In Rob Ficalora's post about his car he complained about scraping his exhaust on a speed bump. http://forum.britishv8.org/read.php?2,21683 . I showed a couple pictures of some oval pipe I made to gain ground clearance for the exhaust pipes on my car and said I would show how to make them - so here goes.
First you need to make a section of oval pipe to go under whatever obstruction you have to clear. Get a piece of pipe half the diameter of the exhaust pipe and slit it lengthwise so you have two half circles. You then need to weld some 16 ga sheet on the top and bottom to form the oval pipe. The width of the center piece can be calculated to duplicate the the area of the main pipe plus about 10% to compensate for any flow loss the transition may create. This is the calculation for a 3" exhaust pipe that flattens to a 1 1/2" high oval:
Area of 3" pipe 1.5 x 1.5 x 3.14 = 7.06 sq"
Area of 1.5" pipe .75 x .75 x 3.14 = 1.76 sq"
Area of center rectangle 7.06 - 1.76 = 5.3 sq"
Width of center rectangle 5.3 / 1.5 = 3.53" plus 10% = 3.88" or about 3 7/8"
The following drawing shows why I don't make drawings for the stuff I make. This just to give you the concept and is not to scale nor is the perspective correct.
Transitionpattern007.jpg
Now to the trasnition pieces. You now know that the width of the flat is 3 7/8". You want to have the bottom transition go halfway up the 1 1/2" tubing sections on each side of the oval or 1.5 x 3.14 / 4 ( 1 3/16" = one fourth of the circumference). You also want the bottom transition to go halfway up the 3" main pipe. Make a cardboard pattern (I like cereal boxes or the backing of a legal pad) that is 3 7/8 + 1 3/16" + 1 3/16" (6 1/4") on one end and 3" x 3.14 / 2 (4 3/4") on the other. It should be shaped something like this.
Transitionpattern001.jpg
The lines you see are break lines for bending. This can be done in an actual sheetmetal brake or by bending by hand in a vise. You want the ends to be pointing up at 90 degrees and look like this.
Transitionpattern006.jpg
With the piece sitting on the bench, the ends will not be perpendicuclar so square them up on a belt or disc sander (or you can file them). With your transition piece, main pipe and oval pipe sitting on the table - tack the parts together so the bottom of all pieces are in the same plane.
Transitionpattern010.jpg
To make the top transition piece, take another piece of cardboard and wrap it around trimming so you get all the edges to line up and you have a piece similar to but not the same as the bottom piece. Cut out the shape in 16 ga sheet and lay out bend lines the same way as you did for the bottom. Bend it up and it should fit with some minor tweaking with a hammer and dolly. Weld it up and you just gained half the exhaust pipe diameter in ground clearance. You can see on my pipe that you can also change the in and out angles by changing the angle of the lower transition to the oval section.
Very nice directions Jim. I'm sure those'll be useful.
JB
Jim,
I like your work there with the custom exhaust. I believe you used 2" radius and 6" radius bent pipe to create your flattened curved piece. Where did you source those different radii pipes?
(There are more good photos of this exhaust work in Jim's project journal: http://forum.britishv8.org/read.php?13,7581)
Summit has them
Here's another approach to more exhaust clearance that's not quite as elegant as Jim's:
(http://i55.tinypic.com/35nbn8x.jpg)
Here is another option.
http://ovalexhaust.com/
Let's not forget the Hillbilly Technique; a 2X4 & a floor jack. ;-)
Ok, question for ya'lls collective wisdom -- what size to use. Reading up & looking at the how it was done articles, I think 2 1/4" exhaust for my mild street cam'd (E303 cam) should be sufficient (seems like most of the 302's on the site use 2 1/2" but talking with Ford Racing's tech & Summit Tech, 2 1/4" is what they all recommended & that's what Graham & a couple of others have so I think it'll be good). Question is when you go to oval pipe, does it flow the same or do you need to upsize to account for the (presumably reduced) flow from the pipe not being round?
