and running my battery kill switch and ground cable. I'm trying to get that completely done before moving on to other tasks. One of the things I can do over the next couple of weeks is some additional detailed planning/thinking about the remaining tasks so I can try to be more efficient and also to avoid forgetting too many things.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BWA on January 30, 2015, 05:28:13 PM
Keep pressing forward Scott, progress is progress whether it is incremental or in great surges!!
I am looking at the steep angle the throttle cable makes as it transitions from the end of the sheath over to the throttle cam.  I think you should try and make the angle a little less as you will get the cable wearing out from friction.

Cheers
Byron
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on January 30, 2015, 06:56:44 PM
QuoteKeep pressing forward Scott, progress is progress whether it is incremental or in great surges!!
I am looking at the steep angle the throttle cable makes as it transitions from the end of the sheath over to the throttle cam. I think you should try and make the angle a little less as you will get the cable wearing out from friction.

Thanks for the feedback Byron. Yes, I plan on heating the cable end with a heat gun and angling the cable housing to lessen the angle a bit. It's too sharp an angle now but not quite as bad as it might appear in the photo,

You're right, every minute spent doing something is one minute closer to finishing. :)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BWA on January 30, 2015, 08:30:20 PM
Scott I know you are a busy man with other priorities, when you get time could you please give your audience some instruction the following things:

I am sure that the LS4 engine had a drive by wire throttle body, what throttle body did you go with?

If the original throttle body was drive by wire could not a person stay with drive by wire and use a generic drive by wire gas pedal that you can buy from a hotrod shop?  If this is possible could a person reuse the ECU that came with the LS4 and get it to work?

If you using the original ECU with another throttle body that runs off a cable how does one deal with the programming issues related to the drive by wire code in the ECU?  Does the programmer just disable this code?

Take your time and give us answers on these issues when you get time.  For us your conversion project is the beta version!!

Cheers
Byron
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on January 31, 2015, 11:44:43 AM
QuoteI am sure that the LS4 engine had a drive by wire throttle body, what throttle body did you go with?

If the original throttle body was drive by wire could not a person stay with drive by wire and use a generic drive by wire gas pedal that you can buy from a hotrod shop? If this is possible could a person reuse the ECU that came with the LS4 and get it to work?

If you using the original ECU with another throttle body that runs off a cable how does one deal with the programming issues related to the drive by wire code in the ECU? Does the programmer just disable this code?

Byron,
Thanks for the interest in the project. I seriously looked into using the original PCM when I was planning this project but decided it wasn't the way to go for a variety of reasons. From what I'm reading, it isn't as simple as getting an off the shelf DBW pedal as you are suggesting. There are several different OEM pedals and in many cases they do not interchange. I'm not sure how an aftermarket pedal would fit into this equation. The usual recommendation is to get the PCM, pedal and TAC box, if needed, with the engine from the same car.

In most cases, it isn't possible to use a DBW PCM in a DBC application. The components used to drive the IAC are usually not included on the circuit boards in DBW PCMs. Hope this answers your questions.

You seem to have a fixation on the original LS4 PCM, what's up with that?
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on March 11, 2015, 09:22:20 PM
I was reminded this morning that it had been quite a while since I made an update. I was going to wait until I got more pictures of the progress but I thought I'd do a small post now. In looking through the thread, the last two pages don't have very many pictures at all so I'm going to try to add more in the next few posts.

I may not have posted anything in a month and a half but I have been getting things done. As I mentioned earlier, I've been doing small fabrication tasks and other minor things that have taken quite a bit of time but good progress has been make. The VSS mount is done finally. That took longer than anticipated but needed to be done. Also got the firewall modification for the PCM wiring harness pass through done as well. The cover plate for the right hand drive brake/clutch pedal opening was modified to avoid creating another hole in the firewall. The new fuel pump was put into a VW surge tank so it should be very easy to place in the tank. Twist the existing one off and twist the new one on. Since the transmission is an inch and a half further back than it was with the V6 motor, I decided to flip the shifter shaft 180 degrees to make up the difference. Kind of hard to describe but I'll get pictures of it for the next post. It was at the rear most position that I could be comfortable with before the V8 swap so I needed to do something to offset the more rearward V8 position. While I was at it I cleaned up the shifter and lubricated it. I'm sure there is more but I can't think of anything else except for the next item I will discuss but as you can see, most of the stuff is going to be invisible on the completed car. All the fabricated stuff that was mentioned above will need to be painted which is on the top of the list for next weekend.

So I thought I'd share a screw up with you all. Back in the summer I posted about modifying my MG coolant temperature sensor to fit into the LS head. I chucked it into my drill press and used a file to carefully turn it down to the correct diameter and then put some threads on it. You can see it here.

LS4ModdedMGSensor.jpg

I thought I was really cool. It's funny how reality corrects those false impressions pretty quickly. :) So I'm installing it into the head and thought I'd give it one final twist with the wrench for good measure and this happened.

LS4BrokenSensor.jpg

Snapped the f*&ker clean off. It was quite exciting for about a half hour as I put thread sealer on the sensor and I didn't have a big enough easy out to extract it from the head. I had visions of it being stuck in the head with all the fun that would cause. I dropped what I was doing and ran to the hardware store to get a usable easy out and fortunately was able to get what was left of the old sensor out. Obviously this was the wrong approach so I had to go to plan B. The reason I tried this approach was I really didn't want to modify the head to accommodate the MG sensor. I'm trying really hard to do as little modification of things as possible. That approach adds time to the project but so be it. Anyway, what you see in the next few pictures is not an original idea. This was found in a post on the LS1Tech site and looked like a good solution to this problem and was reversible if it didn't work out.

What you're looking at is the driver's side coolant drain plug. It's quite large. It takes a 17MM male hex socket to get it off. The center of the plug was drilled out and tapped for a pipe thread. A hardware store brass fitting was drilled out and tapped for the sensor.

LS4TempSensorMod.jpg

Here it is being test fitted into the block. All that's left is cleaning up the block a little and installing it with thread sealer. Oh, the sensor wire needs to be lengthened a bit and incorporated into the wiring harness on that side of the motor.

LS4TempSensorInstalled.jpg

That pretty much does it for now. This coming weekend, now that the weather appears to be getting better, I'm going to get back to assembling the car so much more visible progress should be made.

Edit: Correct spelling errors
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on March 12, 2015, 10:34:45 AM
Don't use thread sealer on the entire thread. That sensor will need to ground thru the block, unless you use a two wire sensor.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on March 12, 2015, 10:45:30 AM
Yeah, you know what happens next don't you? Tighten the plug just a little extra twist... ;-)

Seriously though, it's these details that make or break a conversion and that's why the 90/90 rule exists. (90% of the time to do the first 90% and 90% for the last 10%)

You're making great progress Scott. It's going to be a fine conversion.

Jim
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Jim Stabe on March 12, 2015, 11:00:29 AM
That 90% rule is SO true. I wanted to get the car pretty much sorted out mechanically before I painted it. Got it running last May and I haven't even started the bodywork yet.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on March 12, 2015, 06:06:21 PM
Carl, as always, thanks for the advice. I'll make sure I've got a good ground there.

Jim B., thank you, I appreciate it.

Jim S., yeah, I find I have to adjust my thinking with these small tasks. It takes an incredible amount of time to complete them. With the bigger tasks you see more visible results which makes it feel like you're making faster progress. I'm not complaining, garage time is therapeutic for me so it's all good. I'm quite sure I'll be sorting the car for most of the summer if not longer. I'm glad Indy is so close.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on March 13, 2015, 11:41:24 AM
It was meant as a reminder, Scott. I know you already knew that.  :)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Capt'n Moorgone on March 14, 2015, 11:11:19 AM
Scott,  Your making great headway! We all know the sorting NEVER ends with these cars!! That is what makes them so satisfying.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBGT? on March 14, 2015, 03:08:06 PM
Lookin' good Scott!!  Do you want me to help you on the car again, say in May?  Looking to give you moral & immoral support too.....
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on March 16, 2015, 10:07:40 AM
QuoteScott, Your making great headway! We all know the sorting NEVER ends with these cars!! That is what makes them so satisfying.

Thanks Mike! Yeah, never ending. :-) I do enjoy it!


QuoteLookin' good Scott!! Do you want me to help you on the car again, say in May? Looking to give you moral & immoral support too.....


Thanks Artie! Thanks for the offer! As I mentioned before, you're welcome here anytime. I've been looking at what's left and at a high-level it looks like this:

o Finish assembling the engine bay (which includes fabricating the accessory drive at the front of the motor)
o Assemble the interior
o Finish wiring/assembly under the car
o Drop the tank and install the fuel pump

I'm about to make another prediction so it is going to be wrong but I'm thinking that I've got about 6 or so full days of work left to get it to the point of being drivable if nothing unforeseen comes up. That should put me toward the end of April since I only get one day a week to work on the car. I made real good progress this past weekend.  There are some big unknowns to get through:

1. What will the PCM tune be like? Will it go into closed loop?
2. Are there any mechanical issues that might require pulling the motor?
3. Who knows what else major might come up?

So if 2 or 3 materialize it may be helpful if you came in. The boss says that the weekend of May 15-16-17 could work. So maybe if you tentatively pencil that date in we can discuss as we get closer?

Take care

Scott
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on March 16, 2015, 11:20:24 AM
QuoteLooking to give you moral & immoral support too.....

We already have that covered here, Artie!  ;)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBGT? on March 16, 2015, 03:34:12 PM
Done.  Tentatively set for 5/15,5/16 & 5/17.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Capt'n Moorgone on March 16, 2015, 06:10:55 PM
Scott, Get the car on the road by then, and come with us to Carlisle Kitcar Import car show that weekend ! Always a good time.
Mike
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on March 17, 2015, 11:41:58 AM
Sounds like a lot of fun Mike. I'll let you know as things unfold with the build.

Thanks Artie!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on March 18, 2015, 09:19:12 PM
Good progress was made last weekend. It is going together pretty well at this point. The coolant temp sensor is installed and the wiring changes for it are complete. Carl, I did check and it's grounded to the block real well. Also finally got the exhaust gaskets Jim Stabe suggested installed. The driver's side header was straight so that was real good. Here's a picture of the gasket.

LS4ExGasketViews.jpg

Here's one of a gasket installed. Both sides are done at this point and hopefully leaks are a thing of the past now.

LS4ExGasketInstalled.jpg

Another milestone is getting the steering is back together for the first time in over a year. Here's a picture of the steering shaft in the engine bay.

LS4SteeringInstalled.jpg

This next one is of the VSS reluctor and the sensor mount. I'll get pictures of it installed before too long. As I mentioned earlier, it took more work than expected but I'm please with the result.

LS4VSS.jpg

So the plan is to get a very early start on Saturday morning to knock as many things off the list as possible. I'm going to concentrate on getting the engine bay much closer and then move to get the interior back in shape. The detailed list of tasks is still a little long but things are truly getting there now.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Jim Stabe on March 18, 2015, 10:19:22 PM
I love those exhaust gaskets, they will seal up anything. They squish down to 1/2 the uncompressed thickness.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on March 31, 2015, 06:21:34 PM
More progress over these past couple of weekends. The to do list is still a bit long but not nearly as long as it was a month ago. :) I'll start out with a couple of pictures I promised over the last couple of posts I've made. The first one is of the VSS installed. The last one is of the shifter.

LS4ShifterVSS.jpg

You can see it's an aftermarket shifter. The lever is reversible and I've put the "bend" forward so the knob is moved forward a couple of inches. The picture is after the change. I've got it in the car now but forgot to take a picture of it installed.

The engine bay is getting there. I think it looks much more complete now and I'm very pleased with it. This first picture shows the rear of the bay.

LS4EngineSide.jpg

This one shows an overhead shot.

LS4EngineOverhead.jpg

This one shows the front of the motor. It's starting to look like a complete engine.

LS4EngineFront.jpg

Much more progress was made. The underside wiring is about half routed. Next up is the battery cut off switch and redoing the battery cables. I hope to finally fix my voltage drop problem once and for all.

That's it for now. It feels like things are moving much more quickly now at least. It's fun! :)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on March 31, 2015, 09:22:52 PM
Scott, Looking good!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: 74ls1tr6 on March 31, 2015, 11:28:01 PM
Very clean looking job Scott! Keep checking stuff off the list, and soon will be on the road. :)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on April 07, 2015, 07:32:32 PM
Thanks Jim & Calvin!

I thought I'd give a brief update from last weekend and catch up on some images I promised in earlier posts. First, here is the fuel filter installed. I got a little too close I think but it should give you an idea of what was done.

LS4FuelFiltInstalled.JPG

This next one is the shifter installed in the car. The interior looks a bit messy in the photo but it's worse in person! :) It's a couple of hours away from being put back together and cleaned up.

LS4ShifterInstalled.JPG

So most of you recall I discovered a voltage drop issue while troubleshooting a no start problem. Replacing the defective ground cable helped a whole lot but I wanted to completely update the battery wiring while I was at it. This next picture shows pretty much what was done.

LS4BatteryReWire.JPG

I used "Military" style battery terminals. It's grounded in two places now. One is on the tail housing of the transmission, the other to the body. Maybe a bit of overkill but I'm pleased with the result. I'm using 1/0 cables. I was kind of laughing to myself as I was assembling the parts. Back when I got my car in the fall of '79 one of the first things I did was replace the battery cables. The originals were crap. I screwed up and did something right and went with 1/0 cable back then. I seem to recall I got about 10' to do the job and  I was thinking that I probably gave $10-$15 for it back then. I think I gave more than $20 for the 4' I bought at NAPA last month. It was one of those reminders that times have changed a bit. Anyway the ground side is new cable and the hot side is my 36 year old "updated" cable. All the cable ends are soldered on. Oh, I finally have a battery cutoff switch installed too.

The next step is fabricating the accessory drive stuff. It's actually underway now. I'll go into much more detail in my next post. The final picture shows the radiator roughly in its final resting place. I needed to confirm there was room for what I'm planning...there was plenty.

LS4EngineRad.JPG

That's it for now. Hope everyone is having a good spring!

Edit: spelling, changed "it's" to "its"
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: billymgb1000 on April 09, 2015, 08:18:20 AM
Scott I'm so excited for you to drive that baby. man the first time I drove mine it put a huge smile on my face, well that was about 12,000 miles ago and I still can't wipe it off good luck brother.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: G.R. on April 10, 2015, 07:44:26 AM
Scott
I like your shifter. Can you share the brand and where you found it at?

