BritishV8 Forum

General Category => MG Sports Cars => Topic started by: nobogez07 on January 11, 2013, 04:04:02 PM

Title: Targa Top
Post by: nobogez07 on January 11, 2013, 04:04:02 PM
It's funny but after viewing so many conversions over the last 3 months or so even though everyone has their own canvas (i.e. car) to work with everyone is either a GT or rag top.

In an effort to add a unique apperance to my car I've thought of converting the body mods to include a Targa top.  I've never seen one in all the looking I've done but you all have seen so many more than I have.

Does anyone know of a B that's been converted to a Targa top?
Title: Re: Targa Top
Post by: RMO 699F on January 11, 2013, 08:37:59 PM
That's interesting, never thought of it before....lack of a b/c pillar would make it difficult on the roadster but I'm sure it could be done since there is an abundance of strength in the roadster tub...perhaps since the gt already has somewhat of a b pillar you could start there...major surgery there though since the roof is where the strength is...
Title: Re: Targa Top
Post by: nobogez07 on January 23, 2013, 09:10:21 AM
In looking at it closer, I think you'd almost have to make it such that it would become a B pillar.  I'm looking at it as a design que for both styling and to reduce wind noise while on long road trips.  Can't decide if it should be a T-top or a single top but ultimately it must seal the back edge of the roll up windows to be effective.

The beauty if it works is more storage space and an open top to enjoy sommer driving.  Living in South Dakota we don't get much of that so a solid top that keeps the warmth in is a bonus!!!

My car came with a roll bar which got me on to the idea.  One of the concerns I have is the importance of the solid pannel between the boot and the passenger compartment.  I'm not sure how much frame rigidity is based in that panel but to really gain additional storage and function, i'd like that to come out.  I think I could X brace it to return some strength.

Though the motor isn't completed yet, I'm pretty sure I'll be around the 275-310 HP at the wheels with relative torque numbers and rigidity may be an issue!!  I don't know the anwser on this and I hope someone out there who has more experience can provide some guidance.
Title: Re: Targa Top
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on January 23, 2013, 11:14:41 AM
Triumph had a top with a rear section that bolted on and a removable top panel which could also be replaced with a soft panel. Is that what you are thinking of?

Jim
Title: Re: Targa Top
Post by: RMO 699F on January 23, 2013, 05:33:24 PM
1Triumph_TR4_Surrey_Top_1.jpg
1Triumph_TR4_Surrey_Top_2.jpg
1Triumph_TR4_Surrey_Top_3.jpg
1Triumph_TR4_Surrey_Top_4.jpg
Title: Re: Targa Top
Post by: nobogez07 on January 23, 2013, 10:37:47 PM
Jim
I haven't seen that before but it's similar to what I was thinking of.  When drawing it up, I took the design style from the old Porsche 914 with the flat glass rear window.  This Triumph style does address my concern with the large open area where the soft top folds into.

It's a que worth consideration!!
Title: Re: Targa Top
Post by: flitner on January 24, 2013, 11:11:43 PM
Interesting idea! The thing that will be tough is the transfer of the rounded off windows vs the way the Triumph is. Maybe two small sections that fill the void when it is installed, then when it comes off the car these fold in or slip out of a channel.

Working on ideas for my steel hard top, similar brainstorming going on.
Title: Re: Targa Top
Post by: RMO 699F on January 25, 2013, 11:31:58 AM
One way around the rear B/C pilar section fabrication dilema might be a soft window approach similar to some older Porsche 911 targas and if I remember Lancia had a clever soft window that folded down in the mid 70's. I like this idea because the soft window could be removed/folded down to allow mucho air to flow through through the rear B/C pillar piece making for a much more pleasant open air experience.
On the plus side of the 914 style targa it was a very pleasant experience with the targa off and normal conversations were very easy at 65 mph.
Title: Re: Targa Top
Post by: RMO 699F on January 26, 2013, 11:19:17 AM
Lancia Targa top with folding rear window
lanciatarga1.jpg
lanciatarga2.jpg
Title: Re: Targa Top
Post by: nobogez07 on February 06, 2013, 10:56:22 PM
John
That's exactly what I was concerned with!!  The rounded windows on the B make for some interesting engineering issues.

I like the approach Lancia took!  I don't want to recreate a GT though.  The whole point for me is to reduce the wind noise of a rag top but still have the open air atributes.

I have a CNC plasma cutter but I worry that the kerf will be difficult to get right.  That won't stop me though!!  The plan now is to do the base in aluminum sheet and wrap with fiberglass.  It won't have the strength of a roll bar but should be strong enough to fit an ajoining top to.

The devil is always in the details!!  I have a fiberglass company who makes MGB fenders across the street.  We've started work on how to build a kit that could be added to a ragtop.  Hopefully mine will be the first of many to come.
Title: Re: Targa Top
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on February 07, 2013, 08:32:11 AM
Sounds like a good start Doug. I have a Parish Plastics hard top that I haven't used much in recent years, mostly because it is awkward to move around. A hoop would make it convenient to add either a rear window section or a top roof panel or both, as well as possibly a fine mesh vertical screen within the hoop for wind control. That Lancia design has potential, though it might need to be abbreviated a little to where it looks more like a roll hoop (and possibly a roll bar could be concealed under it). I like where this is going.

Jim
Title: Re: Targa Top
Post by: Moderator on February 08, 2013, 11:07:22 AM
QuoteThe rounded windows on the B make for some interesting engineering issues.