Rob
I always add about 10% to the area of an oval over a round. I don't have any scientific basis for doing so but a round pipe has the minimum circumference for a given cross section area so the parasitic drag from the wall area is minimal - so I add 10%.area for an oval. My ovals are 1/2 the height of the round tube so if you want to make the ovals flatter you might want to add a little more cross section area. It's all Kentucky windage guesstimates on my part.
Jim
I was curious so I called "Dr. Gas Exhaust" over lunch. Figured they're the experts. Their tech rep said that the flow characteristics are only minimally different -- single digit for sure & in the range of a few % points. In my case, (302, mild street cam, etc.) I'm at the edge of 2 1/4" vs. 2 1/2" so he suggested upsizing to 2 1/2" would probably be preferable. The resulting flow would be about in the middle of round 2 1/4" vs. round 2 1/2" and the 2 1/2" oval pipe is only 1/8" taller than oval 2 1/4" so probably worth the compromise. Net - your Blackwood err, umm Kentucky windage assessment sounds like it was right on.
I'm no expert, but I'm very skeptical 2.5" pipes would perform noticeably better than 2.25" for a 302. How often will you drive at wide open throttle, where the difference shows up? Big pipes be a little heavier and a little harder to package. Bends will be larger, etc. They'll cost more.
If you're just trying to get pipes closer to the floorboards, maybe you should be thinking about modifying the crossmembers. If you notch and reinforce the crossmembers, your pipes can be moved right up close under the seats. This is the only photo I have of what I did. I wish it showed the tubular pass-throughs better.
(http://www.britishv8.org/MG/CurtisJacobson/CurtisJacobson-ED.jpg)
Thanks Curtis. I'm going to have to redo my exhaust one way or the other. I have compounded errors.
1. I liked the sound of Steve Carrick's car so I sort of copied his. He has chambered exhaust -- 50 or 52" on each side if I recall. I wanted it to be a little quieter than his so I ordered mine @ 54" each side.
2. I went with the IRS which, by itself isn't an "error" but the lower control arms are "wider" than an axle tube -- net, the chambered exhausts extend a little past the LCA's forcing the exhaust tubes to be lower than otherwise would be needed.
3. I may have gone a little bigger on the chambered exhausts than Steve. I got 2 1/2" units -- that's the inner tube. Add about an inch to that for the outer tubes so my exhaust tubes are about 3 1/2" diameter. (Not to mention that I didn't know at the time that the bigger diameter also makes them louder -- defeating the objective of the longer tubes.)
4. Because the chambered exhausts are so long, the H-tube is under the front half of the tranny & has to dip down in the middle to clear...
Net all adds up to two or three inches of precious wasted space.
They're also way heavier than I realized before I got them.
I think it'll be easier to switch out the exhaust than it would be to try & adjust what I have but, I haven't looked closely yet. I've fixed the shifter piece that was blocking me from getting into 1st & 3rd & I flipped the fan around last night. Plan to test the cooling again tonight & do a few other things to make it more drivable while I research what to order for exhaust. But, sounds like 2 1/4" round or 2 1/4" or 2 1/2" oval will be the ticket.
Rob
Don't feel bad about having to re-do the exhaust, I threw away/repurposed everything from the header connection back to get mine up where I wanted it. Financially it hurts at the time you do it but at least you won't swear at yourself everytime you go out of your driveway for as long as you have your car.
Original exhaust system
Exhaustearly.JPG
Latest exhaust system less the rear section with the muffler
Exhaust022.jpg
Here's the muffler section
Exhaust006.jpg
In the muscle car era Detroit was using 2-1/4" duals on all their performance small blocks and lots of them had very outstanding performance. Plus they were considerably longer. I don't think what you might gain with the 2-1/2" tubes will justify the aggravation. As for how to route the system for best clearance especially with the IRS, the exhaust on the MG-Roadmaster is a great example of what can be achieved. There, Dave VanWyck routed the tailpipes up along the frame rails and over the half-shafts and it was all tucked in real tight. I'm sure there are some photos in that thread, probably from the Virginia meet where we had it up on the lift. Even on that engine it seems to me we ran 2-1/4" tubes, and the tailpipes might have even been 2", which would be consistent with what Detroit was doing. I realize modern theory is that going big all the way back is helpful, but the real question is, does the benefit justify the inconvenience? Personally I don't think so.