It's looking good, If I were that close I wouldn't sleep until it moved on it's own power
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on April 10, 2015, 08:58:12 AM
Thanks Bill, I'm looking forward to it too.

G.R., unfortunately I don't know the brand. I got it off of eBay 3 or 4 yrs. ago. I can tell you it isn't a name brand shifter.

In a perfect world I'd be out in the garage right now finishing it off but work and wife dictate that other things need done too. :(

Will either of you be attending the V8 meet in Indy? Hope so.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: kstevusa on April 10, 2015, 02:03:31 PM
That shifter looks like a copy of the B&M Rippper I have.  My mounting plate is Blue, but the bend in the stick and slotted mounting holes look similar.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on April 14, 2015, 07:27:34 PM
Thought I'd do a very brief update. I've got a good start on the accessory drive stuff. This first picture shows the current state.

LS4AlternatorPulleyMount.jpg

Does that look like 8+ hours of work? I started with the most complex side first and as you can see it isn't nearly done yet. I'm quite pleased with the results so far. This next very bad depiction shows what the belt routing will look like. Keep in mind it really isn't to scale, just wanted to show what the end result will look like.

LS4BeltRouting.jpg

As you can see, I'll be using a jackshaft to drive the alternator and water pump. The black lines show the rear most belt/pulley which will be driven by the crank pulley. The red lines show the forward most belt/pulley which will drive the alternator/water pump. Hope that's clear.

Next steps are completing the alternator side and then the jackshaft side. I also need to fabricate a plate behind the water pump on the passenger side to securely mount the lower pulley you see there. Hope another 8 hrs. gets me close.

That's all for now. More details will follow.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on April 28, 2015, 07:40:22 PM
Here's another small update. Still making progress but haven't had a full day to work on the car the past couple of weeks unfortunately. The only picture to share at this point is this one.

LS4accessoriesalmost.jpg

This has been my view for the past few work sessions. All the pulleys are in place but there still is a bit of work to do. The alternator plus the two pulleys near it are pretty much lined up to the Corvette spec in relation to the water pump pulley. The pulleys on the right are placed where they will live but I need to create the spacers so they too will line up with their respective pulleys. You can see that there is plenty of work left. I find I'm spending a lot of time measuring things so it gets a little tedious at times but I'm really enjoying the challenge of building this. I got a factory belt tensioner, which I intended to use in the system but found I couldn't, to use as my starting point and am lining up all the forward pulleys to it. I ran the twine to make sure the belt routing is good. The next step is to permanently and rigidly mount the pulleys so I can determine belt lengths. I am probably looking at 2 work sessions to get it to that point. This has to be done right. That's all for now.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on May 19, 2015, 06:42:45 PM
Time for another update. I'm keeping the "slow but steady" theme going on this build. Still working the accessory drive but, except for a few more tasks, it is just about there. This first picture shows both belts installed.

LS4belts.JPG

It's probably been the most challenging fabrication task in the build. Strange as it may sound that is one of the reasons I chose to go this route. It's not that its hard, just requires attention to detail. This is the first test run of the thing.

<iframe width="420" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/939i_P3ND-Y" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

I ran it up to about 2000-2500 rpms and nothing flew off so that was good. Of course it's going to have to do much better than that. When I get the cooling system installed I'll give it a much better test at a much higher rpm. The motor sounds like it has marbles in the crankcase in the video. I'm using video mode in my camera and it seems to favor the higher frequencies and disfavor the lower. It actually sounds really nice and quiet especially since I've installed Jim Stabe's manifold gaskets. It has a smooth idle with a hint of something extra that my v6 never had. I'm looking forward to getting it out on the open road.

So the next steps are tweaking a couple of the smooth idler pulleys so the belt runs more toward the center of them and balancing the jack shaft assembly. After that is installing the radiator. I finally pressure tested it and was surprised to not find any leaks! When I get it to that point I can finally start the engine and get if fully warmed up. If I get the brakes bled it will theoretically be drivable. There will be some additional fabrication tasks associated with the radiator like constructing some ducting for air flow and plugging some holes in the radiator support. If I can get the radiator temporarily mounted I may just take it for a quick trip around the block. We will have to see.

Artie had to change his plans so he's now coming in on the 5th-7th of June. Looking forward to seeing him. Our hope is to have a running car on the road by the time he leaves.

This last picture is one I've been meaning to take for quite a while but just never got around to doing. I posted it on the other site but thought I'd put it in this thread for posterity.

LS4Overhead.jpg

For some reason I really like overhead shots, gives a different perspective on things. Hope it will help someone in the future.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: RMO 699F on May 19, 2015, 10:13:17 PM
Looking good Scott!!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on May 20, 2015, 10:06:04 AM
Scott,

I hope you kept the patterns for the accessory brackets.  There is going to be a market for them soon!

Quote...... with a hint of something extra that my v6 never had.

No doubt!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on May 20, 2015, 08:24:20 PM
Thanks Mike!


QuoteI hope you kept the patterns for the accessory brackets. There is going to be a market for them soon!

Carl, I'm taking things one step at a time starting with getting to the end of the driveway and then around the block! :) The real test will be beating on it during the autocross event in Indy. The questions in my mind are will things stay in place with no movement once adjustments are made and is everything strong enough? I've been trying to build the brackets with that in mind.

Oh, patterns, measurements, pictures, and help are always available to friends.

Looking forward to seeing you both in Indy!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on May 21, 2015, 02:13:51 AM
Scott, Excellent!!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Capt'n Moorgone on May 21, 2015, 06:28:52 PM
Scott,
 It's amazing how smooth that thing runs. You can't even tell it's running ,other than the belts. My shakes a least a little bit! Man, that is going to be one sweet ride!
                                 Mike
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on May 22, 2015, 12:11:19 PM
Hey Mike

Thanks and good eye! Yeah, even the vent tube above the intake doesn't seem to be moving and it's just hanging there. I'm anxious to get it all together.

How was Carlisle?
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: G.R. on May 26, 2015, 12:30:37 PM
Looking great!  I dint see an IAT sensor.  does your combo need one, or did I miss where you have it going into your piping?
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on May 26, 2015, 09:36:09 PM
QuoteLooking great! I dint see an IAT sensor. does your combo need one, or did I miss where you have it going into your piping?

G.R.,

Thanks! The IAT is built into the MAF assembly. It actually works too!

Guess I'll do an update while I'm here. First I'll start with a few details of what's been consuming my garage time over the past few weeks. This first picture shows some of the details on the passenger side of the accessory drive assembly.

LS4PSBracketAssembly.jpg

Next is the driver's side.

LS4DSBracketDetails.jpg

Then the lower bracket which sits under and below the water pump. Sorry about the quality.

IMG_0145.JPG

You can see the brackets still look pretty rough. I had hoped to get them smoothed out and painted before the meet, and I still might, but there are other things to do that are of a higher priority at the moment. They do seem to function so far.

So I got the radiator installed over the weekend and finally got the LS4 fully warmed up. Here is another video showing part of that event. I used my phone this time and the quality is slightly better.

<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/89NP0xHLO2Y" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

I got a data log of the whole event which I finally got a chance to look at this evening. I'm pretty pleased. It appears it did go into closed loop. All the sensors seem to be giving reasonable data. My VSS even works! I got it up to about 4500 RPM and the belts stayed in place. The cooling fan cycled a few times which was good to hear. The Costanzo garage was a pretty happy place all things considered.

So my list of issues to sort out is starting to grow. This is expected. First, I've got a leak in one of my brake lines. That one is frustrating because it shouldn't have happened. Second, and I always planned on this, but I need to get the parameters adjusted and the PCM flashed a couple more times before the meet. I need to get it on the road and get some good logs first. Third, and this one could involve some major time, my clutch is making some noise when I engage it. I haven't done any systematic troubleshooting yet but that will be on the top of the list next weekend. Let's hope the motor doesn't have to come out.

I'll close with a picture of the motor cooling down.

LS4CurrentEngineBay.jpg

My air filter won't fit so I need to go to plan B. This is a temporary setup to get me through the summer. I intend on doing an over the radiator air inlet but that will require some fiberglass work that I will tackle this winter. Bit by bit.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: 74ls1tr6 on May 27, 2015, 09:38:47 AM
Very nice sounding V6 er I mean V8 upgrade ;) . Love the sound of an LS!

Looks packed in there very nicely Scott. Can't wait to see it in Indy!!

An FYI which you may already know, these LS engines love to run around 205 to 215 temps so don't think you are over heating in that temp range.

Just recently installed my 83 to 85 Dodge Caravan fan in my TR6, took out my Summit racing fan. What a huge difference in air flow, cooling, and much more quiet sounding. After turning the engine off, the fan ran 2/3rds less time before turning off. Very happy with a junkyard fan of $42 bucks.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Jim Stabe on May 27, 2015, 10:49:05 AM
The good OEM fans are head and shoulders better than any of the aftermarket ones - can't imagine why anyone spends the money on them. I have a friend that built a Factory 5 Cobra coupe kit and it was always overheating with the aftermarket fan supplied in the kit. I had an extra 19" electric fan from a late model Mustang that I gave him and the longest the fan ever runs is about 40 seconds and that is when it is really hot outside. The motor has so much torque that it almost tears out of your hands on start up if you are holding it for a test. You DEFINITELY need a 70+ amp relay to run it though.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on May 27, 2015, 11:41:46 AM
How much are those Caravan fans new? I was out at the junkyard the other day and it looked like they are becoming real popular, seemed like any Caravan that wasn't bashed in the front was missing the fan. They didn't look that easy to remove either, totally closed in by everything. I bought dual Camaro fans for about $150 brand new and wonder if the Caravan fan might be similar?

I did pick up a handful of Volvo fan relays while I was there.

Jim
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: 74ls1tr6 on May 27, 2015, 05:31:35 PM
Jim B,

I don't know what the Caravan fan runs for a new one. To take one out, a non smashed front 83 to 85 single 16" Caravan fan, it is only four bolts that hold it in, and cut the wire harness passed the plug. Maybe took all of 10 to 15 minutes to take one out. I took two of them out in a Pick & Pull and was cashed out at the door in 1/2 hour.

Jim B if you want one, next time I'm at pick & pull I'll pick one up for ya!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: 74ls1tr6 on May 27, 2015, 05:37:41 PM
Sorry for the high jacked thread Scott........I will be bringing my HP tuners software to Indy....we can get a reading and possibly change stuff for you on your tune. Just need to pay for the credits to run your engine on it....small dollars!!   You just need your diagnostic port installed in your wiring. My lap top can do the rest.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on May 27, 2015, 08:58:50 PM
Thanks Calvin! The fan discussion is not a hijack at all.....very relevant. The temperature settled at a steady 200 once the motor got fully warmed up. It's a long story but I need to tweak my fan shroud because one of the corners of the radiator is not covered by it. The radiator I'm using is small so everything needs to be about perfect to be successful with it. I'm using a fan from a late 90s Corolla. It's very compact and moves a lot of air. On a hot day when it's running and I put my foot on the ground to get out of the car, I can feel a nice warm breeze on my ankle as air is blown out from under the car. I'm going to start with what I've got and go from there. I have a bit of work left to get the radiator to where I want it.

I really appreciate your offer to play with the tune and I may take you up on it. Let's see how things unfold over the next couple of weeks and I'll let you know and we can work out the logistics to make it happen. Oh, I do have a diagnostic port installed! :)

Looking forward to seeing you in Indy!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Dan B on May 27, 2015, 10:05:45 PM
I bought the new Caravan fan we are using in the TR7 at Advance for about $90.  I think it was about a 94 model
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: 74ls1tr6 on May 28, 2015, 12:11:48 AM
http://www.autopartswarehouse.com/sku/Dodge/Caravan/Replacement/Cooling_Fan_Assembly/1994/D160910.html?apwcid=productads&003=27846857&010=apwD16091094docacofaas&gclid=Cj0KEQjw1pWrBRDuv-rhstiX6KwBEiQA5V9ZoWo3Pqi5AyGFN_WffcREVYc473JesuGnyvhwbugMQUsaAqkm8P8HAQ&c_aid=40851158144&c2cid=45ee888a-ec58-4697-8804-3bcd030bae3a


I PMed Jim B with this link of a new 94 caravan replacement fan. This is a good price including shipping and no tax depending on where you live.

I think I will go to the Pick & Pull's around here and pick up a few for others. There are probably 6 main Pick & Pulls within a 30 mile radius from where I live. At one alone had 7 94 to 96 Dodge Caravan at their place. Should be able to score on a few of them. Very easy to pull out and easy to install cutting down shroud to fit.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on May 28, 2015, 09:33:22 AM
Calvin, if you can bring one to Indy I'd like to get one to put in the Chump car, since we don't have a fan for it yet.

Jim
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: 74ls1tr6 on May 29, 2015, 09:23:34 AM
Jim B,

Going out this morning to score some fans and maybe some more electric power steering system parts. I will bring some fans to Indy!.....:)   I want to have extras before they are harder to get.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Jim Stabe on May 29, 2015, 10:00:27 AM
Guys, don't forget the Taurus and Volvo fans. The Volvo's are nearly the same fan as the Taurus but they have a nifty mounting flange built in. They are at least as powerful as the Caravan favs.

Taurusfan.jpg

volvofan2.jpg

Volvo_front.jpg

Volvoonshroud.jpg
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: 74ls1tr6 on May 29, 2015, 10:25:20 AM
Jim S,

What year Volvo ,model, for fan (for a good fit)? Also any better year for Taurus fans? I can look today while I'm in Pick & Pull.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on May 29, 2015, 10:58:23 AM
Looks like the Volvo fan is about 16" in diameter and they come in 92-98 S70, 940, 740's according to a Fiero site. If it's thin enough it would work well on my shroud.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Jim Stabe on May 29, 2015, 11:49:46 AM
I measured the Volvo fan I have (don't remember which model it came from but I think they are all about the same). The blade diameter is 15 1/4", the diameter of the mounting flange is 17 1/4" and the mounting bolt circle is 16 3/4". From the mounting face to the tip of the motor is 3 1/4" as close as I could measure it. Rob Ficalora has one on his car and he seems to like the way it cools the car in Houston.