Will GT glass fit in a roadster door?
Title: Targa Top
Post by: nobogez07 on February 08, 2013, 11:07:56 AM
 -- moved topic --
Title: Re: Targa Top
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on February 08, 2013, 01:58:07 PM
It will fit Curtis, but of course it is taller. Not sure exactly how much, and the GT trim caps may be there to cover the extra height.

Jim
Title: Re: Targa Top
Post by: NCtim on February 08, 2013, 05:03:13 PM
Hey Doug,

Definitely keep this idea alive. You may have a market if you can come up with a successful design. Like Mike, my first thought was the TR4 top. Someone makes a similar top for Miatas. I've only seen one on the road in passing, thought it was really cool and instantly reminded me of the Triumph.

Tim
Title: Re: Targa Top
Post by: NCtim on February 08, 2013, 05:06:06 PM
Check out this link, someone made their own:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vw1e7N0GELw

Tim
Title: Re: Targa Top
Post by: Moderator on February 08, 2013, 06:26:47 PM
That cut-up Miata hardtop is neat. However, my thoughts turned to all the discussions here and elsewhere about head trauma caused by contact with roll hoops and cages. The corner where fiberglass meets door glass may be a little close.
Title: Re: Targa Top
Post by: roverman on February 08, 2013, 06:43:12 PM
Doug, You might compare dimensions of the 914 targa. I might be easier to modify the pillar and f-glass top, than building from scratch. You might also consider an MGB roaster lift-off hartop, of a style you like, for a place to start. I went this route with a non-oem  hard top, for my Jensen Healey. It will be heavily modded, later-on, but for now, much better than the rag top. I have seen the "PT Cruiser convertable" roll hoop used in other cars. Perhaps some of those parts ? Good Luck, roverman.
Title: Re: Targa Top
Post by: Robert J on February 08, 2013, 09:53:35 PM
I am totally on board with the Targa top idea...mostly because I want to see it. :)  BUT, have you considered just putting a windscreen on the roll bar behind the driver?  This cuts down on wind noise significantly.
Title: Re: Targa Top
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on February 09, 2013, 01:24:49 AM
Maybe Dave needs to be in on this discussion, it seems right up his alley. I'd picture something in fiberglass along the lines of a simple hoop around 4-6" wide at the top and tapering down a bit larger at the bottom to a secure attachment, perhaps using the stock bow socket and some sort of sturdy tensioner, and just following the rear edge of the window glass all the way across. It could be made with a top panel that dropped into the front channel and latched to the windshield, and either a hard or soft rear panel. Done right it could be possible to store both pieces in the trunk. A soft panel for the top could also be an option.
 
The hoop could be a sturdy skin with a rollbar recess and/or a padded inner cover. I like the lines of the Parish Plastics top. I realize not everyone likes them but they do have a nice curve across the top as well as very good headroom.

Jim
Title: Re: Targa Top
Post by: rficalora on February 09, 2013, 08:51:04 AM
I like Jim's idea.  And maybe the curve needed for the roadster window corners could be incorporated into the removable top panel instead of the hoop.
Title: Re: Targa Top
Post by: NCtim on February 09, 2013, 03:10:36 PM
"That cut-up Miata hardtop is neat. However, my thoughts turned to all the discussions here and elsewhere about head trauma caused by contact with roll hoops and cages. The corner where fiberglass meets door glass may be a little close."

My thoughts also, Curtis. Still someone tried.
Title: Re: Targa Top
Post by: nobogez07 on February 10, 2013, 11:58:31 AM
Jim - you must be clarvoint (sp).  That's exactly what I had in mind!!  You also included the considerations that need to be taken concerning having a top that can be fixed in place.

From an engineering point of view, the B-GT side glass (being more of a 90 degree edge) sure would make things easier in terms of getting a proper seal without jumping through a million design hoops to get there.  I hadn't considered that option but with it being able to be done, I'm going to certainly look into it!!!  

I've drawn the base frame up idea on a CAD program and with some slight mods to the two mounting points behind the doors I should have the stiffness required to get the job done.  As I'd indicated earlier, the frame would be made with 0.090" aluminum sheet and the final shape would be accomplished with fiberglass.

Thanks everyone for the great input!  I hope the outcome is as good as the idea!!

Doug
Title: Re: Targa Top
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on February 10, 2013, 08:13:17 PM
Keep us posted Doug, it'll be a popular option if you pull it off.

Jim
Title: Re: Targa Top
Post by: harv8 on February 10, 2013, 09:39:03 PM
It's amazing how many mods people have made to their MGBs!!!
I just saw this car listed for sale locally here in Ontario.
TargaTop3.jpg
Title: Re: Targa Top
Post by: waterbucket on February 11, 2013, 01:23:29 PM
In the 1970's the Lenham Motor Company (I think that was their full name) produced a large number of hardtops for nearly all the MG and Triumph sports cars, one of the designs was a Targa top for the MG B. The design was very similar to the 914, the only problem was that the  squarish design did not sit happily on the curvaceous B.
Philip
Title: Re: Targa Top
Post by: djw090 on February 19, 2013, 03:27:32 AM
You used to be able to buy a targa top for an MGB. There are some pictures on the following website.

http://www.mgnuts.com/hardtops/mgb/
Title: Re: Targa Top
Post by: BlownMGB-V8 on February 19, 2013, 08:15:50 AM
Supremely ugly isn't it?

Jim
Title: Re: Targa Top
Post by: RMO 699F on February 19, 2013, 10:52:44 AM
Ah yes, the Lenham Company, was located in Harrietsham in Kent...most highly revered for making the Arkley front and rear section for John Britten :-)