As for smashing your tube, there is a simple formula. Calculate the area of the new circle size for the smashed pipe (new radius of the sides) using cobbler (pies are square) and the area of the rectangle between the sides as L x H and add them up. Then run cobbler on the 2-1/4 and 2-1/2" size round tube and compare. My Ky windage suggests it's more than 10% but that's just a guess.
JB
Looking through the April issue of Super Chevy, John Parsons had a formula for calculating the horsepower that a tube can support.
"Engine requires about 2.2 CFM per horsepower, and exhaust gas flows about 115CFM per square inch."
"Assuming 1,400 hp/2( since there are two exhaust pipes) means we have 700 HP per exhaust pipe. Multiply by 2.2 cfm/ per horsepower and we see we need 1,440 cfm. Divide that by 115 cfm/ square inch, and we need 12.5 square inches of pipe area. The area of a 4 inch round pipe is equal to ( pi * r ( squared )= 3.14 x 2 ( squared) = 12.6 square inches. So a 4 inch exhaust is just barely big enough to support 1,400 HP "
The article was about building up a set of SS headers for a mega horsepower engine. Very good article and some interesting food for thought.
Bill
Did he say what a muffler does to the calculation?
Rob,
Don't know if this helps at all, but take a look at the Spintech Cruisers I'm using on the Healey. Only 2 1/4" tall: http://forum.britishv8.org/read.php?13,8264
Here's a link to another article from February, 2009 Super Chevy magazine by David Vizard. He's published quite a bit of stuff about exhaust systems.
http://www.superchevy.com/technical/engines_drivetrain/exhaust/0505phr_exh/index.html
Good info Phil.
Rick, any idea what the spintech's sound like yet?
What you have to consider is that with these big exhaust pipes you are in the area of diminishing returns. What "...barely big enough to support 1400hp..." really means is that going any larger brings no significant increase in power while going smaller gives small but gradually increasing losses. But how much horsepower do you need? Remember, it is torque which does the real work. Horsepower only comes into play at the top end. So in the real world it's only in a drag race taking it to redline that you will be able to tell the difference. Again going back to the muscle car era it was standard for a 300 hp 350 cu.in. engine to exhaust through a 2-1/4" exhaust with a 2" tailpipe. Switching to duals would allow you to pick up maybe 20 hp which is a less than 7% gain. Certainly significant and worth doing as many of us discovered, but we were doubling the flow area from 4 to 8 square inches. Going to a 2-1/4" tailpipe is therefore going to net you probably less than a whopping 1% improvement. Plus the shorter overall length compared to those cars might net another 1% if you are real lucky. So now you really are into diminishing returns. At this point how much gain is to be had in going to 2-1/2"? If you do the math it would seem like you'd have almost a 25% improvement based on flow area but this is deceptive and does not automatically convert into horsepower increases because we're dealing with a logarithmic curve. Plus the actual gain is less than 2 square inches. Even if we weren't into the diminishing returns area that would only be good for 3-1/2% and as it is it may only be good for 1% or less. So on a 300 hp engine is an extra 3 hp worth the trouble? Not to me. In a 2400 lb car 300 hp is silly power. That much of a difference is only significant if you are racing the car on a consistent basis.
JB
Thanks Jim. Earlier replies already convinced me to go w/2 1/4". I'm now just sorting out the pieces I need. I know I need about 10' of straight pipe, 2 90* bends to make an X-pipe (I'm actually thinking that'll be faster/easier to make than an H-pipe), and then some other bends &/or transitions. I'll need to put the car up on stands to figure out if I can go from my headers to the X in a straight shot & from the X to the back where I'll transition back to round in another straight shot. If so, I just need 4 oval to round transitions. The oval bends are expensive so if I need any, I want to figure out the right angles before I order -- they come in 15*, 30* 45*, 60*, 75*, 80*, & 90* and most of those in both 3" & 4.5" centerline bend radius.