I used the Taurus fan on my car because it was slightly larger and felt like it had slightly more airflow doing the "blow it in your face" test even though it was more difficult to mount in the shroud.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Jim Stabe on May 29, 2015, 12:54:35 PM
If you have the room you should also look at a Lincoln Mk VIII fan (same size as the 01-04 SVT Mustang fan I mentioned above). It has a blade diameter of 18" and a housing diameter of 19" and is rumored to flow 3500 cfm on low speed and 4500 cfm on high. I have one but it was a tad too tall for my car but it will definitely blow you wig off, make sure you have a good grip when you hold it for a test. Needs a BIG relay, BIG wires and an uprated alternator. Here is a comparison of the Mk VII and a Taurus and a 01-04 Mustang fan.

MarkVIIIfanvsTaurusfan.jpg

01-04Mustangfandimensions.jpg

01-04Mustangfan.jpg
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on June 02, 2015, 07:18:06 PM
I thought I'd do yet another small update. It was a good weekend.

The first thing I did was look into the clutch issue I mentioned in my last update. I didn't describe it correctly last time. The issue/noise occurred when the clutch pedal was depressed. The noise, which was best described as a tapping sound, happened when resting a foot on the pedal and continued as it was pressed to the floor. My first thought was throw out bearing but that was hard to believe. Everything inside the bellhousing is new except for the clutch fork and pivot ball. Even the input bearing retainer is new. Anyway, I remembered that one of the starter bolts was pretty close to the pressure plate bolts so I needed to check there first. Sure enough, this is what I found.

LS4FlywheelBoltInterfereance.jpg

If you look closely you can see where it was hitting at the bottom edge. It was a relief to realize the transmission didn't have to come out. I'm not overjoyed to have to clearance the bolts in place. I would have preferred to pull them out, grind the ends, ensure they all weigh the same and reinstall. I tried to grind them the same by eye so the weight variance is hopefully small. This approach greatly increases the odds of making Indy so we're going with it. Next time the engine comes out this will be attended to the right way.

The other issue I mentioned was a leaking brake union. So I thought, "Let me try to tighten it one more time." I did and sure enough, the leak stopped and I suddenly had a firm pedal. Like I said, it was a good weekend.

That was two items off the "sorting out" list and what I thought would consume at least an entire weekend ended up only taking a couple of hours. So I start up the car to test the clutch "fix" and was very pleased to hear silence when depressing the clutch pedal. I was making plans to maybe put the car down on the ground and take the first drive around the block when I heard a new, unusual noise. This is what I found.

LS4BeltDamage.jpg

Take two items off the "sorting out" list and add another to it! :) This is the smaller, inside belt that drives the jack shaft. Obviously there was a misalignment there. I literally measured the alignment at least 5 times. It's hard to describe but it is difficult to get an accurate measurement. You'd think after 5 times I would have gotten it right though. I spent another 30 minutes looking at it, put the new belt on and eyed it up to finally see the misalignment. So everything needs to come forward about 3 mm to get the inner pulley on the jack shaft to line up with the crank pulley. It actually is an easy fix and the other good thing is it happened in the garage.

All of the above items are builder errors, no one to blame but him. :)

Artie will be coming in this Thursday evening and we'll spend Friday through Sunday on the car. We will get the front of the motor put back together, install the throttle pedal and take it out for a short drive. If nothing else pops up the next steps are to fabricate some radiator ducting, install the new fuel pump, permanently install the PCM, and do other minor reassembly tasks and checks. Those are the only items left I'm aware of at the moment. With any kind of luck we should be able to put some miles on it before Artie leaves.

That's all for now.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: ex-tyke on June 03, 2015, 09:44:49 AM
Quote....increases the odds of making Indy

Hang in there Scott - we're all rootin' for ya!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on June 03, 2015, 05:16:43 PM
Scott, Almost there! Can you replace the bolts you ground with pan head Allens? I would use hardened washers under the heads.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Capt'n Moorgone on June 03, 2015, 08:55:52 PM
Great news Scott! Some times all the planets line up for you. Hope to see you in Indy.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on June 03, 2015, 09:50:20 PM
Thanks Graham, Jim, and Mike! Just to be clear, both Artie and I will be in Indy car or no car. Our wives will even be there for a short time. It's such a fun event and the people are first class! Wouldn't miss it! Not to jinx anything but the car is where I hoped it would be at this point so I'm optimistic it will be ready too.

Jim, I'm not quite sure I understand your question. The picture I took shows the back of the flywheel and you're looking at one of the pressure plate bolts before any grinding took place. One of the starter bolts just happened to occupy the same place that the pressure plate bolts do. What bolts are you referring to?
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on June 04, 2015, 08:59:52 AM
Scott, I didn't see the shiny spot by the ring gear and assumed the pressure plate bolt heads were rubbing. Looking forward to your first test spin!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: 74ls1tr6 on June 08, 2015, 03:24:43 PM
Scott,

Photo's of 98 S70 Volvo fan with relay! Photo's should give you an idea of dimensions, that maybe can work with your application.

About 17 1/2' width across furthest.
2015-06-0807.22.33.jpg

2 speed relay!
2015-06-0807.22.48.jpg

Mounting would need some spacer away from radiator for fan blade...maybe 1/2"
2015-06-0807.24.41.jpg

Total from out most fan blade center to fan motor is 3 3/4" or less
2015-06-0807.24.01.jpg
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: 74ls1tr6 on June 08, 2015, 03:31:13 PM
2015-05-2914.26.59.jpg
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: rficalora on June 08, 2015, 07:23:59 PM
That's the same fan & relay pack I'm using.  It's never even gone to high speed even in Texas heat with the A/C on.  I can definitely recommend it if the Lincoln one won't fit.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on June 09, 2015, 06:36:01 PM
Thanks for the suggestions Calvin & Rob. Calvin, I'll be in touch with you next week.

Artie was in and we had a great time as usual. I really want to thank him for all his help! He's a really good friend and a great guy. We got a lot of work done on the car. We didn't get it out on a long run like we hoped but we are very close now. We did do a short first run and got a couple of videos showing it. Here is the drive by.

<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/eSq3GBjnm3Q" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

The car is still rough in this video but it was very fun getting it out even for a few minutes. Can I officially call this a V8 car now?

As I said, we got a lot of work done. The throttle pedal is in and adjusted, the PCM is installed permanently, the new fuel pump is finally installed and the radiator ducting is well on it's way to being complete. I have a distinct lack of pictures and I apologize for that...just too busy working to get things done. I didn't even get a picture of Artie!

I still have a few things to do besides completing the radiator ducting:

o Fix a pesky leak at the thermostat housing
o Adjust the tach for the V8 (the PCM actually puts out a 4 cylinder signal I'm told)
o Put the interior back together and clean things up
o Do a bunch of minor tasks here and there

Here is the current state of the engine bay as of last night.

LS4EngineBay.jpg

I'm very hopeful for the meet. It seems like the odds favor the car being ready for Indy unless something major goes wrong. It will NOT be "done" at all. There will be incomplete things that will need to be redone. Everything I'm doing now is just to make it as reliable as possible. I really need to get it out on the road and put a few hundred miles on it. Hopefully next weekend.

Scott
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: 74ls1tr6 on June 09, 2015, 07:35:46 PM
Was that a BIG GRIN on your face Scott when you drove by :)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BWA on June 09, 2015, 07:53:26 PM
Scott that is pretty awesome!!  You are just about ready to run with the "big boys" now.
If I ever do another project it might be an LS4 in to a TR4 or TR4a.  You are blazing a path for others to follow.
Thanks for the detailed thread on this topic.

Cheers
Byron
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBGT? on June 09, 2015, 08:30:06 PM
Scott, thanks for allowing me to participate in your build experience.  It's a pleasure working with you.  Hang in there.  When I'm back in 5 weeks, we'll finish up the important details you haven't gotten a chance to address & I'll do the detailing of the car for you.  After all, she must look her best.
I thought we fixed the leaky thermostat?
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on June 09, 2015, 08:52:52 PM
I'm still grinning Calvin! :)

Thanks Byron, it's fun to share it with fellow car guys. Oh, I took your advice and adjusted the throttle cable support so the angle isn't so severe.

Artie, yeah, so did I. I looked after we started it yesterday morning and it's leaking slightly again. I'ii try to tighten it again to see if that helps. If not its on to plan B. :)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on June 09, 2015, 09:42:07 PM
Great to see Scott, and yes definitely official. I imagine you'll be giving a few rides at Indy.

Jim
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: rficalora on June 09, 2015, 11:13:35 PM
Can't wait to see it.  I'll be in line for the rides at Indy :)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on June 09, 2015, 11:57:39 PM
Scott, Wow! Cool!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: rficalora on June 10, 2015, 12:19:01 AM
By the way... talk about a sleeper.  Looks totally stock.  Even looked like single exhaust - or at least both exiting the left side.  You are going to surprise a lot of folks :)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: 74ls1tr6 on June 10, 2015, 07:26:49 AM
Scott,

That is correct about your Tach being switch to a 4 cylinder. This is what mine is set to. We are both using the same computer.

Is your engine hunting for idle as soon as your car starts rolling? In one of your video's, I though thats what I heard?

We could maybe fix that in your tune!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on June 11, 2015, 08:08:13 AM
Thanks everyone. Jim B., I hope I can give some rides next month.

QuoteIs your engine hunting for idle as soon as your car starts rolling? In one of your video's, I though thats what I heard?

Calvin, I didn't think that was happening but you could be right. Keep in mind that the video was taken on Friday afternoon before most of the work was done. We replaced the fuel pump and updated the wiring in the tank as well early on Sunday. When we started it for the first time after all the work on Monday morning, just before Artie left, it ran like a different engine. We're still very early into the sorting out phase. I will keep everyone informed. Please keep the comments coming, I appreciate your insight!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on June 11, 2015, 09:32:43 AM
Gonna be a hoot!

<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/R5xTxMYWvXI" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on June 17, 2015, 06:14:36 PM
Carl, I hope I don't experience the fire part of that video! :)

Time for another update.Finally got the car out for about a 20 minute drive in the country. Actually made it back home without incident so that was good. The temperature ran a little less than 200 F so I was quite pleased with that. As you'll see below, the ducting isn't quite complete yet so that is encouraging. The temperature was in the mid 80's F during the drive. I have not taken it out on the freeway to get it really warmed up and then allowed it to sit still for any period of time after that so there are still quite a few unknowns cooling system wise. So far so good.

Here is a picture of the engine bay in what I believe will be the "final" Indy state. Still need to paint the ducting but I can't think of anything major left to do here.

LS4SummerEngineBay.JPG

Artie and I co-designed and built this and I'm quite pleased with the way it turned out. It isn't perfect but it isn't too bad all things considered. This next photo shows the frame for the lower ducting.

LS4LowerRadiatorDucting.JPG

I didn't have to drill any holes to mount this so it fits in well with my theme of minimal modifications. I'm using a couple of the sway bar mounting bolts and the rearward front bumper bolts to hold the thing on. I was going to cut some sheet metal for the skin to cover this frame but after thinking about it I'm going to use some coroplast because it will be easier and just as effective I think.

So the drive uncovered some additional "sorting out" issues. I got a check engine light with three trouble codes. Two were knock sensor related and the remaining was the cam sensor. It has been difficult to start at times and the symptoms it is showing fall into line with the cam sensor problem. I'll have some troubleshooting to do for this one. I'm not surprised the knock sensors are throwing a code but I'll save that issue until I get the cam sensor fixed. Should be interesting. Inch by inch.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on June 24, 2015, 09:05:48 PM
OK, time is getting short. I figure I have 4 working days left before the meet counting the Tuesday before we leave. I'm still cautiously optimistic we'll make it. Additional progress was made over this past weekend. I pretty much completed the lower ducting, except for paint and a few miscellaneous tasks. Painting it may or may not happen at this point but you can't really see it from most angles. Here's one side.

LS4CloroplastLowerDucting.JPG

It's a little bright :) but what you are looking at survived a couple of 70 mph runs no problem at all. So far so good. It took an incredible amount of time for me to make it. Probably somewhere between 6 to 7 hrs. total. It doesn't really look like it should take that long. If I used a metal skin it probably would have added at least another hour. Maybe down the road. So I took it out for a few tests to see how the upper and lower ducting worked and, all things considered, I'm pretty pleased. I got it fully warmed up and then took it for about a 15 mile cruise on the freeway at about 70 mph. The temperature, according to the factory coolant temperature sensor, ran about 205 F. with the air temperature in the mid to upper 80's F. Seemed to be pretty steady. It never got above about 215 F coming back home on residential streets at about 25 mph. The interesting thing is the factory temperature sensor isn't very accurate. When it's cold, it reads a good 10 degrees above the ambient temperature in the garage when compared to my wife's temperature display in her car and to the incoming air temperature sensor. I'm not sure if that difference is linear as it gets warm. I'm hoping that someone at the meet will have an infrared  gun they can test my radiator with. I could potentially be running around 195 F with a high of 205 F.

I was able to get the cam sensor wiring squared away pretty quickly. The first test I did identified the problem. This may help someone down the road so I'll mention briefly exactly what this issue is about. I'm using the 0411 PCM that was flashed with LS1 code. The LS1 has a rear mounted cam sensor. My LS4, like the LS2, has the cam sensor mounted into the timing cover at the front of the block with no option for a rear mounted sensor. I went to an LS2 front cover and the LS2 cam sensor. The plug for both the LS1 and LS2 cam sensors are the same...works out great except that the order of the wiring in the plug changed. There are 3 wires in the plug, the sensor signal, a 12 volt reference, and a low (ground) reference. In the LS2 sensor the sensor signal and the 12 volt reference are switched when compared to the LS1 sensor. So I knew this when I built the harness and I thought I had accounted for it. Guess not because they weren't switched. I'm beginning to think I did the crank sensor instead of the cam sensor by mistake. The two plugs look identical. You might recall if you've been watching this thread for a while that I had a no start issue caused by a crank sensor wiring problem. It was switched and now I find the cam wasn't. Oh well. It was an easy fix at least. It starts much better now as you can imagine and the code is gone. I discovered another wiring issue the other night. It seems that one connector on the ignition fuse is deformed slightly and it's causing an intermittent issue. I'm going to replace it this coming weekend and hope that is the end of my wiring issues.

I really haven't had time to play with this much yet but I'm trying to get the wide band sensor data into my TunerPro logs by trying different, unused outputs that are included in the OBD2 ALDL output. I got the brilliant idea of trying the air conditioner pressure wire. So I start the car and about 30 seconds later the cooling fan comes on. It seems that's how the computer knows if the air con is running or not. I had to laugh. It appears the wide band controller is putting out some voltage at least. What I'm trying to do may not be possible but trying further will have to wait until after Indy.