Rob,
If you're going stainless, have a look on Columbia's web site. They seem to have a good selection of products and good prices:
http://www.mandrel-bends.com/catalog/
Ken
Thanks Ken. I'm planning to go with aluminized steel -- once I get it set up I'm going to use Eastwood's ceramic coating on it so no point in springing for SS.
Rob
Make sure you post pictures as you go. Let me know if I can help you with anything
Jim
Rob, Check out Keith Tanner's LS GT exhaust. Not IRS but,centered tank. Also check out Thrush website for mufflers. Look at the Hush Thrush SuperTurbo ,they have a mellow deep tone. Not the welded,chambered,baffled type(Flomaster clone)which is louder.
img_7191.jpg
Rob,
Haven't got the Spintech's installed yet. A couple of people that used them on SBF Cobra replicas told me they're quiet with a healthy sound when you get on it. I searched in vain for a sound clip for them. I hope they're not too quiet. OTOH, I hope they're not too loud either.
Bill Jacobson exhaust picture:
frontend.jpg
Yeah, Bill's is probably closer to what I'm thinking for this next pass. I priced oval pipe -- before I spring for that, I'm going to spend some time under the car (this evening) to decide if 2 1/4" round with the changes that will affod me (vs. the long chambered exhaust tubes I currently have) will be enough. The oval would be cool, but I'm thinking my real problem is that my current exhaust hangs about 1 1/2" lower than it needs to as a starting point & on top of that the chambered tube lengths drive the H-pipe to cross the tranny at a lower spot than it would need to if I could move it back further.
Rob
Are you thinking of making the pipe cutouts in the welded in crossmember wider to accomodate the flattened oval pipe so you could run the oval pipe from the front all the way to behind the battery boxes? If you reweld the piece in the crossmember with a series of MIG tacks strung together it won't screw up the paint very much and you could retouch it easily. You could then merge the ovals into an "X" pipe or have an "H" pipe (oval) just behind the crossmember. . It looks like the highest ground clearance path under your IRS is just inboard of the inner pickup points of the lower control arms. You could make up some triangular cross section pipe in that area to tuck it up even further. If you rubber mount the pipes to the tubular IRS structure you could use minimal clearance and shouldn't have rattle problems. You could then make a sharp bend outward and have mufflers beside the fuel tank with another mount at the exhaust tips.
I haven't decided that yet Jim but that's what I've been thinking about. Until I jack up the car this evening & get under it I don't know for sure how I'm going to run it. I'm thinking I'm going to cut some strips of cardboard to the width of the pipe & tape it to the bottom to sort out the routing & bends. But, basic idea is is to run it fairly tight along the bottom to the battery box area... from there I need to look closer but I think I can turn up there & then go through the IRS between either the LCA & axle or the UCA & axle. Currently it runs under the leading edge of the LCA & then turns up & back from there between the LCA & axle... If I can turn the new tube up before the LCA I'll gain a 2-3" of clearance there (depending on oval or round). I hope to sort this out tonight or tomorrow. After tomorow I won't get a chance to touch it again until next Friday.
Rob, did you look at the shots of the tail pipes on the MG-Roadmaster? They are completely out of the way and go *over* the axle.
JB
Went quiet for about a week -- was in Mexico on a mission trip building a house. Lots of fun (http://cbcbridges.wordpress.com/). Back now & working on the car this weekend.
I decided to go with 2 1/4" oval; ordered the parts yesterday. Took my exhaust off to make measurements to figure out what bend angles I needed & when I reinstalled I was able to pull the existing exhuast up about 1". Still too low but at least it's a little higher till the parts come in. With the oval pipe I'll gain almost another 2" -- close to 3" overall gain vs. prior.
Jim B - I did look at the roadmaster & it looks good. I have an upper control arm (vs. the Jag set up that uses the 1/2 shafts as the UCA) so there's less room. The way mine runs now it goes under the leading edge of the LCS & then turns up & goes between the LCA & 1/2 shaft. That's the best I could do at the time because the chambered exhausts extended about 1-2" past the LCA leading edge. When I re-do it, I'll be able to turn up at the battery shelf & then go through the same area or maybe even above 1/2 shafts; will have to see. I'm planning to make everything up to that turn up & then have a muffler shop bend the pieces that'll go through there. There's a shop nearby with a mandrel bender.
Jim N - Not sure if I'm going to modify the cross member cut-outs, but probably.
just read through all this and just want to say that in my 2008 mustang v6 4.0l automatic ,ford saw fit to install a 2 1/2" exhaust system from the manifolds back to the single muffler.of course i removed the rear section and replaced it with the gt version of the exhaust which is also 2 1/2" and used the gt mufflers.i'd say some people finally learned something about exhaust flow in the last 30 or so years or at least i would hope so.what works on paper does NOT always compute as far as sound goes especially on a street car.the difference between 2.25 and 2.5 inch exhaust is minimal as far as performance goes on a MILD engine but it does affect mpg and sound of the vehicle.i know of several guys who have redone their exaust systems on new stangs time and time again trying to find just the right sound with no drone.drone is an issue with the rear mounted mufflers on these cars.also it can be increased by having an equal exhaust system on a car,meaning if the one side is exactly the same as the other as far as length goes it will set up a resonance and drone.the anwser is to offset one muffler to the other in an undercar muffler layout.having the mufflers at the back there is not much that can be done about it.some guys use x pipes ,some use h pipes and some run true seperated duals with no connection between the two banks.i myself run an x pipe with stock gt muffs and have no problem.for those of you looking for good muffler that sounds great without a huge price try the 2005-2010 mustang gt takeoff mufflers found on ebay .they come with a nice stainless tip already and are free flowing.in fact even the gt 500 used the same mufflers in the early production .the gt500's now use a different muffler.they are shaped to go over a rear axle and are 2.5" in dia. inlet and outlet.that's all ,just thought i would throw that up there.
Rob,
You may already be aware, the Spintechs can be order with oval inlet/outlets.
Rick
Quote: Are you thinking of making the pipe cutouts in the welded in crossmember wider to accomodate the flattened oval pipe so you could run the oval pipe from the front all the way to behind the battery boxes?[/I]
I am going to be doing this. Am thinking I'll make a U channel (out of 16Ga) & pie cut the sides of the U in order to enable bending it. Is that strong enough or do I need to do something additional to reinforce?
U-Channel...
CrossmemberExhaustclearance.jpg
Rob
I'm sure 16 ga would be strong enough but if you are feeling squeamish you could make the same thing in 3 pieces out of 1/8". By using 3 pieces you could make the side plates much larger and that is what carries the load. Drill some holes in the plates so you can do some plug welds as well as the perimeter welds.
I think what I'm going to do is make the piece the way I showed it... but also another 16Ga piece on each side that gets sandwiched between the existing cross member vertical face & the piece shown above. I'll bend it 90* where it meets the floor like the existing cross member. I think that should provide enough rigidity.
Hey Rob,
The only function of that X member seems to be the termination of the front frame boxes.
If it were my car I would remove whatever portion that is required right up to the floor level.
Taper and cap the ends nicely and call the underside done.
To make up for lost strength nobody said you can't have a x member inside the car.
Weld in a 1" x 2" tube from rocker box to trans tunnel on both sides and your better than new.
Even gives you a nice strong mounting place for the seats.
Hope thats of some use
Cheers
Fred
That's an interesting idea Fred. I have some box pieces I made that raise my seats about 1" in the back & 1 1/2" in the front... this would eliminate those & serve both purposes.