I finally got some time with the car on the road. I've put close to 80 miles on it so far. It's fun. I don't think of myself as one of those guys that select an engine just for the sound. I love the sound of all sorts of engines. I think the original B motor sounds great as a matter of fact. But I grew up lusting after Camaro's, Chevelle's and Corvette's. Back then, as a 14-15 year old kid, watching one rumble down the street got my blood boiling. So listening to the LS4 while going down the road brings back the notion of how I think a performance car should sound. Kind of hard to explain and I didn't mean to get all philosophical about it. Bottom line, it sounds great....like it means business as you go through the gears. The torque is unreal! According to the factory dyno chart it gets above 300 ft. lbs. at something like 1800-1900 RPMs. Going down a residential street in third at 20-25 mph and accelerating is effortless, the engine hardly sounds like it's working. Absolutely no problem breaking the tires loose in third. It's going to be fun learning about how this new motor has changed the car. I haven't driven the car hard at all yet either. Got to be careful I don't kill myself with it!

If things continue to progress like they have so far, Indy should be doable. The car is by no means sorted yet especially when I compare it to how sorted Mike Moor's car is. That is my benchmark. Mike's car is the best sorted conversion I've ridden in to date. I'm a looong way from that point. I don't think I'm going to be able to compete in the autocross and that will be a little disappointing.

Looks like I wrote a novel so I'll close for now.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: 74ls1tr6 on June 25, 2015, 03:22:35 AM
I'm bringing my infrared gun.... :)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on June 25, 2015, 06:30:20 AM
Cool!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on June 25, 2015, 09:40:10 AM
QuoteI don't think I'm going to be able to compete in the autocross and that will be a little disappointing.

C'mon Scott, I bet we could sell tickets to the drift event!  :)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: billymgb1000 on June 25, 2015, 08:31:56 PM
Hello scott
I'm just wondering this ls4 is it a 5.7? you may have already said but I missed it. thanks fellow ls man (lol)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on June 25, 2015, 08:45:19 PM
It's a 5.3L rated at 303 horsepower and 325 ft-lbs of torque at the crank.

Looks like you are supposed to run 91+ octane, Scott.  I have to run high test in my 215.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on June 25, 2015, 09:14:21 PM
Hey Bill, as Carl already pointed out it is a 5.3.

Carl, yeah, I'm running high test in it.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: billymgb1000 on June 26, 2015, 06:43:23 PM
Thanks I run 91 in mine also, mine is the 4.8 carbureted you have to love it good luck scott. I know I still after 15,000 miles can't get enough
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Capt'n Moorgone on June 26, 2015, 07:19:08 PM
Thanks Scott, but these cars are always evolving. Mine has had nearly twenty years of it. I just got a head start on you!

Indy should be a blast!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on July 09, 2015, 09:36:58 PM
Two more days to work on the car! No pictures tonight but things are progressing. I have just shy of 200 miles on the car now. It is running better than where it started from for sure. Got the radiator ducting painted but not installed yet. I put the car up on jack stands last weekend and inspected things. Nothing seems out of place. I did tighten and use some blue loctite on the two motor mount bolts.....one of them was slightly loose. It was something I've been meaning to do. So my brakes started feeling weird. It is the master cylinder. Just what I needed but it's better it happened now. The new one came today. I can't complain, I got over 25 years out of a rebuild! Also noticed a squeaky idler pulley so I'm going to replace it too. I'm feeling pretty confident the car will make the trip but it's still very rough at this point.

Artie is coming in on Monday afternoon and we will spend Tuesday on the car. He's going to detail it for me. Hope I'm not spending the whole day under the car!

Several of us are going to meet up at Mike Maloney's on Wednesday and caravan to Indy. Mike Moor, yeah, Indy is going to be a blast! Looking forward to seeing everyone!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on July 20, 2015, 11:39:17 AM
I saw someone at the V8 Meet that could not wipe that ear-to-ear grin off his face.......  :)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: danmas on July 20, 2015, 12:18:00 PM
QuoteI saw someone at the V8 Meet that could not wipe that ear-to-ear grin off his face....... :)

And not without good reason.  Outstanding workmanship.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on July 20, 2015, 12:40:50 PM
Hey Carl,

Yeah, still can't! :-)

Made it there and back with no real issues which was great. I've got over 500 miles on it at this point. The only issue we had was a slight hiccup every once in a while at speeds above 65 mph and going up hill. Kind of hard to describe....like letting off the throttle for just a moment. I'll have to try to get logs of this happening at some point.

I was real pleased with the cooling system as well. The weather was quite hot and we had no issues. The drive to and from Skillman's was a great test. I got a Volvo fan from Calvin which I'll get installed at some point before winter I hope. That should give me some extra insurance. Barry Glass has one installed with a manual switch and he turned it on for us. It moves an amazing amount of air!

It was good to see you and everyone else!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on July 20, 2015, 12:42:38 PM
QuoteAnd not without good reason. Outstanding workmanship.

Thank you Dan!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: rficalora on July 20, 2015, 09:09:33 PM
Yeah, very well done Scott.  Clean install.  You can tell you took time on all the little details!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: kstevusa on July 21, 2015, 07:32:46 AM
Scott, the car is a "Work of Art",  This is the way Abington could have done it :-).  Hate we all did not get to share a DIckel, I just barely got to have a lite 2-3 hit during the situation.  See you and Artie in Townsend.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on July 21, 2015, 05:24:11 PM
I wasn't there but, I can picture Scott smiling the whole time! Great job! As far as I know, the only RWD LS4 starter solution!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on July 21, 2015, 06:00:26 PM
Thank you Rob, Kelly and Jim, I appreciate it!

Kelly, I regret we didn't share a Dickel too. The time just flew by! There were several people I didn't get to talk to as much as I wanted. Hard to believe it's been about a week since the meet got started. Guess it's good that we leave wanting it to go a bit longer. Artie and I were just saying today that we're ready to do it again! :) Oh, I'm so glad Sandy is recovering so well. She scared us there for a little while!

I'm planning to document the sorting out phase in this thread but it will be a few weeks before I get back to work. I'm going to get some things on the honey do list done first.

Scott
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on August 04, 2015, 07:10:20 PM
I thought I'd do a small update and talk about weighing the car at the V8 Meet.

Pete Mantell brought his scales to Indy which was great since I was/am very interested in where the car stands. To give a point of reference, the last time I had the car weighed was in 2008 at the Wisconsin meet. Just so happens on the very same set of scales. At that time I had my 3.1 V6 in the car and it weighed 2019 lbs. with half a tank of gas. In Indy, I believe Pete said I weighed 2106 lbs. with only a 1/4 tank of gas. So if I add 25 lbs. to account for the lack of gas in the tank it puts the weight at 2131 lbs. give or take. So I've added about 110 lbs. going with the LS4. I never weighed the V6 unfortunately but that generation was very light. I'm guessing at or just below 300 lbs. I have a reprint of the factory owner's manual for my 68 somewhere...looked briefly but couldn't find it. Anyway, I seem to recall the manual had the "curb weight" at 21xx lbs. Can't remember the exact figure. Bottom line, I think the car weighs close to what a factory 68 weighed. I'm pleased with that.

So, as you can imagine, there are a few things on the list to be sorted. The things I'd like to do before the Fall Gathering are:

o Try to sort out the knock sensor issue
o Fix a leak in the transmission
o Get the tach sorted
o Adjust the pedal heights
o Put in a new windshield to top seal

I've pushed the car a bit harder this past weekend than I have up to this point. I was giving some dinner guests a ride around the block and nailed it in 2nd and then into 3rd. I think they liked it...I know I did. I thought I might have heard some pinging though so the knock sensor thing moved up the list. One of the things I'm seeing with the issue I'm experiencing is the sensor's might not be torqued correctly so that's one thing I'll be checking.

This winter I'll try to get to the following things:

o Install the Volvo fan
o Get the fuel pump I really want to use installed
o Perhaps get a new rear axle and maybe even get it installed
o Maybe add factory cruise control
o Finally install the GAZ coil over shocks on the front end
o Re-enforce the front of the rear spring mount
o Several other small things to numerous to mention

I haven't had a chance to touch the car since the meet but hope to soon. :)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: RMO 699F on August 05, 2015, 10:21:53 AM
Scott, what is the exact issue on the pedal heights?
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on August 05, 2015, 05:45:06 PM
QuoteScott, what is the exact issue on the pedal heights?


Good question Mike. There are two things I want to change. Currently the throttle pedal is at about the same height as the brake pedal and I like it lower than the brake by 3/4" to 1". That should be fairly easy to adjust and I meant to do it before the Meet but time ran out. The second issue is when I put the seat in the most comfortable position for me I can't quite push the clutch pedal all the way to the floor so I want to move the clutch pedal pad rearward maybe an inch at the most. Those two adjustments should make the driving position much more comfortable especially on a long trip.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on August 24, 2015, 04:51:13 PM
Weigh-in from Indy V8 Meet:

Scott' Costanzo's 1968 5.3L Chevy MGB = 2104 lbs.

Steve Carrick's 1974 302 Ford MGB = 2252 lbs.

That is fantastic, Scott!   Scratching my head, wondering how that can be?!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: billymgb1000 on August 24, 2015, 05:51:57 PM
Hey Carl
I think it's because of all the aluminum parts on these L/S engines. I know on mine the heads,oil pan, intake, front timing cover is all aluminum. and that's all factory.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on August 24, 2015, 08:41:51 PM
Yeah, but an LS is not that much lighter. Steve has aluminum heads, intake, & a Fast Cars front end that is much lighter. I just don't see 150 lbs difference. A 2100 lb. MGB with a LS engine is outstanding!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Jim Stabe on August 24, 2015, 10:08:23 PM
How much gas was in it? 15 gallons of gas weighs over a hundred pounds.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on August 24, 2015, 11:12:11 PM
Good point, Jim. I believe they both have stock 12 gallon fuel tanks. One empty, one full?  I don't think that is all of the story.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on August 25, 2015, 05:10:42 AM
Thanks Carl! I only had a quarter of a tank, roughly about 3 gal, when it was weighed. Another difference is I don't have a roll bar but that might be a wash with my car still having the stock front end. I tried to keep weight in mind as I was building the car so hopefully that helped too. I believe the biggest factor is earlier cars are lighter. I was very pleased, I was hoping to be in the mid-2100 lb. range.

FYI, Pete mentioned he weighed an LS and got, if I heard him correctly, about 360-370 lbs.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBGT? on August 25, 2015, 08:21:47 AM
I know why  Scott's car was so light......It didn't have the Artie Clark suspension lower kit in it at the time.......  :)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: danmas on August 25, 2015, 12:51:07 PM
Interesting to compare the corner weights:

LF:  + 9 lbs

RF:  - 12 lbs

LR:  + 90 lbs

RR:  + 62 lbs.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: kstevusa on August 25, 2015, 02:29:24 PM
Well, we can't lay the difference to Artie,  he'd been RR :-).  Barney must have had some extra beer in the trunk the owner overlooked,NOT
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on August 25, 2015, 03:17:02 PM
Well, Barney may well have had a cooler in the trunk, but we all know that there was NO chance it would be overlooked.  ;)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: danmas on August 25, 2015, 03:36:40 PM
Overall, Barney is 3 lbs lighter in the front, and 152 lbs heavier in the rear. That's more than just a few cans of beer. Interesting.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on August 25, 2015, 04:42:36 PM
Rear axle and suspension differences?
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on August 25, 2015, 04:44:35 PM
1) Marcia's luggage + beer cooler?  :)

2) Let's see; he has a 9" rear with aluminum pumpkin, a 3-link with panhard rod, a top crossbar to mount the coilover shocks, 225/50-15 tires & wheels, & whatever is in the trunk (see #1).

I am jazzed that the front end weight of Scott's MG w/LS4 is right there with a 302 Ford w/ a Fast Cars front end. That is something!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: danmas on August 25, 2015, 06:59:52 PM
QuoteI am jazzed that the front end weight of Scott's MG w/LS4 is right there with a 302 Ford w/ a Fast Cars front end. That is something!

Your winter project, Carl?
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on August 25, 2015, 09:12:40 PM
I wish!  Right now my winter project is looking like two ChumpCars.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on September 09, 2015, 09:06:23 PM
Overdue for an update. Things have been too busy lately. First, let me mention a few things about the weight-in results. Although I'm very please with the total weight of my car, you can see the weight distribution isn't very good at the moment. When I'm done making changes to the car I'll take steps to improve it. The weight most certainly will go up from here and my challenge will be to minimize it. I do daydream about the Fast Cars front end....don't think I could ever swing it though. :(

I'll go into the sorting out process a little now. You will see it's a story of ignorance, bad decisions, and defective parts. Like most of you, I absolutely HATE leaks! So I think you can imagine how overjoyed I was to discover that I had coolant, transmission and gas leaks to deal with. About the only thing that wasn't leaking was the engine, as far as I can tell.This first picture shows the source of the transmission leak.

IMG_0194.JPG

Pretty obvious as you can see. :) This one I consider a bad decision. I was hoping to save some time in my quest to get to Indy and I guess it worked because I did make it there and back. The transmission output shaft pushed the plug out of the yoke. I had a half inch of the yoke sticking out of the end of the tail shaft housing and really thought I had enough clearance. Oh well. Here's the shortened drive shaft. I had an additional half inch removed from it.

IMG_0198.JPG

The first yoke was an ebay special, the new yoke is a Spicer and there is a huge difference between the two. The ebay special was a little loose on the splines of the output shaft but the Spicer is nice and tight. Also, the yoke seems to go into the tail housing a bit more than the ebay special did...I wasn't going to take the chance but I bet it would have worked with the longer drive shaft but I'm happy I don't have to worry about it now. This was a lesson hopefully well learned!

The next item was a gas leak and I consider this one a result of ignorance. I imagine most of you wouldn't take this approach but I used a bulkhead fitting through the front side of the tank for my supply line when I did the in-tank pump about 8 years ago and it didn't leak at all during that time. When I updated the fuel pump I redid a few things in the tank which disturbed the seal and the result was seepage when the tank was full. Wonderful. Anyway, as I was looking at my installation I realized it was less than optimal as I had a nylon seal only on the inside and it wasn't as "solid" in the way it was bolted to the tank as it needed to be. I added a washer and an additional seal on the outside which made a world of difference. It's much more permanent now. Here's a bad picture showing what I'm trying to describe.

IMG_0201.JPG

Last thing on the leak list is the thermostat housing. This one turned out to be a defective part. This one was a frustrating problem because it seemed like it was fixed about a half dozen times. Here's a picture of the housing.

IMG_0197.JPG

I'm using one of those swivel thermostat housings because of the angle I need to route the inlet hose. It actually solved that issue really well. We first noticed it was leaking when Artie came in about a month before the Meet. We tightened the clamp at the housing and it seemed to fix the problem. Waited overnight and the next morning it was dry under the car. We started it and let it warm up and the f&%#er started leaking again. I kept thinking the hose was cocked on the inlet and it wasn't sealing properly. Then I was convinced the swivel part of the housing was leaking so I pulled it off and used some sealant behind the O-ring. Thought that would for sure fix the problem. Put the housing back on, filled it with coolant and the mother was still leaking!!! I ended up pulling the housing, clamping a piece of sheet metal to the O-ring side and kept the hose clamped to it, turned it upside down and filled it with water. It only took 5 minutes to figure out it was leaking where the inlet fitting was screwed into the housing. Luckily, I purchased it from Jeg's and they happen to be located in Columbus so it was a matter of taking the defective part to them and getting a replacement. They were great to deal with. I looked the replacement over pretty good before installing it on the car and discovered that they are now using thread sealant on those threads. Not sure if the original just didn't get the sealant or if they discovered an issue and started to use the sealant on the new ones. Bottom line the leak is now fixed finally!!

The last thing I'll talk about tonight is the tach. So I'm using one of the Theo Smit circuit boards in my tach and have been really happy with it. When I purchased it from him he modified the circuit to use the signal generated by the GM DIS I was using on my V6. I figured that it would be a no brainer to adjust it to the LS1 PCM. I was a little disappointed because I had a terrible fluttering problem with it. I figured that the circuit would need some tweaking so it went to the back burner before the meet. I researched it a little and the common theme that caused this problem was a bad ground. Keep in mind I've been using this circuit for over 10 years with no issue. I pulled the tach out of the housing and I'm looking at it and I don't like the way the ground is looking so I added an additional ground wire directly to the tach housing and suddenly I've got a stable tach! I was able to adjust it finally so all is good now.

I still need to do a few things before the Fall Get Together. My wife will be going so I'm going to add some insulation to the firewall at least on the passenger side and I still need to adjust the throttle pedal. I've decided I don't need to adjust the clutch pedal after all. To summarize, the car should be more reliable now but I still consider it "rough" at this point. I've got a driveline vibration I need to troubleshoot, my crank pulley needs attention and there are about a million other things I want to do yet. I'm in the process of deciding a realistic list of things to do this winter. This post ended up being a novel so I'll shut up for now! :)

Looking forward to seeing everyone in a few weeks!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on September 09, 2015, 11:29:46 PM
Sounds like good progress Scott. Not terribly bad on the "weird problems" list.

Jim
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on September 24, 2015, 06:02:09 PM
Scott, Does the starter work good? How about the clutch?
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on September 24, 2015, 08:59:59 PM
QuoteScott, Does the starter work good? How about the clutch?

Good questions Jim. So it will probably fall off the car tomorrow now that I say this but the starter has been working flawlessly so far. It's quiet in operation and the pattern on the starter gear looks typical to other starter gears I've seen. I'm not foolish enough to declare it a success at this point though. Dale Knapke and I were discussing it at the V8 Meet earlier this year. I think success will be measured in years not months. The question still remains, did I design it to be rigid and unmovable enough to last for a number of years? I should be at the Fall Gathering a week from today with my car. Maybe other members in attendance will chime in on how they think it sounds to get an unbiased opinion.

I guess I really haven't mentioned the clutch too much. As some of you may recall, it's a metallic 6 puck disc. It took at least 500 miles to break it in. It wasn't broken in at the time of the V8 meet and was one of the reasons I didn't want others driving it. It's completely broken in now and grips really well. No problems I'm aware of at the moment. I have an adjustable McLeod throw-out bearing on it. It currently is at the longest setting so the pressure point is a bit high. The next time I pull the transmission I'm going to put it at the middle setting to bring the pressure point down a bit. While I'm on the subject of the clutch I'll mention that when I was discussing what I needed with Ram Clutches, I told them I wanted it spec'd for 400 ft. lbs. and that I would be doing at least an annual autocross and an occasional track day. I don't think I mentioned that before.

I'm looking forward to getting it out on the road next week. Should be close to a 1000 miles before all is said and done. I've been doing a lot of small things to get it ready. I'm going to get it off the ground and crawl under it this weekend to give things a final check and then give it a bath.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on October 09, 2015, 11:10:55 AM
QuoteCurrently the throttle pedal is at about the same height as the brake pedal and I like it lower than the brake by 3/4" to 1".

(http://www.mgexp.com/phile/71/203835/Paddy_Hopkirk_Throttle_Pedal_NOS_Front_View.JPG)

http://www.mossmotors.com/Shop/ViewProducts.aspx?PlateIndexID=37170
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on October 09, 2015, 12:12:18 PM
Scott, Thanks. I was wondering if you added a brace from your starter adapter plate to the oil pan rail. On the clutch, I was worried about starting out and having to slip it quite a bit because of the solid hub. The separate pucks probably help in that respect.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on October 13, 2015, 08:23:58 PM
Thanks for the link Carl, looks like a nice pedal. This is what I'm currently working with.

IMG_0221.JPG

I'm still not totally happy with it and I'm going to revisit it this fall. Need to tweak it a bit.


QuoteScott, Thanks. I was wondering if you added a brace from your starter adapter plate to the oil pan rail. On the clutch, I was worried about starting out and having to slip it quite a bit because of the solid hub. The separate pucks probably help in that respect.

Jim, yes, I've always had a brace to the oil pan rail. I believe it's a must have.

IMG_0215.JPG

Believe it or not, the clutch is very civilized. Much more than I thought it would be. I got caught in a back-up on I75 on the way to Townsend a few weeks ago....no issues at all. I'm very happy with it. At some point other people will drive the car (like Carl) and they can give an unbiased opinion.

So I guess I give a little update. Townsend was a lot of fun. I have about 1800 miles on the "new" motor now. I did have an incident where one of my belts got shredded. I was giving Kelly Stevenson a ride and we didn't get very far. I punched it in second and the belt let go. I was getting pretty good wheel hop at the time. It was the inside drive belt and I originally thought it was caused by the wobbly harmonic balancer and that may have been a contributing factor. I'm now thinking that the belt was rubbing against the "frame rail". It's close and I ground a slot into the flange to gain clearance. That was before I adjusted the belt pulleys by moving the whole thing forward a few mm. I didn't think to widen the slot a little more to account for that. So if this theory is correct the belt would have hit on a sharp edge and that could have caused it to come apart. I pulled things apart yesterday and corrected that issue. One thing for certain, I need to replace that harmonic balancer. It's off at least an 1/8"...pretty bad wobble. I had a bunch of people helping to put the car back together in the hotel parking lot. Believe it or not it was pretty fun. Did anyone get any pictures of the event? I didn't think to get one at the time.

The other issue I encountered was a periodic hiccup when going up hill with a light throttle. That's the best way to describe it. It's almost like taking your foot off the throttle for a split second. You can go 10 miles and nothing will happen and then suddenly it will happen. We talked about it in Townsend a little and I was thinking that it might be in the tune. So on the way home I got to wondering if it could be the MAF sensor? I picked up some MAF cleaner and sprayed the thing out pretty good. Took it out on the highway and had to go nearly twenty miles before getting it to hiccup again but it did hiccup so the cleaning thing didn't work. When I got the car back home I hooked my laptop up to check for codes and sure enough, I had 4 codes set. The two knock sensor codes and then one for the MAF and one for the cam sensor. When the belt came apart it caught the cam sensor plug and pulled it out of the sensor. Anyway, I think my next step will be to replace the MAF and go from there.

It might not sound like it given the above issues but I'm starting to get good confidence in the car and will be anxious to get it out on the road next year.

My list of winter fixes/updates is starting to get more clear now.

o New harmonic balancer
o Resolve the knock sensor codes
o Volvo fan install
o Fuel pump update
o Coil over shocks on the front end (I've got terrible bump steer that I'm attributing to the original sagging coil springs)
o Strengthening the front rear spring mounts.
o Add factory GM cruise control

This is a fluid list but I'm going to concentrate on the first 5 things and see where I end up. I'll update the thread as progress is made.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on October 14, 2015, 11:45:17 AM
I see, by lower you meant closer to the firewall. I was thinking of that little square pedal like on my dad's '63.

I took 1.5" out of the rod on the back of my pedal. The late pedal is way too close to the driver.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: rficalora on October 14, 2015, 08:00:20 PM

The late pedal is way too close to the driver.


Amen to that.  I've modified mine some and am going to move it even further forward.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on January 22, 2016, 11:55:21 AM
I've been meaning to do an update for quite a while but work, family and life seem to get in the way sometimes. I am working on the car when I can though. I'm repeating myself but my goal this winter is to move the car off the "rough" list and onto the "reliable" list. Basically that means going back and addressing issues that I ignored while getting the car on the road last summer. Before I get into the status of the project I wanted to post a current picture of the engine bay. I realized I never did post one. This was taken right after the Fall Gathering so it is a little dirty.

IMG_0222.JPG

On a semi related issue, I also did a little dumpster diving. I noticed that my neighbor was throwing out a bunch of insulation so I grabbed it to use on the garage walls. I'm ashamed to admit it but I've been in my house for over 18 years and never bothered to insulate the garage. I spent a couple of weeks putting the insulation up and it has made a pretty big difference. Should have done it years ago.

garage.jpg

So one thing I haven't had the chance to explore yet was my wideband O2 sensor. Just before I pulled the car off the road I temporarily installed a gauge just to ensure the sensor worked and to get an idea of what was going on with the FI. It actually worked but it was reading lean, even sitting there idling. Investigating that was put on the winter list. As I pulled the exhaust off the car it was obvious I had some leaking going on. Both flanges that connect the down pipes to the rest of the exhaust, just before the Y, were leaking badly. I checked the down pipes while I was at it and noticed some pin holes in them as well. I've been doing a bit of welding lately. :)

The other major issue that needs addressed is the bad harmonic balancer. It's putting a lot of stress on the drive belt. Making good progress there as well. This came yesterday.

LS4Pulley.jpg

Don't ask how much I had to pay for this thing. Ridiculous. The front of the engine bay is disassembled and I just need to pull the old pulley off and put this new one on. I'm going to go back and ensure all the pulleys are lined up as I reassemble things and make a few minor changes to improve reliability as well.

Last weekend I put some new motor mount rubber on the car. I'm a cheap b@stard and I bought some Chinese knock-offs of the Berry mounts that Curtis recommended. I wasn't happy with the way they were holding up so I got a couple of the real thing with a higher durometer. Not sure I've learned my lesson yet though. :)

I've mentioned this before but while I've got the radiator out of the car I'm going to tweak the shroud so it covers the whole surface of the cooling fins. I'll post some pictures when I get to that task. I'm also going to do a slight modification to the cross member so my lower radiator hose routing is improved. It doesn't appear that the Volvo fan is going to fit my application. I'm going to keep it around for possible future use though.

I'm still planning on doing the front coil over shocks and the fuel pump as well as strengthening the front rear spring perches and welding some of the seams in the back as well. Time is slipping by quickly though. Can you believe January is coming to a close?

I will periodically update the thread as progress is made. Oh, this is part of the sorting out process so the project is still ongoing from that perspective. That's why I'm still updating this thread as I feel that it gives a more complete view of the project. If anyone has a different view, please bring it up.

Hope everyone who's in the path of the snow storm stays safe!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on January 23, 2016, 11:05:46 AM
Don't forget a bit more clearance for changing belts.  ;)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on January 24, 2016, 09:02:43 AM
QuoteDon't forget a bit more clearance for changing belts. ;)

For sure Carl!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on January 26, 2016, 02:15:57 PM
Thought I'd do another very small update while I had some time, for the very few of you who may have an interest in this kind of stuff. The following picture shows some of the details of the serpentine belt setup I'm using and some of the effects of the bad harmonic balancer.

LS4IdlerPulleyWear.jpg

Both of the idler pulleys you see were new and installed at the same time. Notice how much of the paint was worn off the rear most pulley. There isn't much "give" since the belt isn't very long and that is making things a little worse. The bad balancer probably contributed to the problems I had measuring the offset when trying to line the pulleys up too. Duh. If I get some time I'll measure just how far off the balancer is just for my own information.

This next one shows one of the GAZ shocks I'm going to use with the new upper mount installed.

GAZShockUpdate.jpg

I've been meaning to do this for a few years but didn't get around to it because I thought it was going to be a PITA. It actually wasn't bad at all. Glad it's done.

That's it for now.

Edit: corrected the automatic Android spelling corrector.  :)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on March 08, 2016, 08:09:07 PM
Been a little while but progress has been steady. Time is flying by. Seems like it was just Christmas and all of a sudden it's the middle of March! Thought I'd be a bit further along by now so I'm reducing the tasks so I'm not stressed out trying to make the meet. I think I'll stop crying and do my update now! :)

As I've mentioned previously I'm concentrating on cleaning up things I rushed to get done last year to make the car more reliable. I'm tweaking the exhaust to get rid of some pesky leaks. Should have it done by next weekend. I'm also working on the front of the motor. I replaced the harmonic balancer this past weekend. This next series of pictures shows a little of that process and where things currently stand.

IMG_1459.JPG

IMG_1463.JPG

IMG_1467.JPG

These are the only pictures in have at the moment. Carl, you'll notice that I should have an easier time slipping a belt between the balancer and the cross member now. I'm also in the middle of putting captive nuts on the radiator support to inner fender mounts. That turned out to be a PITA but it's almost there. Should make pulling the support/shroud much easier.

I also cleaned up and painted the pulley brackets. Now that I have a straight harmonic balancer I'm going to align all the pulleys for the last time I hope. I should have that done next weekend too with some luck. I'll post more pictures of this stuff as I make more progress.

I'm still planning on doing my fuel pump and some welding at the rear of the car but the coil overs at the front will have to wait yet again. I am going to shim the springs at the front to get my ride height a bit better.

I'm really getting excited for the meet and I'm looking forward to seeing everyone!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on March 08, 2016, 08:46:15 PM
Awesome, now you won't need me to lay in the water puddle!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on March 23, 2016, 06:08:30 PM
Time for another update. Made some good progress I think. Got the exhaust all sealed up.

LS4ExhaustMod.JPG

As you can see, not the greatest looking but it should get the job done. There were two flanges where you see the new welds. No real reason to keep them so they're gone now.

The following picture shows the accessory drive brackets finally cleaned up and painted.

LS4AccessoryDrivePainted.JPG

I'm pleased with the way it looks now. I re-aligned all the pulleys since I now have a straight crank pulley. I did find the alternator was off a little unbelievably (to me anyway) but the pulleys are now lined up and parallel with each other. While I was in there I lengthened the range the front belt adjuster moves just in case it's needed. Carl, now that I have confidence in the accessory drive I invested in some good belts. Hopefully no one will have to lay in a water puddle now! :)

This next picture shows my fan shroud and the small change I made to it.

LS4ShroudMod.jpg

Left is old, right is new. Guess I should explain why it was made that way in the first place. When I first installed the radiator I got a bug up my butt that I wanted to see if I could mount the radiator with the shroud without modifying the stock CB front shelf. I still had my V6 at the time. As you can imagine, it was really tight. So tight that I had to allow for the pinion housing on the rack. The front most bolt was so close there wasn't room for a shroud. That's why the corner is/was missing. I did get it to fit and had it that way at the Texas meet. In the overall scheme of things this is a very minor thing, I know, but it was one of those things I meant to get to last year. I feel better now. :-)

The last item I'll talk about is the fuel pump. I had a plan in place to go with an older GM module and upgrade to a high flow pump that fit into the module. So I started looking around for one to buy when I came across this one.

LS4GTOFuelPump.JPG

The one on the left is a 2004-2006 GTO fuel pump module. In the pictures I saw it looked like it might just fit into the MGB tank so I took a chance and purchased one. The module to the right is the VW Jetta unit that I used for my V6. As you may notice, the GTO unit is almost exactly the the same height. Disregard the two posts that support the rods/springs. They will be cut down. I'm pretty excited about it for a number of reasons. The biggest is it was designed to feed a 400 HP LS2 so it leaves room to grow. Another advantage is it is a "returnless" system which means it uses a single line from the tank to the fuel rail. There is also an upgrade path as several vendors make high flow pumps that fit into this module. One final point that closed the sale for me is it uses an internal venturi pump to keep the surge tank/swirl pot/bucket full of fuel which keeps the pump cool and helps to avoid fuel starvation as you go around corners when the fuel level in the tank gets low. As I mentioned, it will require some modification to be used in the B tank. The small canister you see in the upper assembly (which won't be used) is the fuel pressure regulator. I toyed with trying to incorporate it into the tank but decided to go with an external regulator since it will be much easier. I also need to build an in-tank wire harness. I'll add a lot more details as I start doing this task.

I have about two hours of work left on the front of the engine and the car will be drivable at that point. I'll probably start it since it has been so long but I'm thinking I should jump right to the fuel tank. I'm going to reseal the tank as well. (I have a story about that I will tell) I figure it will take two work sessions to complete it so, based on how bad my estimates usually are, it will probably take 4 sessions. That translates to a month in real time since I only get to work on the car one day a week usually. That puts me very close to the meet. I need to stop writing and get back out to the garage....Townsend is sneaking up on us quickly!!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: kstevusa on March 24, 2016, 03:22:21 PM
Great progress Scott.  The GM fuel module should be adequate for your needs.  The one in my car was from a Malibu V6 and never showed lean on the dyno.  All ways showed around 14:1 A/F ratio across the entire band. I was also feeding thru a 5/16 fuel line to 24# injectors.   The workmanship is excellent and should serve you well.  Hope my ride is reserved?  As noted, Time is short :-)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: billymgb1000 on March 24, 2016, 03:34:57 PM
Awesome Scott I am also doing those things that were not really important but I wanted to do anyway, I just welded the seat bolts to the floor under the car so now I have studs that don't move as I put the seats in (love it). Your car is looking great and all the odds and ends your wrapping up you are going to love in the end. good luck brother.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: DiDueColpi on March 24, 2016, 04:09:13 PM
Looking pretty sharp Scott!
If you do mount a remote FPR make sure that it has a return to the tank and does not dead head the pump.
Or your pump life will be very short.
The stock FPR dumps excess fuel back into the thank through the bottom.
If height is the deciding factor why not offset the regulator assy from the pump module?
That way you can use a regulator that you already own and it's matched to your application.

Hope that's of some use.
Cheers
Fred
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on March 24, 2016, 06:14:39 PM
Kelly, thanks! You are first on the list and I want to make sure we do it asap. Time has a way of flying by at the meets. They are SO much fun!! Looking forward to seeing you.

Bill, thanks and those little things do make a difference. When is your car going to be on the road again?

Fred, I really value your input. Thank you for taking the time to respond. I'll be adding pictures as I get things done but the reason for not using the stock FPR is the difficulty of fitting it in the tank. I won't be using the upper assembly at all. I have a rectangular cover in place at the top of the tank now and I'm going to mount the module to it. It would take a lot of work to modify that upper assembly to fit on the cover. It's hard to describe in words but I will get some pictures to make it more clear after I pull the tank. The FPR I got is a three port unit that has a return port but I don't think I'm going to have any dead head issues. The fuel pump outlet is o-ringed into a manifold which contains an internal filter and the venturi "pump". Part of the pump output is diverted to the venturi assembly which is o-ringed to the bottom of the bucket. So it actually isn't a returnless system in a strict sense as the return is "powering" the venturi which sucks fuel into the bucket if I understand what is going on correctly. It is much better to see pictures of this rather than try to describe it and I'll try to put some up asap. You may be aware of this already but if not, would you still be concerned with a dead head situation?

On a side note I think it's an ingenious setup and I'm a big fan of GM's engineering dept.

Here is a video of the system in action:

<iframe width="420" height="315" src="//www.youtube.com/embed/n0gAlkV2xGc" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: DiDueColpi on March 24, 2016, 06:56:28 PM
I'm not sure that enough of the output is diverted to the venturi pump to be useful Scott.
The other issue is the three port FPR. On most, if the return port is blocked, they no longer have the ability to regulate pressure.
It might be best to mock up the system first and bench test it with a gauge and amp-meter before installing it.

Fred
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on March 24, 2016, 07:10:43 PM
Thank you Fred. It's actually not going to be an issue running a return from the FPR. I'm mounting it to the battery box so all I need are a couple of fittings. Everything else is right there. I appreciate the advice!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: billymgb1000 on March 26, 2016, 04:30:39 AM
That's pretty cool scott, my car would have been painted this last week but the weather turned back to winter so I'm hoping the end of next week she'll be painted and then it's just putting her back together. So by the end of april the latest she will be smoking the tires. yeee haaa
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on March 27, 2016, 11:02:24 PM
So it's interesting how you can go from  being pretty ignorant on a subject to at least thinking that you're somewhat informed. I've been doing some pretty intensive research on this fuel pump so I thought I'd bring everyone up to speed on what I've found out about the GTO fuel pump. I'm not sure at this point how I missed some of this information initially.

I took some pictures of the disassembled pump which I hope will be enlightening to those who might be interested in this. The first picture is of the bucket.

LS4GTOBucket.jpg

On the left you can see the valve that lets the fuel in the bucket equalize with that inside the tank. On the right where you see the o-ring is the port for the venturi pump. The next picture shows the outside of the bucket.

 LS4GTOVenturi.jpg

On the left you can see the port that the venturi pulls the fuel through. On the right is the tube/port that the valve in the previous picture is associated with. The next picture is the interesting one in my opinion.  

LS4GTOFuelPumpFPR.jpg

The enlarged inset shows the venturi pump assembly which is the black component. You can see that there is an FPR on the assembly. The upper assembly shown in a previous picture is a part of the tank/vapor venting system and has nothing to do with fuel delivery. So the canister I pointed out earlier is not the FPR. I'm taking the long way to tell you that the module is, in fact, a self contained unit. I communicated with a guy who has done two conversions using this pump and he confirmed it. It should be pretty simple to adapt this pump to my tank. This last picture shows the modified module with the updated wiring harness.

2016-03-2722.39.09.jpg

I still need to fabricate a plate to attach the shortened rods and springs to and weld the assembly to the existing top cover on my tank. Shouldn't be too bad.

I want to thank Fred for getting me to think in more detail about what I was about to do and keeping me from making a mistake. I will add more details later.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: DiDueColpi on March 29, 2016, 01:01:09 PM
That's awesome Scott!
I should have clued in sooner about the FPR.
They're using the waste from the FPR to power the venturi pump.
Simple, neat and tidy.
Looks like you're good to go.

Cheers
Fred
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on March 29, 2016, 01:07:56 PM
That sounds pretty neat, they're using the return line to fill the bucket from the tank? Like the jet pumps used in water wells use a jet to lift water out of the well? Sounds like somebody was using their noggin.

Jim
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on April 25, 2016, 01:44:17 PM
Time for a quick update. Well, it's back on the road. A little later than I had hoped before the meet but still earlier than in past years. Also my list of things to do at the beginning of winter was whittled down to about half of what I had hoped to accomplish. Not a huge issue as this is a long term project. I'm still going to rate the car as "rough" but it should be much more reliable now and I'm really happy with where I'm at with it.

So the fuel pump is in and seems to work great! Pressure is right at 58 psi and it's now a true single line system. Here's a picture of it in the tank just before I closed things up. You can see it fits really well.

IMG_1558.JPG

It's really quiet. The car should be much more reliable with this change. I want to say the engine runs better but this is probably like getting a new set of sneakers (tennis shoes) as a kid. I was always convinced I could run faster and jump higher with them. :) This next picture shows where I was coming from for those of you who are wondering "WTF is he doing, the car runs with the current pump!"

IMG_1560.JPG

What you are looking at is a Bosch 040 knock off pump inside a VW Jetta bucket. This is a common performance upgrade for the VW guys. The main reasons I went with it is because it was easy, cheap and the pump flowed enough to support the LS4. I also had a fixture in the bottom of the tank that allowed me to mount the pump bucket by just twisting it on. No fuel tank mods and it got me on the road for last summer. It's kind of "ghetto" and there are quite a few things wrong with it. The main thing is the bucket is just a holder and doesn't function as a surge tank at all. The original VW unit was really nice in that it had a pump housing built into the bottom of the pump that drew fuel from both the bucket and the tank. It just didn't flow enough fuel to use with an LS engine.

So I put a brand new idler pulley in my accessory drive and the f&*king thing wobbles. I'm going to replace it before the meet. Seems like it's so difficult to put something to bed once and for all...frustrating at times. It was a plastic one and I'm going with metal now so it will be better all around.

Other than cleaning the car up, I'm going to be putting some miles on it and addressing anything that comes up between now and the meet. As I've said many times, I'm really looking forward to it!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on June 09, 2016, 06:53:24 PM
Thought I'd do a minor update since it has been a while. I've put well over 1500 miles on the car so far this year. Knock on wood they've been trouble free so far. I had some squeal from my accessory drive but it was the new belts stretching a little and some tightening seems to have cured it.

I took the car on the Eric Jones Memorial Riverrun over the memorial day weekend. It is an all day tour to the Ohio river across some outstanding roads in southeast Ohio. I went by myself so I had an opportunity to beat on my car for many hours and not worry about my wife yelling in my ear to slow down! &#128513; Here I am at the start of the day.

 http://crashton.smugmug.com/5-28-2016-Erics-Riverrun/i-MBp9MXt/A

It was so much fun and it was the first time with the LS. I've been going on this tour on and off since the early 90s so I started off with my 4 cylinder. The torque of this V8 is unreal. I won't bore you with the details but I'm so looking forward to West Virginia next year!

I'm in the process of putting the heater back in the car as a summer project .

IMG_1581.JPG

There have been several instances where it would have been nice to have it so it has moved up the list. The good thing is the car doesn't have to be off the road for any extended period to get it done.

I've been thinking about doing this for a while and I'm guessing that there is some curiosity about the costs of doing an LS4 conversion into a B. I thought I'd share a little bit of what I encountered. This is LS4 specific.  I'm going to present it as a "ready to run engine" with the components I think should be included,  you may not agree. Hope this helps when comparing other engines similarly equipped if you want to include an LS4 during the planning part of your project.

LS4 w/59k $850 w/Ohio tax
Flywheel  $400
Starter $70
Starter mount materials $30
DBC throttle body $45
Water pump $100
Accessory drive assembly  $200

Total  $1695

I don't think that's too bad. Keep in mind that this for an all aluminum LS motor that has 303 HP and 323 ft/lbs of torque out of the box. Also, the LS4 is the red headed step child so it isn't in demand like the RWD car and truck aluminum engines are. There are good and bad things about this. The good is you're likely to find an LS4 that is much cheaper with less miles on it. The bad is you have to deal with the starter. That will be a show stopper for a lot of guys. There is a lot more to this but I'll stop here for now.

I know there is a lot more needed beyond what I listed but most of it is going to be common to every engine.

This ended up being much longer than I intended. Hope you found it interesting and/or informative.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on June 10, 2016, 08:43:16 AM
These days that's an exceptional value Scott. And for anyone capable of building their own engine mounts and headers, doing the starter conversion should not be too difficult. We need more info on engine positioning of course but that will come. I'd guess you should have another 200K miles or more left in that engine, how is it doing for fuel economy?

Next year I'd like to consider doing that Memorial Day drive, keep me in mind if you would.

Jim
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on June 10, 2016, 04:16:39 PM
Jim,

I'm getting in the mid-20s so far. I expect it will improve a little when I do the rear axle.

I'll for sure keep you informed about Riverrun. Having your car there will shake things up a bit in would imagine. &#128522;
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: lwcwb08 on December 07, 2016, 04:51:21 PM
Scott, was there anything preventing you from running a different crank dampener to get around the accessory drive issue? For instance running an ls2 crank dampener/water pump?
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on December 07, 2016, 09:41:54 PM
Hey Mike,
Good question. I considered just about every scenario I think. When I was first planning the conversion I debated between a truck aluminum LS with the Corvette accessory drive to putting the Corvette crank pulley on the LS4. I haven't gone into many of the goals I laid out when I first started planning this project but the main ones were:

        o Must fit under the stock hood
        o Steering rack to remain in stock position
        o Absolute minimum modification of the car to fit the new engine

The first two were show stoppers.....I would have gone a different route to meet those goals, FYI. So when I started looking at the different combinations it became apparent pretty quickly that the truck motor would require a lot more work to fit especially with the size of the sbc bellhousing. The LS4 is for sure the shortest LS engine followed by the Corvette versions. The difference between the two was about 3/4" when using the Corvette pulley. Using the Corvette pulley would have allowed using off the shelf accessory drive components which is a good thing. But as you know, 3/4" is huge and I couldn't move the engine further forward without violating my steering rack goal. So on the downside it would have meant cutting much more deeply into the firewall to accommodate the LS4 bellhousing. It would have made adapting the stock heater assembly pretty much impossible and that was also part of my overall plan. The upside of the LS4 pulley is less intrusion into the firewall. The downside is I would have to design and build a custom accessory drive. So for me it was a pretty easy decision to go with the LS4 pulley. To be honest I was looking forward building the accessory drive and I ended up really enjoying the process......doing stuff like that is one of the reasons I enjoy this hobby so much.

I know this is probably much more information than you were looking for but I'm trying to point out it often isn't a simple yes or no choice and this was just one of many decisions I had to make over the course of the project. All of them are a compromise in some way and a good thing about having a plan/goals in place is it is a little easier to assess the consequences of each decision you make. Otherwise it's easy to fall into the 10 year plan as each uninformed decision changes the scope in unintended ways. At least it works that way for me! &#128522; Other people are going to have different goals, make different decisions and end up in a completely different place. That's another thing I really like about this hobby.....the great variety you see in other guys work.

Hope I answered your question.

Scott
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on December 07, 2016, 09:44:33 PM
Forgot to mention I am running the short Corvette water pump.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: lwcwb08 on December 08, 2016, 07:27:18 AM
Thanks Scott! I enjoyed reading this thread, gave me many ideas for my build. I'm leaning more and more towards the LS4 since it's so cheaply acquired. Mines a 77 RB so might get away with using vette accessories without too much cutting into the firewall.

As much as I hate it I believe my MGB conversion falls into the 10 year plan with 3 young kids at home haha!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on December 08, 2016, 09:11:37 AM
Glad you enjoyed it Mike. Don't have kids so I was never faced with that.

My good friend Artie just bought a 78 B V8 and I took a quick measurement of his rack to crossmember gap and it was almost exactly an inch further forward compared to my car. So if you plan on keeping the steering rack in the stock position, which I recommend, your firewall mods will be very similar to mine since your engine will be set back about that much with the Vette pulley in place.

Hope you do a build thread here when you get started. I would be very interested in how you approach this.

Scott
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on December 08, 2016, 11:18:18 AM
QuoteMy good friend Artie just bought a 78 B V8 and I took a quick measurement of his rack to crossmember gap and it was almost exactly an inch further forward compared to my car

Now there's some good info!  That is about what I thought.  Can't find the thread where we discussed it, though.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on December 08, 2016, 11:56:54 AM
QuoteNow there's some good info! That is about what I thought. Can't find the thread where we discussed it, though.


It's here:

http://forum.britishv8.org/read.php?6,55025,page=1

I want to do an update there when i get some time.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on December 09, 2016, 10:50:02 AM
Not the thread I was thinking of.  It may have been on that other forum.  ;)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mgb260 on December 09, 2016, 02:50:10 PM
Scott, Great work! What rear axle did you decide on?
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on December 09, 2016, 03:08:51 PM
Hey Jim,

I'm going with an S-10 7.625 3:42. I hope to at least get started on it this winter sometime. We will have to see. I live within driving distance to Moser so that will help.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on December 09, 2016, 04:18:40 PM
Found it! Spent nearly 2 hours looking. Never would have guessed it was over a year & a half ago.  Google make waaay too much revenue from its not all that great search engine. What a PITA.

Quote from: V8MGBV8
Quote from: scott68BHow much further forward is the RBB rack compared to the CBB rack?
   

   Not sure, Scott. An inch or so?

Quote from: scott68BAt this point in time it looks like it's going to require about the same amount of effort to get the LS into a RBB as it is to get it into a CBB although if Carl is right and the rack is 1" further forward in a RBB then the heater and rack can stay where they are if you're using an LS4.
   
   

http://www.mgexp.com/phorum/read.php?40,2976250
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on December 10, 2016, 10:52:43 PM
&#128522; I remember that thread! Nice you could relocate it. Yeah, time is going by so quickly. As I become more familiar with RBBs I'm more convinced it's going to be relatively easy to fit an LS4 in one.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BMC on December 17, 2016, 05:32:43 PM
Scott,

It's looking good.

What does that engine run out of power at? 5500? 6- 6500?? I know what my car is geared like and believe that you might want to look at 3.23 with the extra power even if it does rev higher. Unless you are going with a wide body kit, you're going to need to narrow that axle down.

-BMC.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on December 18, 2016, 10:48:51 AM
Hey Brian,

Peak HP is at 5600 RPM. I wouldn't say it falls off a cliff after that as it is still close to 300 at the red line of 6000 RPM. Thank you for the suggestion on the ratio. I've been going back and forth between the two. So this past spring I went on a tour to some great twisty roads in southeast Ohio. I got to beat on the car for several hours. I really liked the way the car performed with the stock gear in that situation.  On the other side,  I spend a lot of time on freeways going back and forth to events so a lower ratio would help there. I came to the conclusion that the 3.42 is a good compromise.

Oh, Moser narrows axles, that's why I mentioned them. &#128522;

Are you coming to the meet?
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on December 19, 2016, 09:28:50 AM
Mike,

I just remembered that I neglected to mention another option I considered when deciding which way I was going to go with the crank pulley/accessory drive. I looked into an electric water pump very seriously for a time and, for a short time, actually made the decision to go that route. I was looking at this pump:

 http://www.jegs.com/i/JEGS-Performance-Products/555/50950/10002/-1

I was planning on mounting it on the shelf in front of the radiator. You use these big AN and vendor fittings to plumb it. It's actually pretty neat in many ways. One advantage is you get lots of room at the front of the engine without the stock water pump in the way. An even bigger plus, in the case of the LS4, is you don't have to worry about driving the water pump and it greatly simplifies the conversion using the stock LS4 crank pulley. I think that is a compelling reason for going this route and as I mentioned,  I made the decision to go with it and was planning for it for several weeks. It's funny, but I kept thinking about turning the key on and listening to that pump running each time I started the engine and also reliability issues, whether they are real or not. For those reasons I opted to go with a traditional water pump.

Just mentioning this as another option I looked at.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: lwcwb08 on December 20, 2016, 09:55:54 AM
That remote water pump setup would free up a lot of space for a turbocharger &#128521;
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on December 20, 2016, 05:00:01 PM
QuoteThat remote water pump setup would free up a lot of space for a turbocharger &#128521;

Mike,

Your build planning seems to have taken an interesting turn! &#128522;
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BMC on December 26, 2016, 12:45:30 AM
Scott, My MGB with 200 or so foot pounds of torque and an engine that basically ends at 5,000 RPM currently has the 3.42 behind it and with future modifications and more power band, the 3.42 is going to make sense. With your engine of more than 300 foot pounds of torque plus an engine that runs to 5600+ before it runs out, 3.42 is not bad. Since I like my car somewhat quiet and I don't mind losing a 1/10th second, I wouldn't mind either the 3.23 or 3.42. The question would become- does the 1/10 second loss in 0-60 bother me more or during a 80 mile drive, would that 200 RPM drop give me a more relaxed feeling during and after the drive.

Looking forward to your future water pump choices.

-BMC.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on January 04, 2017, 08:07:11 PM
I mentioned on the other forum that a couple of guys contacted me with some questions about the LS4 starter approach I used. I've stayed in touch via Instagram with one guy named Justin (crustywagon on Instagram). I don't mean this to sound condescending he's a younger guy but he's  just like us....loves cars and conversions. He's putting his LS4 into an old Toyota wagon. He's in the automotive business and has access to lots of equipment. He's got a lot of talent. I asked him if he could share his starter solution. I think you'll enjoy it......I did. He's documenting his build on instagram so check out more of  his work there.

<iframe width="750" height="600" src="https://www.instagram.com/p/BOxpIahgq3l/embed/" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on January 30, 2017, 04:20:32 PM
It's about time for an update to bring anyone who might still be following this thread up on where the conversion currently stands.

Believe it or not, I have about 5000 miles on the car since the conversion. I put more miles on the car this past year than I have for many years. It's been really reliable so far. I am very pleased with the conversion, it's every bit what I imagined it would be.

So I'm neck deep in my winter projects. The weather hasn't been too bad so progress has been steady. I'm doing a wide range of things this year including the following:

- Volvo fan install
- Reinstalling the stock heater box w/Fiero fan update
- Factory cruise install
- New seats

This will end up being a bit long so I'll break it down into a few posts. Since all of the changes involve wiring,  I concentrated on getting most of the wiring done first. The F6 wire sleeving that Jim Stabe suggested is working great. I was able to get into the harness easily and incorporate my changes with no issues. It was the right choice for me. Thanks again for the suggestion Jim! I'll start with the cruise control since it is straight forward. It is mostly a wiring exercise and is pretty straight forward. You need to supply key on power and ground to the module and then tie the module to the cruise control switch,  the brake/clutch switches, and the PCM. Here is the module partially installed into the engine bay.

LS4CruiseModuleInstall.jpg

I got the module out of a 2000 Cadillac DeVille mainly so I was sure it would work with my throttle body. Most of the GM Cruise modules from that period are the same but the cable ends vary depending on the application. You can change the cable but I think it is easier to get the right one to begin with.

So I really like having the cruise switch within easy reach and in a place you don't have to take your eyes off the road to find. For my situation finding a cheap turn signal mounted switch I could adapt seemed like the easiest approach.  I looked around for quite a while finally settling on a cruise switch from a 94-95 Grand Am. I wasn't sure it was going to work like I hoped but thought it was worth the chance based on what I could see in the pictures so I bought one. It actually worked out really well. Most of you may know that on a 68 B the horn switch is a part of the turn signal switch so something needed to be done there first. A new steering wheel was on the list so an aftermarket unit was purchased. Luckily, the parts for a steering wheel mounted horn switch that was used for a period of time on later Bs are available from Moss. Here is what I ended up with.

LS4HornMod.jpg

The steering wheel hub had to be drilled and the contact ring modified to fit properly to the hub but the mods were straight forward. 

Next the stock turn signal switch and the Grand Am switch had to be modified.  Here's a picture of of what they looked like after modification.

LS4CruiseSwitch.jpg

The Grand Am switch has a hollow tube running down the middle of it that the cruise switch wiring runs through. That tube is also a part of the headlight switch. At the end of the tube there is an arm that actually flips the internal headlight switch. This really isn't important to this description since I cut all of that stuff off of the switch anyway but I thought I'd include it. The interesting part about that tube is the MGB turn signal arm is a nice snug fit into it. So with a little tweaking you can just push the Grand Am switch on and you're good to go. Here is a picture of it installed.

LS4CruiseSwitchInstalled.jpg

I still have to finish the cruise module mount and build the brake/clutch switch mount but should be done after that.

I'll close for now but will add more later.

Edit: corrected some grammar/spelling
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on January 30, 2017, 05:47:24 PM
Anyone else having trouble watching the above video?  I signed up for Instagram just to watch it & it still won't play for me!

Nice cruise, Scott.  I didn't see replacing the DoD lifters on your list.  ;)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Capt'n Moorgone on January 30, 2017, 06:05:30 PM
Video played for me OK.

  Scott didn't mention the new steering wheel! Looks sweet. Smaller wheel will need EPS, LOL

Mike
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on January 30, 2017, 08:55:11 PM
Hey guys, thanks for spending my money and scheduling my time!&#128513;

I know you guys are busting my chops but it brings up a couple points. I think most guys with very limited time have to prioritize their time and pick their projects carefully. For me, two out of the four were wife driven which jumps it pretty far up the list. Another is a sorting out task and the last seems to fit into what I'm doing with the rest. So these are the top priority tasks for ME at this point. The car will be much better when these are in place. On the other hand I really want to get to work on the suspension and it will be my top priority starting this year. I think I most of the decisions are made at this point.

Carl, I really want to get rid of that cam but the car does really well in spite of it....it can stay for now. Mike, same with EPS, I'll have it on my car but I'll need to wait for now.

What have you guys been up to?
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: kstevusa on January 31, 2017, 09:10:09 AM
Scott, I'm impressed with your craftsmanship and progress, keep up the good work.   Question is,"What will you do when you complete the major and minor portions of this build?"  You cannot just "QUIT".  The tweeks are what keep your interest and provides satisfaction for a job well done!  ;-)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on January 31, 2017, 09:26:39 AM
I spent 12 hours Saturday working on the TR6 ChumpCar race car with Max, Tim, Daryl, & the rest of the team.  

Mikey is fixing to be knee deep in a secret project with his brother, Al, it seems.

I know the cam is is fine, Scott, but friends don't let friends drive with DoD lifters in their engines!  ;)

(http://image.superchevy.com/f/101362120+w640+h640+q80+re0+cr1+st0/07-ls-engine-dod-lifters.jpg)
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on January 31, 2017, 10:42:16 AM
Quote"What will you do when you complete the major and minor portions of this build?" You cannot just "QUIT".


Thanks Kelly! I'm looking out probably to 4 or 5 years before I reach that point. Who knows what will happen in during that time. If nothing else after I retire I suspect I'll go back and redo some of the fabrication tasks to make them look a little better. I've actually been thinking lately that at some point I'll document some of the things I've done...sort of an owner's manual for the next guy that I'll keep with the car. I'll never quit playing with the car, that's for sure.


QuoteI spent 12 hours Saturday working on the TR6 ChumpCar race car with Max, Tim, Daryl, & the rest of the team.

Mikey is fixing to be knee deep in a secret project with his brother, Al, it seems.

I know the cam is is fine, Scott, but friends don't let friends drive with DoD lifters in their engines! ;)


Wow, you've been busy! Mike mentioned he might be assisting Al with something.

If it makes you feel any better, I have an LS1 cam (from Calvin) and a set of LS6 springs sitting on the shelf waiting to go into the motor. As you know it's an involved task especially when it comes to tuning the engine for the changes.

Did you try going directly to Instagram to view the video?

Try this URL after you fix it up:  https :// www.instagram.com/p/BOxpIahgq3l/

I'm able to get to it from multiple machines including my work laptop which is really locked down.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on January 31, 2017, 11:11:03 AM
With XP?  :)  Turns out the video will run in Chrome, but not Firefox on my XP machine.

Slick starter solution!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mstemp on March 21, 2017, 06:16:25 PM
Just was thinking about how the TVR's used forward facing exhaust header/manifolds. Would this be an option with the LS series engines into the MGB? Flowtech has the ones below available and thought it might be possible, but unlikely.

http://www.jegs.com/i/Flowtech/387/11535/10002/-1
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on March 22, 2017, 09:33:49 PM
QuoteJust was thinking about how the TVR's used forward facing exhaust header/manifolds. Would this be an option with the LS series engines into the MGB? Flowtech has the ones below available and thought it might be possible, but unlikely. 

Hi Mike,

I'll give you my opinion. If you have your heart set on it you probably can get them to work but there are going to be a lot of compromises to make along the way. There isn't an over abundance of room in the B engine bay with an LS engine in it. It looks like the collector end of that particular set is going to sit pretty far forward and I'd be worried about getting the bonnet closed with them in place. It would be an interesting exercise to route the exhaust too. You'd probably have to go through the front of the inner fender and then up and over the shocks before going under the car with it. You would be going under the crossmember otherwise. Accessory drive routing would be another fun exercise. Again, I think it's doable for a motivated individual and I'd enjoy watching someone try it especially if a turbo was part of the equation.

This is my opinion again but from an aesthetic point of view (this is hard for me to put into words) I think it looks unfinished or like the guy gave up and just threw an exhaust on it. In my favorite MGB conversions, the engine looks like it belongs there and this approach doesn't quite do it for me. Others may disagree.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mstemp on March 23, 2017, 11:03:59 AM
Scott,

Yes aesthetically not the best, just thought it may be possible. I see one of the biggest obstacles to any conversion the fabrication required. Had hoped those headers might remove one of the major obstacles. (Besides the mounts & potential RB clearances).

Maybe you should market headers Scott!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on March 23, 2017, 11:10:58 AM
I concur. This type exhaust will put quite a bit more heat in the engine bay, and up close to the hood as well where it could get the paint hot enough to bubble under the wrong conditions. It also introduces a fairly significant risk of skin burns if the hood is open. Routing over the shock would be pretty difficult and under the crossmember cuts ground clearance significantly. It could probably be done, but not all that can be done should be done.

Jim
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on March 23, 2017, 12:29:16 PM
Mike,

Are you considering an LS swap?
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on March 23, 2017, 08:07:16 PM
Saturday I think we will be junkyarding for an LS4. Let you know how that goes.

Jim
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: mstemp on March 23, 2017, 10:03:08 PM
Scott,

No my Rover 4.6 will have to do. Just thinking of others. We now have Bill Guzman working on the Ecoboost, LS would be another great new option for new conversions. Unlike yourself I am not a pioneer! Congrats on your build.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on March 24, 2017, 10:39:34 AM
Thanks Mike! I really appreciate it. Just an FYI, I built my car for myself, not with the intention of  developing a kit. Perhaps I would have done things a little differently? Not sure as I never even considered the possibility. I have zero time to get involved with developing a kit or even just components at this point in my life.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on April 11, 2017, 10:06:36 AM
Thought I'd do a quick update. My car is back on the road and I took it out for a few rides to continue to sort it out. I was pretty pleased overall. Bottom line, the car appears to be running about 10 degrees cooler than it did last year and the Volvo fan takes the heat away much faster than my old fan did. I should mention that I've run the old setup on days that were in the low to mid 90s many times with no issues but I worried about how the cooling system would perform in a traffic jam on days in the high 90s and above. That was the motivation to include the Volvo fan upgrade this winter.

So a few things have changed compared to my old cooling system setup. Obviously,  the biggest change was the addition of the Volvo fan but I made some other changes that may have had an effect as well. As I mentioned earlier, I reinstalled the heater back into the car which required me to add some 90 degree fittings at the water pump in place of the plugs I  installed originally. So in my research to make these changes I discovered a few inconsistencies in what I was doing. I needed a 90 degree thermostat housing that pointed straight down for my application so I got an aftermarket unit that swivels 360 degrees. It specified that a Gen 1 SBC thermostat should be used and that is what I did. Seemed to work ok. What I realized after my research is the machined surface/opening in the water pump on the wall that separates the hot and cool sides within the pump is there for a reason. Duh! You can see it in the pic below.

20170410_154701.jpg

The protrusion you see to the left contains the inlet/outlet from the heater core. This is pretty obvious but for the heater ports in the water pump the hot side comes off the hot side of the pump and the cool side is the return from the heater core. The LS thermostat has a spring loaded valve that covers the machined surface/outlet inside the pump. See picture below.

20170410_154328-884x884.jpg

During warm up the valve comes off the machined surface and allows the hot side to blend with the cool side internally within the pump. Some say it's to keep coolant flowing through the block to avoid pump cavitation. As the engine reaches operating temperature the blending is reduced as the valve closes when the thermostat begins to open and more of the hot coolant is directed to the radiator. The point to this is with the SBC thermostat, it's possible not enough of the hot coolant is going through the radiator which could reduce the efficiency of the system.  I believe I could have had issues if I didn't make changes because with the addition of the heater, even more hot coolant would have been bypassing the radiator as I'm using one of the 4 outlet heater valves. So when the heat is off the coolant is directed back to the cool side of the pump bypassing the heater core. Although my original setup wasn't optimal I think it worked because I had plugs in the heater outlets in the pump. Hope this makes some sense. I had to modify the LS thermostat slightly so it would fit into the thermostat housing but it wasn't a big deal. I attribute my cooler running while going down the road to two things, using the correct LS thermostat, and going from a 12" fan to the 15" Volvo fan which is allowing air to flow through the radiator a little easier since the hole in my shroud is now bigger. FYI,  I usually log during my drives and I'm comparing a log I did last October with the two I did the other day. The weather was very close temperature wise on those two days.

Here is a current picture of the engine bay.

20170410_080437-1612x120911.jpg

You may notice that I finally moved the air filter from behind the radiator into some cooler air. I logged incoming air temperatures in the 160s and above on hot days last summer. This change should help with that. Oh, before anyone mentions it, I know this filter is small and and I hope to go to a larger one before the meet. I would bet it is hurting flow at high RPMs.

I still have to do the seats and further clean up/sorting from my winter tasks. Really looking forward to the meet!
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on April 11, 2017, 10:32:14 AM
Looking good Scott, a proper conversion to be sure. Interesting note on that thermostat. Robertshaw made thermostats that worked in a similar fashion (and still does I expect). I'm most familiar with the one used in the I-H SV series V8 engines, which also closed off a port in the bottom of the housing when it opened.

Jim
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: MGBV8 on April 11, 2017, 11:39:56 AM
Beat me to it, Scott.  :)

Looks like you have room for a longer round straight or round tapered air filter.  Here the one I believe come with K&N's Air Charger kit for the Impala, Monte Carlo, Grand Prix  5.3L

http://www.knfilters.com/search/product.aspx?prod=RF-1048

I much prefer the new color of the fan cover/shroud.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on April 11, 2017, 03:25:20 PM
Thanks guys.

QuoteBeat me to it, Scott. :)

I figured you'd have something to add Carl which is why I tried to beat you to it! &#128522;


QuoteI much prefer the new color of the fan cover/shroud.

Yeah, it's all new. I had to move the radiator forward a little to accommodate the Volvo fan so I decided to do it over rather than trying to adapt the original. It's very visible so it has to be right. I applied the lessons I learned from the first time too. I went with semi-gloss rather than satin this time. It's not perfect but I think it looks pretty good.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: standard32 on August 02, 2017, 07:11:56 PM
Nice job and thanks for all the documentation

I'm trying to get my head around balancer/crank/timing cover compatibility...

you posted this on page 9..... "I also replaced the timing cover. The main reason I did this was the original LS4 timing cover has the cam sensor positioned 180 degrees from the position of the RWD LS motors. Obviously, the signal from the cam sprocket reluctor will occur at a different time. I did a lot of investigation but couldn't tell if the 0411 looks at a rising edge, falling edge or just an edge and didn't want to take the chance of finding out the LS4 cover doesn't work when everything was together. An added benefit is the water pump fits without having to modify the timing cover. ....

If I'm understanding correctly, you are saying you still retain the original LS4 crank and cam ...but with a RWD timing cover?

If so, which RWD timing cover did you use? Or maybe they are all the same though?  (I haven't had any luck finding that info yet).... I worried that the truck timing cover would protrude too far and hit the balancer so that's why I was curious if that's a truck or a shallower version.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on August 03, 2017, 03:08:22 PM
Hey Kenny,

Thank you!


QuoteIf I'm understanding correctly, you are saying you still retain the original LS4 crank and cam ...but with a RWD timing cover?

If so, which RWD timing cover did you use? Or maybe they are all the same though? (I haven't had any luck finding that info yet).... I worried that the truck timing cover would protrude too far and hit the balancer so that's why I was curious if that's a truck or a shallower version.

Yes, I'm using the original LS4 crank, cam, cam spockets/chain with an "LS2" timing cover. I took the old timing cover off and directly placed the new one on the motor. It was from a car motor I believe. I got it off of a guy on LS1Tech. The dimensions of the new timing cover appear to be the same as the LS4 cover (except for the position of the cam sensor) and it's been on the car for close to 5,000 miles now with no issues. I'm pretty sure the truck covers are the same and will interchange but you should double check that yourself before buying one.

You probably already know this but the original LS1 had the cam sensor at the back of the engine and with the LS2 it was moved to the front and placed in the timing cover. The LS4 is of the same "generation" as the LS2, in regards to the timing cover/position of the cam sensor at least.

Tell us a little about what you intend to put the LS4 into. It's ok if it isn't a British car. :) What computer are you going to use?
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: standard32 on August 03, 2017, 06:51:57 PM
Thanks. I have a 34 Ford pickup and an LM7 5.3 (from a truck). Like you, I have a very tight physical space to fit it in... I made it worse by making my own front crossmember that sits a couple inches higher than the original (thus lowering the truck a couple inches.)  I don't want to cut any more than absolutely necessary on the firewall, so I'm trying to make the engine as compact as possible.

After digging around on the internet, I stumbled on to the front wheel drive LS4 balancer. I just bought one and am anxious to try to put it on. Through cross referencing dimensions for part numbers, I found that the LS4 and LM7 balancer share the same inner diameter and it should fit. But, the LS4 crankshaft is 10mm shorter....meaning the LM7 crank will stick out 10mm further.
I am thinking that, if I'm lucky, and the depth of the balancers is the same where it fits on the crank, I might be able to solve this problem by making a spacer that is clearanced to slide over the crank to allow the bolt to tighten against the balancer.

I will have to do some searching on the timing covers. That is definitely helpful to know that an Ls2 timing cover worked with the LS4.

I am very new to LS stuff. I'm just sort of going at it with the mentality of working my way through it and trying to figure out as I go.
I plan to go with a carb rather than the fuel injection though.

Here are a couple before/after pics where I made tubular crossmembers and how much tighter it is around the balancer now.
34framebefore.jpg
34aresizedcrossmember.jpg
34resize.jpg
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on August 03, 2017, 07:23:31 PM
Very cool project! Thanks for sharing. I really like your garage too!

I'm quite sure that you'll be OK with the truck timing cover. I'm just cautious with advice because I don't want to lead someone down the wrong path. I didn't take any measurements but the crankshaft was still recessed into the pulley when it was fully seated on the LS4 crank. I'm not sure there was 10mm of space left but at least there was something there.

Keep us informed how this works out for you if you don't mind? I think this will be very useful information.
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BWA on July 27, 2019, 05:48:25 PM
Hello Scott it has been a while since i have talked to you.
I have been driving my TR6 (Gm 3400 v6 engine) for a while now and I have 2900 miles on it now.
When I switched out the TR6 diff which I had set up with a reluctor wheel and a 2003 Olds Alero vehicle speed sensor I installed a Nissan r200 diff and I used one of the abs sensors for a vehicle speed sensor.
It seems that the Nissan abs sensor does not talk to the ecu and the air idle control system is not working as well as it could.
So I am looking at re-using the Alero speed sensor.
The alero speed sensor has two wires one is yellow and the other is purple.
The last time i used this sensor I did not pay attention to these colors and I hooked up the sensor to the two wires that go to the ecu.  
Now I am wondering if I need to make sure the wires goes to the proper connectors on the ecu.
Or does it make any difference?
When you set up the vss for the ls4 engine did you have to make sure that each wire went to a respective hookup on the ecu?
This stuff drives me nuts anyways thanks for your time and consideration.
Cheers
Byron
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: Scott Costanzo on July 29, 2019, 01:06:10 PM
Hey Byron, I'm just seeing this. Can't believe it's been two years since there has been a post to this thread! Time flies.

When I did mine, I did some research to make sure I wired it correctly. I'm not 100% sure it makes a difference but I can tell you that my VSS works. My cruise control works and the speed shows up in my logs. What ECU are you using and what operating system is installed on it? There should be tags on the unit with that information. Are you able to log and are you sure nothing is being returned? I can tell you that the configuration in my ECU has been updated to account for the pulses I send to it with my 4 tooth reluctor. It may be helpful to determine the number of pulses per mile the code you have in your ECU is expecting and then compare it to the number of pulses/mi you're generating with your setup. It is possible the pulses you are generating are too low or too high to be recognized by the code in your ECU. I had that happen with my V6 ECU.  

Let me know if you have any other questions.

Hope you've been doing well.

Scott
Title: Re: LS4 Into an MGB
Post by: BWA on July 29, 2019, 02:55:06 PM
Thanks Scott for your reply.
I dug into the GM manual that my friend copied to do the electrical on my car.
The manual shows that the two wires at the ECU are purple and yellow which match the wires on the VSS.
Today I am going to switch the wires where I spliced the Nissan abs sensor and see if there is any change.
If nothing changes I am going to fab up a bracket and mount the GM VSS and make sure the wires are connected properly.
The reluctor wheel will be the mounting hub on the passenger side of the diff, this hub has six lugs.
The original setup had a reluctor wheel with 8 blades and it seemed to work better than it does now.
Hopefully it will work with six lugs.
I will keep you posted as to what happens.
Cheers
Byron